I agree with Madden

[Fritz]

Well, given Favre's stature and what he has meant to Green Bay I would only trade him to a team he would agree to go to. Of course, no team would trade for him if they didn't think he'd come play for them, but I'd ask Brett first. He deserves that consideration.

[Harlan Huckleby]

For me, if Favre could garner a 2nd I'd settle for that. I think a team like the Ravens would jump at that. But he has to want to play for a winner first.

hell, I'd take a 3rd or 4th.

I agree it is up to Favre. If he wants to retire, fine. If he wants to play another year, either here or somewhere else, fine. I wouldn't hold any of these choices against him. It's just a game, many local legends finish-out with another team, including St. Vince.

[MJZiggy]

Oddly enough, Vince died before he had much of a chance to do anything with the Giants.

[Harlan Huckleby]

Oddly enough, Vince died before he had much of a chance to do anything with the Giants.

You mean TO the Giants. He was with Redskins. But come to think of it, didn't Vinnie start career as assistant coach on Giants?

[MJZiggy]

Yes he did, that's my mistake. I meant the Skins.

[Tarlam!]

OK.

1. Where could Favre go, where he would not need to do a lot of learning of a new offense?
2. Where could he go and become the guaranteed starter?
3. Where could he go that would offer a 1st to 3rd?
4. Where could he go, that did not disrupt the winning percentage of the Packers?
5. Where can he go and potentially win his 2nd SB ring?

If you can name the team that offers legitimate answers for all 5 of these parameters, I'd say, there is a case. I think if even a single parameter is flawed, he stays or retires.

[Iron Mike]

Bet you could wangle a first rounder out of them. If a GM thought that by giving up a first round pick he could get to the Super Bowl, he'd very likely do it.

Didn't Tampa Bay give up a 2 #1s and a #2 to get Gruden????

[MJZiggy]

That amazes me. Dungy was as good a coach (and man) as you'll ever find.