NFC North Quarterback Ratings 2011

[vince]

I think I still remember when 99.1 was really good.

[channtheman]

I think I still remember when 99.1 was really good.

Isn't it crazy? Guys like Stafford, Brady, Brees who are all having excellent years look average compared to Rodgers.

[gbgary]

Week 9


Aaron Rodgers 129.1 1st overall Last week: 125.7 - 1st overall
Matt Stafford 99.1 4th overall Last week: 99.1 - 5th overall
Jay Cutler 85.6 14th overall Last week: 84.0 - 15th overall
Donovan McNabb DNP 82.9 19th overall Last week: 82.9 - 17th overall

Christian Ponder Does Not Qualify 77.5 Last week 77.5

Can we just give Arod the trophy now?

Week 10:

Aaron Rodgers vs. Minnesota
Matt Stafford at Chicago
Jay Cutler vs. Detroit
Christian Ponder at Green Bay

I think I still remember when 99.1 was really good.

Isn't it crazy? Guys like Stafford, Brady, Brees who are all having excellent years look average compared to Rodgers.

yup. that is insane. AR is on a completely different level this season. hope it continues. lot's of interesting games this weekend. some tough ones to pick.

[Guiness]

Crazy is that it was 125 last week...and went up!

[channtheman]

Crazy is that it was 125 last week...and went up!

And the week before it went up 3-4 points as well.

[woodbuck27]

[QUOTE=Upnorth;626901]

I beleive we have mentioned that the internet is slow in Canada eh.

I knew we we're playing them sometime. Just
wasn't aware when I posted that, that they we're behind us.

[woodbuck27]

Aaron Rodgers ! Brialliant !! Utterly amazing. In a class by himself. Easily now, the BEST QB in the NFL. Putting up numbers over a short term stretch like I cannot re-call and we may never see again.

I'm enjoying it.

Enjoy it Packer fans.

Thank GOD he's a Green Bay Packer.

GO Aaron ... GO PACKERS !

[Upnorth]

So I think ARod is ahving one of the greatest seasons ever, however Brady's 2007 rating for the first 8 games was 130, then fell in the cold weather. I hope that does not happen to ARod but 5 of the remaining 8 games are pretty much garrenteed to be shitty weather. That is the only thing that can slow down this O.

[Joemailman]

Week 10


Aaron Rodgers 130.7 1st overall Last week: 129.1 1st overall
Matt Stafford 89.9 9th overall Last week: 99.1 4th overall
Jay Cutler 84.4 12th overall Last week: 85.6 14th overall
Christian Ponder 69.8 DNQ-Would be 31st overall Last week 77.5

At some point, it will be tough for Rodgers to keep getting better. Stafford had a real drop. Cutler didn't need to do much. Ponder had no chance against Packers.

Week 11:

Aaron Rodgers vs. Tampa Bay
Matt Stafford vs. Carolina
Jay Cutler vs. San Diego
Christian Ponder vs. Oakland

[Upnorth]

I dont know how this can keep going. I want it to, but it is unreal, completly unreal. What is teh greatest season in history, 120 by Manning in a dome I think. He has a 10 point lead on him outdoors!

[smuggler]

This is what Brady had going in 2007 and Manning in 2004. Godly numbers. The amazing thing is that Rodgers does it with so many fewer pass attempts.

[Joemailman]

The cold weather didn't didn't slow him down much last year. He had 16 TD passes and 2 INT's in the last 8 games, that that included missing a game and a half. His pace right now is about 50-5. The TD passes might slow down a bit, but I could see 45-5.

[superfan]

Comparing Rodgers to the NFC North is not even fair.

Rodgers compared to the best full seasons of current and future hall of famers:

2011 Aaron Rodgers 130.7
2004 Peyton Manning 121.1
2007 Tom Brady 117.2
1994 Steve Young 112.8
1989 Joe Montana 112.4
1999 Kurt Warner 109.2
1947 Otto Graham 109.2
1984 Dan Marino 108.9
1943 Sid Luckman 107.5
2009 Brett Favre 107.2
1966 Bart Starr 105
1971 Roger Staubach 104.8
1963 Y.A. Tittle 104.8
1990 Jim Kelly 101.2
1993 Troy Aikman 99
1968 Len Dawson 98.6
1965 Johnny Unitas 97.4
1990 Warren Moon 96.8
1993 John Elway 92.8
1947 Sammy Baugh 92
1975 Fran Tarkenton 91.8
1970 Sonny Jurgensen 91.5
1961 George Blanda 91.3
1971 Bob Griese 90.9
1981 Dan Fouts 90.6
1960 Norm Van Brocklin 86.5
1978 Terry Bradshaw 84.7
1951 Bob Waterfield 81.8
1954 Bobby Layne 77.3

[Joemailman]

Otto Graham and Sid Luckman having passer ratings over 100 in the 1940's is pretty damn impressive. Surprised Fouts highest was 90. Elway 92.

[smuggler]

Elways stats were always below the curve. He made his name with good comebacks and clutch performance, but other than that and some decent rushing production, he was pretty "meh", supporting cast notwithstanding.