Say it ain't Suh.......DO WE REALLY WANT SEED #2 ?????

[Bretsky]

Blasphemy, some would scream !!! But I think it's a legit question


Let's assume we win round one of the playoff if we are the 3

Would we rather face San Fran in Green Bay or in California ?
Crappy weather or bad weather ?

Is our team more apt to perform better in cold bad weather, or perfect conditions ?
Is our team more apt to beat a tough, intense, powerful defense in the cold or the sun ?
And which venue will give our offense the greatest chance to succeed ?


I will keep my bias aside but I'm curious what others thing. Let's assume, for argument sake, that the Giants don't make the playoffs (since they scare many here)

The simple answer is of course we want time off to heal and rest, but recent history sometimes suggests that week off actually hurts a team and they play a less than stellar game after having too much time off.

And one could also argue we have a finesse offense that woud perform far better in the sun while San Fran has the makeup of a team who could physically dominate us in bad weather.


Where do you stand on this issue ??????????????????????

[Packers4Glory]

I don't want to play SF. we'll get murdered. They are built for any weather. Our best hope is they get knocked off by someone some how. I don't know what would have to happen for that to play out. The only chance we have vs SF is for their QB to shit himself under the playoff pressure. Sad but true. They can run and I don't like our O-line at all vs their front 7. mismatches all over the field there. MM would have to have a career day calling plays to keep Rodgers from being killed and the defense off balance.

[Upnorth]

I don't want to play SF. we'll get murdered. They are built for any weather. Our best hope is they get knocked off by someone some how. I don't know what would have to happen for that to play out. The only chance we have vs SF is for their QB to shit himself under the playoff pressure. Sad but true. They can run and I don't like our O-line at all vs their front 7. mismatches all over the field there. MM would have to have a career day calling plays to keep Rodgers from being killed and the defense off balance.

I think if we played SF today the results would be different that week 1. Our Defence is better and have some outstanding rookies with experience now. We also have some sembelance of a run game, and while we have a worse pass blocking oline, we have a better run blocking oline (EDS and Barclay are both big upgrades in the run block this year).
I think we would play better in SF but I look forward to kapernick freezing his hands off in the cold.

[pbmax]

This dome team stuff is WAY overrated. Home games all the way. 49ers don't want to be cold. Their ST can't handle the ball when its warm. Seaturkeys don't know what to do it anything other than rain.

If you could arrange to play the Giants in the Georgia Dome, that I will agree to.

[woodbuck27]

This dome team stuff is WAY overrated. Home games all the way. 49ers don't want to be cold. Their ST can't handle the ball when its warm. Seaturkeys don't know what to do it anything other than rain.

If you could arrange to play the Giants in the Georgia Dome, that I will agree to.

I agree that I'd take that #2 seed all day.

I want home field advantage; especially so in January. January in Green Bay is a far cry from a Sept. game at a temperate Lambeau Field, if it's us Vs the San Fran 49ers, after the bye.

I want the San Fran 49ers (#3 seed) facing the New York GIANTS (#6 seed). The GIANTS have already defeated them in San Fran by a score of 26-3. Let them beat one another up. Bring the winner of that matchup to a more rested and healed Green Bay Packers team at Lambeau Field.

We need to 'get the monkey off our back' and defeat the GIANTS in Lambeau Field. No matter when we face the GIANTS in the playoffs; and I believe we will. We have to see our team get that done.

GO PACKERS !

[George Cumby]

You buncha' pussies. Let's play them in the parking lot for fuck's sake.

[woodbuck27]

You buncha' pussies. Let's play them in the parking lot for fuck's sake.

Yaa but ....... 'all that smelly sausage' !!

[RashanGary]

I'd rather play at home. Kapernick is a really good player IMO, but as young as he is, playing on the road should be tougher for him than a veteran QB. There are still a lot of things that could happen. My ideal scenario would be the 2 seed with SF, or Seattle coming to us. Seattle preferably.

[Jimx29]

Kapernick will fold like a cheap suit.

[Pugger]

Kapernick will fold like a cheap suit.

Like he did in NE?

[pbmax]

Like he did in NE?

NE's defense can be had in a big way. Unless you are the Texans.

[Iron Mike]

NE's defense can be had in a big way.

From your lips to God's ears. GB vs. NE in the SB!!!

[Bretsky]

From your lips to God's ears. GB vs. NE in the SB!!!

That would be great...but I'd rather play any other team in the AFC

[Fritz]

Yes, the bye week, please.

[Joemailman]

Blasphemy, some would scream !!! But I think it's a legit question


Let's assume we win round one of the playoff if we are the 3

Would we rather face San Fran in Green Bay or in California ?
Crappy weather or bad weather ?

Is our team more apt to perform better in cold bad weather, or perfect conditions ?
Is our team more apt to beat a tough, intense, powerful defense in the cold or the sun ?
And which venue will give our offense the greatest chance to succeed ?


I will keep my bias aside but I'm curious what others thing. Let's assume, for argument sake, that the Giants don't make the playoffs (since they scare many here)

The simple answer is of course we want time off to heal and rest, but recent history sometimes suggests that week off actually hurts a team and they play a less than stellar game after having too much time off.

And one could also argue we have a finesse offense that woud perform far better in the sun while San Fran has the makeup of a team who could physically dominate us in bad weather.


Where do you stand on this issue ??????????????????????

The perception is that the Packers are a finesse offense. The reality is that over the past 6 games the Packers have run the ball 187 times while passing 180 times. They've run it pretty well too, averaging 4.2 YPC and 132 YPG. Allso, as they've run the ball more, Rodgers' YPA has actually gone up. The Packers are now a balanced offense.