An Attempt At Discussing McCarthy's Future

[Joemailman]

Current? Besides Belichick, I'd probably take Harbaugh, Pagano, Tomlin, Carroll. Maybe even Chip.

The latter question is a harder one. Don't have an immediate answer to that.

Pagano just lost 45-7. Tomlin hasn't won a playoff game since 2010. Chip hasn't won a playoff game.

[vince]

and Mike McCarthy will still be THE SAME MIKE MCCARTHY.

He won't get his team another Super Bowl win unless he makes some serious changes.

That man has to first and foremost hold himself responsible for that loss today.

That's a decent and understandable start.

I give up. Serious changes? Replacing their 3rd string TE on the hands team is a change that woulda got him to the Super Bowl this year. How serious is that?

[call_me_ishmael]

but for the love of God, can we get rid of dunderdummy?? I'm beggin ya??

We gave up 21 points to the prolific cowboy offense. We gave up 22 to the Seahawks on a day where Rodgers through two picks. Exactly what is the problem here? Did you not expect to win both games with the points allowed?

[call_me_ishmael]

Harbaugh was 8-8 this year. Pagano just lost 45-7. Tomlin hasn't won a playoff game since 2010. Chip hasn't won a playoff game.

Top coaches IMO:

1. BB
2. John Harbaugh
3. Jim Harbaugh

After that, it is Tomlin/Payton/McCarthy/Carroll. John Harbaugh is amazing.

[pbmax]

I don't think Michigan beats the Steelers or Packers.

[Bretsky]

Top coaches IMO:

1. BB
2. John Harbaugh
3. Jim Harbaugh

After that, it is Tomlin/Payton/McCarthy/Carroll. John Harbaugh is amazing.

John Harbaugh was absolutely schooled by the best last week. Maybe he's better than MM but I'm not sold yet. I'll take Carroll though

[oldbutnotdeadyet]

A good coach learns from his mistakes. I'm just not seeing that from stubby. Since I agree he will be back next year, please please prove me wrong and fire Slocum and capers, and grow some larger balls.

[mraynrand]

I agree. Seeing Big Mike after the game, he looked shell shocked. I don't mean that as a metaphor, I mean he literally looked like he crawled out of a WW I trench.

It will take some time.

Yeah, I gotta imagine as tough as it is for fans, it's got to be devastating for coaches and players.

[mraynrand]

Top coaches IMO:

1. BB
2. John Harbaugh
3. Jim Harbaugh

After that, it is Tomlin/Payton/McCarthy/Carroll. John Harbaugh is amazing.

Packers routinely beat John Harbaugh.

[BallHawk]

Pagano just lost 45-7. Tomlin hasn't won a playoff game since 2010. Chip hasn't won a playoff game.

Pagano overachieved with the roster he had. Tomlin has been wrecked by injuries the last few years. Chip just brings so much to the table that I think his success is inevitable if he decides he wants to stick it out in the pros.

[mraynrand]

Maybe the Packers just need to tank a season or two to get higher draft picks. All this success is just leading to draft failure. It will be worth it, believe me. You will enjoy those 4-12 seasons.

[pbmax]

Maybe the Packers just need to tank a season or two to get higher draft picks. All this success is just leading to draft failure. It will be worth it, believe me. You will enjoy those 4-12 seasons.

They could trade Brad Jones and AJ Hawk plus a fifth rounder for Joe Thomas. Then move Thomas for a pair of first round picks.

[mraynrand]

They could trade Brad Jones and AJ Hawk plus a fifth rounder for Joe Thomas. Then move Thomas for a pair of first round picks.

I think that would work, but Hershel Walker has to be included somewhere in that trade sequence.

[ThunderDan]

GOOD LIST....some might argue Sean Payton

I think I'd prefer Hoody Genius and Pete Carroll but I"m not sure I"d take any of the others.

Sean won how many games this year?

[woodbuck27]

There will be no changes... Ted doesn't make rash decisions.

They'll rationalize that the coaching decisions played no role in the loss - they'll cash their paychecks, and we'll see everyone again next fall.

The facts of life and Packer Nation.