My Rankings

[HarveyWallbangers]

I was going to post my rankings by position, but the board pooped out. I just uploaded my draft spreadsheet instead. If you want to see what the consensus rankings are, you can just download the spreadsheet and sort by the consensus (CRk column).

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1_yTdYPh_kt3y1KgC10QLa9o03GB4_4O5Fx1h4ahwrtc/edit#gid=1962482956

I wasn't going to publish this, so there's some things that may not be obvious. There is a worksheet for each position. The columns are position, my rankings, where I'd draft them, player, college, consensus rankings, consensus round range, consensus position rank. Then, there are the players measurables--including a crude formula to calculate the player's SAA (speed, burst, agility), explosion (vertical and broad jump), and overall athletic ability. Next, are various scouting reports on each player for traits key to the position. Then, the player's scheme fit and NFL player comparison. Finally, there are the consensus rankings. Key players acquired by Ted Thompson measurables are listed under the Packers worksheet.

If a player has injury concerns, their name is in red. If a player has character concerns, their name is in purple. Measurables listed in blue were Pro Day measurables--not Scouting Combing measurables.

[HarveyWallbangers]

Sorry that the font is kind of small and hard to read on Google Docs. Also, the gray is darker than when I'm viewing it in Excel. You can always download the spreadsheet and tweak it however you want.

[HarveyWallbangers]

Also, I haven't finished my CB and S rankings, so they are mostly the consensus rankings at this point.

[red]

great shit harv

[red]

how do your rating go?

is it

great-good-solid-average-poor?

or

great-good-ave-solid-poor?

[KYPack]

Dern, good work, Harv.

You actually did all this stuff?

[HarveyWallbangers]

how do your rating go?

is it

great-good-solid-average-poor?

or

great-good-ave-solid-poor?

Great, Good, Solid, Avg, Poor. There's a Bell Curve.

[Freak Out]

TT needs to sign Gator Hoskins as a FA.

[Joemailman]

Awesome stuff Harv. Jordan Matthews is one of my top hopes to be a Packer. The comparison you have of him is Jordy Nelson. He practically has Jordy's first name and his last name is Matthews. He was meant to be a Packer.

[Freak Out]

Fuck....I am getting stoked for the draft now. There is some insane talent at WR this year.....no matter what happens before 21 the packers will end up with a badass unless TT totally fucks this thing up. JH anyone?

[red]

Awesome stuff Harv. Jordan Matthews is one of my top hopes to be a Packer. The comparison you have of him is Jordy Nelson. He practically has Jordy's first name and his last name is Matthews. He was meant to be a Packer.

i think he goes late first very high second, meaning we're out of play. we have much bigger needs with that first pick

[Joemailman]

i think he goes late first very high second, meaning we're out of play. we have much bigger needs with that first pick

You okay with him as the pick if TT trades down?

[red]

You okay with him as the pick if TT trades down?

no

with that first pick, and maybe our first 2 picks, we need immediate impact starters at safety, ILB, TE, DL first before messing with what we'll need next year (2015)

if he were to somehow fall to our second pick, then i could live with it. but not our first

and i'm not so sure that mathews with our first is all that much better then one of the guys who could be there at our pick in the third

[HarveyWallbangers]

You take BPA-unless things are close. IMHO, if Pryor, Ward, HaHa are gone, you don't reach on the next safety. I don't see any ILBs there worth drafting. Shazier and Mosley will be gone. Huge dropoff to Borland, Brown, and Kirksey. Don't chase a need.

[red]

You take BPA-unless things are close. IMHO, if Pryor, Ward, HaHa are gone, you don't reach on the next safety. I don't see any ILBs there worth drafting. Shazier and Mosley will be gone. Huge dropoff to Borland, Brown, and Kirksey. Don't chase a need.

don't throw a pick away on a non need and neglect your biggest need for yet another year. we saw how well that worked out last year when we tried that approach of not worrying about needs