A Template for Sitton's Contract

[Scott Campbell]

I guess mine went over your head as well. Just because he won the award doesn't make him a better guard than Mankins.

Yep, it did manage to go over your head. Perhaps you should reread it.

[pbmax]

It's prorated across all years of the contract, assuming he's on the roster IIRC.

I think proration is limited to either 5 or six years.

[mission]

Sitton doesn't even have a pro bowl appearance. I know that doesnt speak to how good a guy is but it does matter when signing an extension mid season. I dont see this contract being a template for the 4th round pick. No way. 6-7 mil IMO

[pbmax]

Read This, Stop Talking Past One Another

The NFL Alumni awards for 2010:

Quarterback: Philip Rivers, Chargers
Running back: Maurice Jones-Drew, Jaguars
Wide receiver: Roddy White, Falcons
Tight end: Jason Witten, Cowboys
Offensive line: Josh Sitton, Packers
Defensive lineman: Ndamukong Suh, Lions
Linebacker: Patrick Willis, 49ers
Defensive back: Aqib Talib, Buccaneers
Special teams: Devin Hester, Bears
Spirit Award: Felix Jones, Cowboys
Coach of the Year: Todd Haley, Chiefs
Player of the Year: Troy Polamalu, Steelers

Its a list of good players to be sure, but there are signs (such as Polamalu's award and Hester's) that indicate they weren't paying full attention. There is kind of a career effect here, as MJD is a great back but did not have a great season compared to some others. Talib at CB seems strange too. At first I thought they nominated someone from each division, but 6 of 9 positions are from the NFC.

[mission]

I guess the NFL Alumni association must have a heavy Packer bias.


"Josh Sitton wins Offensive Lineman of the Year

Josh Sitton has been named 2010 Offensive Lineman of the Year by the NFL Alumni Association."

I love Sitton and think he's a big time guard, but that award really doesn't count for anything besides forum fodder. Alumni association? Come on...

[mission]

Read This, Stop Talking Past One Another

The NFL Alumni awards for 2010:

Quarterback: Philip Rivers, Chargers
Running back: Maurice Jones-Drew, Jaguars
Wide receiver: Roddy White, Falcons
Tight end: Jason Witten, Cowboys
Offensive line: Josh Sitton, Packers
Defensive lineman: Ndamukong Suh, Lions
Linebacker: Patrick Willis, 49ers
Defensive back: Aqib Talib, Buccaneers
Special teams: Devin Hester, Bears
Spirit Award: Felix Jones, Cowboys
Coach of the Year: Todd Haley, Chiefs
Player of the Year: Troy Polamalu, Steelers

Its a list of good players to be sure, but there are signs (such as Polamalu's award and Hester's) that indicate they weren't paying full attention.

Isn't Talib the dude who's always getting arrested? I can think of tons of DBs I'd rather have.

[pbmax]

Isn't Talib the dude who's always getting arrested? I can think of tons of DBs I'd rather have.

Yes, that's him. He was also hurt in 2010 in Week 13. He is young and good, but not quite Revis or Asomugha. Its an odd list. Suh is a forward thinking pick and you cannot quibble with Willis. But Hester hasn't been the threat he used to be in 3 years.

Part of the problem was the selection process. It consisted of one old and tired former GM and coach, Bill Parcells, who couldn't even be moved to name Belicheck as a candidate for Coach of the Year. http://espn.go.com/blog/afceast/post...-elite-players

His list:

OFFENSE

Quarterback – Tom Brady (New England Patriots), Philip Rivers (San Diego Chargers), Aaron Rodgers (Green Bay Packers)

Running Back – Jamaal Charles (Kansas City Chiefs), Maurice Jones-Drew (Jacksonville Jaguars), Michael Turner (Atlanta Falcons)

Wide Receiver – Greg Jennings (Green Bay Packers), Reggie Wayne (Indianapolis Colts), Roddy White (Atlanta Falcons)

Tight End –Tony Gonzalez (Atlanta Falcons), Dustin Keller (New York Jets), Jason Witten (Dallas Cowboys)

Offensive Lineman – Jahri Evans (New Orleans Saints), Jake Long (Miami Dolphins), Josh Sitton (Green Bay Packers)

DEFENSE

Defensive Lineman – Ndamukong Suh (Detroit Lions), Kyle Williams (Buffalo Bills), Mario Williams (Houston Texans)

Linebacker – Clay Matthews (Green Bay Packers), Cameron Wake (Miami Dolphins), Patrick Willis (San Francisco 49ers)

Defensive Back – Troy Polamalu (Pittsburgh Steelers), Asante Samuel (Philadelphia Eagles), Aqib Talib (Tampa Bay Buccaneers)

SPECIAL TEAMS PLAYER

David Akers (Philadelphia Eagles), Dustin Colquitt (Kansas City Chiefs), Devin Hester (Chicago Bears)

COACH of the YEAR

Todd Haley (Kansas City Chiefs), Lovie Smith (Chicago Bears), Mike Smith (Atlanta Falcons)

PLAYER of the YEAR

Clay Matthews (Green Bay Packers), Troy Polamalu (Pittsburgh Steelers), Philip Rivers (San Diego Chargers)

The list and explanation is here: http://www.nflalumni.org/ArticleDeta...5/Default.aspx

[mission]

Sitton doesn't even have a pro bowl appearance. I know that doesnt speak to how good a guy is but it does matter when signing an extension mid season. I dont see this contract being a template for the 4th round pick. No way. 6-7 mil IMO

QFT

[smuggler]

We'll see on that. Sitton is better than Mankins, when you consider his age. He'll be a strong contender for All-Pro this season (w/ Mankins, Evans, and Nicks)