Pro Bowl voting leaders

[LegandofthePack15]

1998 (SF), 2002 (Vick) & 2004 (Vikings).

Favre's W-L in playoffs = 13-11 (rating 86.3). Rodgers = 4-2 (rating 105.5)

Yet, Super Bowls: Favre 2, Rodgers 1.

As a die-hard Packer fan, I hope Rodgers leads the Packers to a few more SBs. But Favre will always be the G.O.A.T no matter what.

[Patler]

But Favre will always be the G.O.A.T no matter what.

How can he "always be", when he never got there in the first place??

[LegandofthePack15]

How can he "always be", when he never got there in the first place??

Winner. Champion. Iron man. Record holder.

The greatest of all time, indeed.

[Patler]

Winner. Champion. Iron man. Record holder.

The greatest of all time, indeed.

His "winner" and "champion" qualifications were nothing extraordinary, matched by many and exceeded by some.
I'll give you "iron man" which in turn begot "record holder".

I think the term (old) goat applies, but not G.O.A.T.

[Pugger]

Winner. Champion. Iron man. Record holder.

The greatest of all time, indeed.

You should take your comedy routine on the road. You'll make a bundle. The consensus overall greatest QB of all time was Joe Montana. Hell, your lover isn't even the best QB to ever wear green and gold.

[Cheesehead Craig]

Kuhn should be the All-Pro FB just for the fact of the "KUUUUUUUHHHHHNNNNN" cheer regardless of where the Pack is playing.

[woodbuck27]

"Ice" Ryan is no laughingstock. Currently, the guy's completing 68% of his passes for almost 4000 yds and 24 tds. Ryan has been sacked only 24 times cos he doesnt hold the ball longer than it takes Bob Dole to play a round of golf, e.g., "Erin" Rodgers and his 42 sacks. Most importantly, the Falcons currently have the best record in the NFC at 11-2.

Your choice... Matt Ryan is the MVP 'of the NFC' over Aaron Rodgers, Adrian Peterson and Calvin Johnson.

As I look at it today and all things considered. If Tom Brady doesn't get the MVP 'NFL'; voters arn't paying attention to much more than hype.

Tom Brady is clearly the NFL MVP and the runner up should be a toss up between Aaron Rodgers and Adrian Peterson.

Peyton Manning is a first year member of the Denver Broncos a team that had much in place before his signing. I truely feel as a result of his first year status that he's ineligible.

Accepting that argument it comes down to Tom Brady, Aaron Rodgers and Adrian Peterson and OK..... toss Matt Ryan into that mix? No.

After some brief thought it comes down to Tom Brady and Adrian Peterson who are both having exceptional years and clearly extremely valuable to their teams.

The winner is Tom Brady. Count on it.

[mraynrand]

His "winner" and "champion" qualifications were nothing extraordinary, matched by many.

I'm a winner, I'm a champion.

[mraynrand]

"I'm a winner, too! And I would have won a college championship if coach had let me throw the ball when I came in for Casey Weldon when he lost his shoe."

[LegandofthePack15]

Peyton Manning is a first year member of the Denver Broncos a team that had much in place before his signing. I truely feel as a result of his first year status that he's ineligible.

Accepting that argument it comes down to Tom Brady, Aaron Rodgers and Adrian Peterson and OK..... toss Matt Ryan into that mix? No.

C'mon, Woodbuck, Peyton Manning is not MVP-worthy b/c he's a first year Bronco? That's kinda funny.

I am a Tim Tebow fan and I wish Thompson had drafted Tebow and traded for Tebow prior to this season. But the Broncos are light years better offensively this season than last season. Manning is the reason why. Manning is MVP worthy.

However, I do think Denver would be undefeated right now and en route to New Orleans with Tebow at the helm instead of Manning. Tim Tebow may not throw pretty but he always find a way to win.

Rodgers is NOT MVP-worthy. Last season, sure. This season, nada.

[mraynrand]

But the Broncos are light years better offensively this season than last season. Manning is the reason why. Manning is MVP worthy.

In related news, water is wet.

[LegandofthePack15]

In related news, water is wet.

Water can also be solid as well as gaseous.

[mraynrand]

Water can also be solid as well as gaseous.

uhh no, those would be called ice and steam/vapor, respectively. water is H2O in liquid state. You just won the Woodbuck Award for the day.

[3irty1]

I am a Tim Tebow fan and I wish Thompson had drafted Tebow and traded for Tebow prior to this season...

However, I do think Denver would be undefeated right now and en route to New Orleans with Tebow at the helm instead of Manning.

HAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH A!

[Upnorth]

I think I would vote
1. AP
2. C Johnson
3. T Brady
in that order.

Also Pugger was bang on with here assesment that Starr is the G.O.A.T.