Russell Wilson: Overrated?

[Guiness]

I'll tell you who's overrated: Coldplay.

this thread is about to take a turn for the worse...

Not as overrated as Darrin Charles. I could cover that guy easy peasy.

well, that took about as long as expected.

Can't say I see him as over-rated, I think he's viewed as about where he should be. Obviously his stock went up a somewhat with the SB ring

[bobblehead]

this thread is about to take a turn for the worse...


well, that took about as long as expected.

Can't say I see him as over-rated, I think he's viewed as about where he should be. Obviously his stock went up a somewhat with the SB ring

Darrin Charles has a superbowl ring?? Since when?

[Brandon494]

Btw, I don't think Luck is overrated. The Colts were the worst team in the league prior to his arrival. Granted, the AFC South is weak, but Luck has turned the Colts into a respectful playoff contender.

The only reason the Colts sucked that season was because they had Painter at QB, the year before they were a SB contender with Manning. We saw first hand what can happen when you lose your star QB and replace him with a bum. Everyone wants to talk about Luck's comeback wins but hes the reason they have to make a comeback with all the turnovers he commits. 7 INTs in two playoff games this season, Wilson had 9 all season and ZERO in the playoffs. Compare his stats to Wilson and its not even close. Yes Wilson has the best defense in the league and that helps him win games but that has nothing to do with his stats.

Wilson has a higher completion %, more TD passes, less INTs, more rushing yards, higher yards per pass attempt, and a higher QB rating but hes the overrated one? Come on man!

[KYPack]

I am NOT suggesting the guy flat out sucks. Wilson is a so-called "natural born leader." He has a good arm. He's elusive. Smart. A winner. A champion.

But.....The truth of the matter is the Seagulls' D dominated and will probably continue to dominate the league. All Wilson has to do is hand the ball off to The Beast, make the occasional 3rd and short conversions and not turn the ball over. In other words, a game manager.

Tank, why don't you learn some football?

All he has to do is hand the ball to Beast Mode, eh?

The Broncos shut Lynch down, 39 yds in 18 carries. Wilson then made the proper calls and distributed the ball. He was 4 of 5 in 3rd down conversions IN THE FIRST QUARTER!

Passer rating of 123.

He established a start to his legacy.

It doesn't matter where you rate him, you being a moron and all.

[mraynrand]

Wilson has a higher completion %, more TD passes, less INTs, more rushing yards, higher yards per pass attempt, and a higher QB rating but hes the overrated one? Come on man!

I'm still kinda looking to see someone rate him. If they put him in top 3, I suppose I would think he was overrated, but it could be there's not enough data yet. Ratings didn't help Manning all that much; he looked worse than Painter against Seattle.

[Rodgers12]

I'll tell you who's overrated: Coldplay.

You're joking, right? Coldplay is without a doubt the best rock band since the Plastic Ono Band.

[Rodgers12]

The only reason the Colts sucked that season was because they had Painter at QB, the year before they were a SB contender with Manning. We saw first hand what can happen when you lose your star QB and replace him with a bum. Everyone wants to talk about Luck's comeback wins but hes the reason they have to make a comeback with all the turnovers he commits. 7 INTs in two playoff games this season, Wilson had 9 all season and ZERO in the playoffs. Compare his stats to Wilson and its not even close. Yes Wilson has the best defense in the league and that helps him win games but that has nothing to do with his stats.

Wilson has a higher completion %, more TD passes, less INTs, more rushing yards, higher yards per pass attempt, and a higher QB rating but hes the overrated one? Come on man!

Take away Luck and the Colts are more hapless than the Packers with Tolzien playing.

Tarvaris Jackson could've won the SB with that Seagull D. Watched all 3 of the Gulls' playoffs game, including the SB, and Wilson looked like a robotic game manager. Maybe Bevell forbid him, but Wilson rarely called audibles. The only time he took a chance down the field, the Ninners jumped offside and it was a free play.

Wilson didn't even have to show up in the Super Bowl for the Gulls to win. Defense held the great Peyton Manning to 8 points and scored 9.

Again, I'm not saying Wilson sucks. Just saying his playoff performance was pretty Alex Smithsque (not the McCarthy-era Alex Smith but the Reid-era Smith).

[Rodgers12]

My cute moose avatar is gone. WTF?

Whatever.

[Brandon494]

Tarvaris Jackson could've won the SB with that Seagull D. Watched all 3 of the Gulls' playoffs game, including the SB, and Wilson looked like a robotic game manager.

I stopped reading after that .

[Brandon494]

You're joking, right? Coldplay is without a doubt the best rock band since the Plastic Ono Band.

[MadtownPacker]

My cute moose avatar is gone. WTF?

Whatever.

I took it off. Do you have a problem with that you little fucking bitch??

[call_me_ishmael]

Overrated? I don't think so. Where do people view him? He will eventually be a very good QB in my opinion. He's short, but mobile, and has a gun. He's a natural leader. Easy to see him being a good player coming out of UW. It's all about the arm with these guys - and he has one.

[smuggler]

I stopped reading after that .

I do think there are a lot of QBs that would have won with the Seagulls in that game. I mean a lot. Tavaris is probably on the list, but Russell Wilson is not a robotic game manager.

[KYPack]

I took it off. Do you have a problem with that you little fucking bitch??

Some of 'em get Patlerized.

Tank is getting "Fresno-ed".

This is gonna be fun.

The knot is behind his left ear.

[Brandon494]

I do think there are a lot of QBs that would have won with the Seagulls in that game. I mean a lot. Tavaris is probably on the list, but Russell Wilson is not a robotic game manager.

The super bowl isn't won in one game, I'm talking about the whole season.