WTF NFL?

[red]

so how the hell is the victor cruz td for a giants a TD?

he caught the ball at the one, turned while being hit and extended the ball across the goal line and lost the ball before hitting the ground

they ruled this a TD because he broke the plain.

WTF is a TD or a catch anymore?????? it changes from play to play and game to game

[red]

i like the old rule much better. you have the ball and its not moving and you have both feet down = a catch

[pbmax]

so how the hell is the victor cruz td for a giants a TD?

he caught the ball at the one, turned while being hit and extended the ball across the goal line and lost the ball before hitting the ground

they ruled this a TD because he broke the plain.

WTF is a TD or a catch anymore?????? it changes from play to play and game to game

That has been consistent called, even if it no longer makes any sense. If he established possession outside the goal line and gets it over the plane, its a TD. But its an exception to the rest of the going to the ground with possession and I don't think it makes any sense.

[red]

That has been consistent called, even if it no longer makes any sense. If he established possession outside the goal line and gets it over the plane, its a TD. But its an exception to the rest of the going to the ground with possession and I don't think it makes any sense.

a catch outside the endzone should be the same as a catch in the endzone, wouldn't you think?

[pbmax]

a catch outside the endzone should be the same as a catch in the endzone, wouldn't you think?

I would like to think so, yes. My fear is they dump the break the plane rule for TDs and continue with the going to the ground with possession there as well.

[smuggler]

Pathetic. Did the Chargers review that play?