CHARLIE PEPRAH - STARTER - REST OF SEASON

[gbpackfan]

I don't care if Bigby comes back this week, Peprah played really, really well today. Wow - two plays stand out. The big hit and the pass break up towards the end of the game. Good Lord those were great plays. I have been really impressed with his play. So, what do you guys think. Bigby or Peprah?

[Joemailman]

Peprah. He really surprised me this year. Next year the Packers will have as good a trio of safeties (Collins, Burnett, Peprah) as you'll find in the league.

[mission]

Peprah, no doubt. Bigby hasn't earned anything.

[Joemailman]

Well, I see Atari Bigby has voted.

[Lurker64]

If Bigby has any of that "flying around like a crazy man, putting the fear of god into people" that he did against the Seahawks in the playoffs, we can certainly use some of that down the stretch (in some situations, Dom likes to play 3 safeties in the nickel).

But I think that Peprah hasn't given anybody any reason to bench him.

[packerbacker1234]

Peprah, no doubt. Bigby hasn't earned anything.

Nor has Peprah. Bigby has done everything Peprah did in this game and then some throughout his career. He has also caused the most turnovers per play in packers history. I'm not saying you simply hand the job back to Bigby, but you have to give him a shot to earn it back as well.

I really never understood all the Bigby hate in the past. Guy has been one of the most underrated safties in my opinion throughout hte league. He seems to always be causing havoc. He doesn't have the speed at times that you like, but he is sound and usually always in the right position. He makes occasional big hits and forces turnovers at a rate higher than any packer on the roster.

Peprah played well in one game. Bigby has played well for most of his career. Remember the staunch turn arounds our defenses made int he past when he stepped on the field? He never was given credit for that.

I say you let bigby earn it back. IF he can't perform to the level we saw out of him in the past, then you just have him be the backup.

[The Leaper]

Stay with Peprah...Bigby won't be in midseason form right away anyway.

[mission]

Peprah has played well in more than one game this season. Not sure which Packers you're watching 1234.

[Zool]

Peprah has played well in more than one game this season. Not sure which Packers you're watching 1234.

Debating with 1234 is akin to clapping with 1 hand.

[Lurker64]

Peprah has played well in more than one game this season. Not sure which Packers you're watching 1234.

Debating with 1234 is akin to clapping with 1 hand.

The sound of it is of dubious philosophical status?

[Bossman641]

Gotta stick with Peprah. He appears to be getting better every game.

I don't think this poll becomes official until Skinbasket weighs in on it though.

[Brandon494]

Peprah without question.

[mmmdk]

Pep, Pep, hurrah - Peprah :P

[bobblehead]

If Bigby has any of that "flying around like a crazy man, putting the fear of god into people" that he did against the Seahawks in the playoffs, we can certainly use some of that down the stretch (in some situations, Dom likes to play 3 safeties in the nickel).

But I think that Peprah hasn't given anybody any reason to bench him.

+1 for the voice of reason.

[SkinBasket]

If Bigby has any of that "flying around like a crazy man, putting the fear of god into people" that he did against the Seahawks in the playoffs, we can certainly use some of that down the stretch (in some situations, Dom likes to play 3 safeties in the nickel).

LOL. How many years ago was that?