Finley Sits Out Practice

[pbmax]

There is still a little immaturity left in Finley. He didn't let anyone know his knee/leg was bothering him until Wednesday before practice apparently. Made McCarthy gruff and caused Fin to do a verbal dance with the locker room media access.

http://www.jsonline.com/sports/packers/finley-sits-out-practice-and-mccarthy-seems-a-bit-miffed-v03jmlp-136356983.html

[pbmax]

In other injury updates, Jennings is running but no practice or cutting yet. He is not playing versus the Lions. Clifton did practice. Bulaga could practice Friday. And Cobb has a groin and will not practice in pads Thursday.

[Harlan Huckleby]

the media, like yourself, are chasing and magnifying the "Finley is a pill" story. It was a small deal, MM expressed mild frustration. I guess Finley reaps wgat he sows

I have been irritated at Finley, his war dances after routine catches are a little rich, especially given the drops.

[pbmax]

the media, like yourself, are chasing and magnifying the "Finley is a pill" story. It was a small deal, MM expressed mild frustration. I guess Finley reaps wgat he sows

I have been irritated at Finley, his war dances after routine catches are a little rich, especially given the drops.

That is definitely the lens this is being examined through. And it might simply be bad timing, certainly other players haven't discovered until Day 2 after the game that they are suffering from something more severe than they thought. But its still unusual for the coach not to get a report on a player until Wednesday morning.

[Guiness]

Cobb has a groin, does he?

[Guiness]

Was Jenning's injury ever clarified?

[Patler]

That is definitely the lens this is being examined through. And it might simply be bad timing, certainly other players haven't discovered until Day 2 after the game that they are suffering from something more severe than they thought. But its still unusual for the coach not to get a report on a player until Wednesday morning.

I suspect the aggravating part is that Finley claims to have hurt it against KC, not Chicago; but yesterday it didn't feel right to practice on. So it wasn't the second or third day after he hurt it, it was the ninth or tenth day after, and apparently no one knew about it.

[pbmax]

I suspect the aggravating part is that Finley claims to have hurt it against KC, not Chicago; but yesterday it didn't feel right to practice on. So it wasn't the second or third day after he hurt it, it was the ninth or tenth day after, and apparently no one knew about it.

I read that as the staff knew about it last week and he assumed McCarthy was aware of it. And then there was no new update until he was declared out of practice. Either way, someone (staff or player) needs to realize that potentially being out of a practice is a different level of concern than a banged up knee that doesn't keep you out of practice.

And actually reading it again it makes no sense as he is talking about banging his knee in KC and now its leg soreness/tiredness. But it does seem clear he didn't report it until Wed. morning.

[Fritz]

My own view based on what I've read is that Finley seems to be asking for an "out" from practice due to tired legs. He said something about keeping him out of practice or even the Sunday game as the "smart" thing that "everybody" knows, but that it would be up to the coach and GM. Not a good quote to put out there, and maybe it's rubbing MM the wrong way that Finley appears as if he might just be wanting a rest. I'm sure most if not all players do, but that's the coach's call, and it appears that Finley may have pushed to get himself this off day, and that's what's irking MM.

[Brandon494]

Trade him!

[Patler]

This is simply another stage in Finley's goofy year in 2011:

Stage 1 - attention seeking (the SB picture flap, "YOTTO" coming into the season & whatever).
Stage 2 - consistently inconsistent performances starting in training camp.
Stage 3 - excuse making (saying he and Rodgers had lost "chemistry", the coverage was too intense, etc.)
Stage 4 - denial (the recent stares in disbelief upon drops, once he was said to have shouted at his hands.)
Stage 5 - sympathy gathering (see, I've been hurt, but was gutting it out.)

Hopefully, he will start fresh (and low key) in 2012.

[Brandon494]

^ like clock work

[hoosier]

I agree with Fritz, Finley sounds like he is asking for a day off. And McCarthy's tone is probably broadcasting the message that he is going about it in the wrong way, and trying to nip any week 17 indifference in the bud. It is nice to see (as far as one can really see from where we sit) that McCarthy refuses to coddle guys like Finley but can toe this line without becoming a disciplinarian who simply cannot relate to his players. The ability he has shown to motivate and manipulate--in the best sense--in the last 13 months has really surprised me.

[Patler]

^ like clock work

I simply recounted what FACTUALLY has occurred this year (can you dispute any of it?)
I concluded with a hope for a better 2012. Don't you as well?

So, what the hell are you complaining about this time with my post?????????
Am I not allowed to comment on Finley, even when it is to wish him well?

[Fritz]

This is simply another stage in Finley's goofy year in 2011:

Stage 1 - attention seeking (the SB picture flap, "YOTTO" coming into the season & whatever).
Stage 2 - consistently inconsistent performances starting in training camp.
Stage 3 - excuse making (saying he and Rodgers had lost "chemistry", the coverage was too intense, etc.)
Stage 4 - denial (the recent stares in disbelief upon drops, once he was said to have shouted at his hands.)
Stage 5 - sympathy gathering (see, I've been hurt, but was gutting it out.)

Hopefully, he will start fresh (and low key) in 2012.

Agreed. My personal favorite is his staring at his hands in disbelief, then shouting at them. I think his hands need a twitter account of their own!

But like Patler and all Packer fans, I hope for him to have a big, big playoff run. If he can become that impossible-to-stop-over-the-middle guy, that will take great pressure off the receivers and allow them to do their voodoo on the sidelines.