Ya/Nay - Would you have traded a 3rd + conditional for Lynch

[pbmax]

Voted yes, but did not know he is reported to be one misstep away from visiting Johnny Jolly. That would change the calculus, though probably more about a future contract than this year. Unless he has a pending appeal that could be adjudicated during the season.

Otherwise, the only thing I would fear is fitting into the season and doing it quickly.

[Smidgeon]

He spent a second round pick on Jackson, and he couldn’t spend a 3rd for Lynch? And how do you know it would take a 3rd. Maybe the Seahwaks were just more aggressive and the Bills went with their offer? Maybe TT was only offering a 5th round pick and they didn't feel like wasting time with him. Seattle just got a great trade IMO. A 24 year old back and an ex pro bowler for a 4th and what another low rounder?

We saved our 4th last time when we didn't trade for Moss and who did we pick Barbre?

It would have taken a third because there's no way, in conventional circles, that Seattle will finish with a better record (and a worse draft position) than Green Bay.

[PaCkFan_n_MD]

He spent a second round pick on Jackson, and he couldn’t spend a 3rd for Lynch? And how do you know it would take a 3rd. Maybe the Seahwaks were just more aggressive and the Bills went with their offer? Maybe TT was only offering a 5th round pick and they didn't feel like wasting time with him. Seattle just got a great trade IMO. A 24 year old back and an ex pro bowler for a 4th and what another low rounder?

We saved our 4th last time when we didn't trade for Moss and who did we pick Barbre?

It would have taken a third because there's no way, in conventional circles, that Seattle will finish with a better record (and a worse draft position) than Green Bay.

Yeah I see your point. Still I think a 3rd would have been a good trade. Oh well, its too late to worry about that now. I doubt he will trade for anyone else so I hope Starks makes us forget about Lynch.

[MichiganPackerFan]

I have to say, I'm very disappointed in how the vote was set up. I was led to believe that I would be able to vote "Ya" or "Nay" and when I got to the vote I was only offered a "Yes" or "No". Bait and Switch.

[The Leaper]

For a late 3rd...sign me up as a yes. Lynch is a bona-fide talent...he's got some character risk for sure, but the fact that he and Rodgers know each other well would've smoothed that over a lot for me. Lynch would've come to play in Green Bay.