The thing that always confused me is this: why did so many people think the GM needed replacing?
In general, in sports you only replace someone if you can upgrade the team by doing so (or it would be too costly to retain his services). If a better Punter is available, you can replace your Punter. If your first baseman is overpaid and underperforming, you can try to replace him with a cheaper player. If your coach reliably fails to get the team ready, and there is a (theoretically) better coach available you you can upgrade that position.
But why do we believe we are all so quick to judge the GM? Certainly, the buck stops there... but we don't have nearly enough information to conclude that the GM "isn't doing a good job" (except using the long-view, since every GM will miss on picks and every GM will make some mistakes in free agency) and we absolutely have no clue who we would replace him with that would be better. I mean, seriously... if Ted Thompson ascended to a higher plane of being and left his physical body tomorrow to travel through space and solve crimes, do we have any clue who would be in line to replace him?
In general, in sports you only replace someone if you can upgrade the team by doing so (or it would be too costly to retain his services). If a better Punter is available, you can replace your Punter. If your first baseman is overpaid and underperforming, you can try to replace him with a cheaper player. If your coach reliably fails to get the team ready, and there is a (theoretically) better coach available you you can upgrade that position.
But why do we believe we are all so quick to judge the GM? Certainly, the buck stops there... but we don't have nearly enough information to conclude that the GM "isn't doing a good job" (except using the long-view, since every GM will miss on picks and every GM will make some mistakes in free agency) and we absolutely have no clue who we would replace him with that would be better. I mean, seriously... if Ted Thompson ascended to a higher plane of being and left his physical body tomorrow to travel through space and solve crimes, do we have any clue who would be in line to replace him?



Comment