OFFICIAL duds & studs

[RashanGary]

I'm giving Randall a stud because of the key interception. He lost battles with some WRs, but his coverage was decent.

I don't know about "stud" but he does look like a guy who might just turn out to be a very good player. For a rookie, he's either making the play or right there. And he makes some splash plays. Id bet on him being a good player for a lot of years.

[Patler]

I don't know if he should be called a stud, but James Jones has to be recognized for making a heck of a catch when his team absolutely needed it.

[Harlan Huckleby]

No...it's a vet telling the kid to shut up and move on. Yeah, the kid had a point, and it clearly hit a nerve. The defense played considerably better after the dust up.

You were privy to the conversation? You think it is cool for a big guy to push around a little guy cause he thinks he is right in an argument?

The "vet" is a giant man-child, and he's not bullying a kid, he's threatening a man half his size. He's acting like a kid on a playground.

The defense played considerably better after the dust up.

You think the two are connected? Childish.

[Smidgeon]

Dud: Lacy. What is wrong with him?
Dud2: O-line. Of course, this could explain the first Dud.

[MadtownPacker]

You were privy to the conversation? You think it is cool for a big guy to push around a little guy cause he thinks he is right in an argument?

The "vet" is a giant man-child, and he's not bullying a kid, he's threatening a man half his size. He's acting like a kid on a playground.

You think the two are connected? Childish.

If we dig hard enough we can find a post by you threatening to wrassle me into submission cuz you claimed you where bigger and outweighed me.

[Pugger]

Studs

Rodgers for almost bringing us back despite lousy protection up front
Perry for at least 2 tackles for loss
Randall for getting an INT even tho he is getting picked on because he is a rookie
Starks for running hard until we had to abandon the run

Duds

O line for its poor play all around
Front 7 for not pressuring Cam and giving all damn day
Ha-Ha for his worse game in recent memory.
Lacy - is he out of shape or injured?

[esoxx]

Studs don't get scared:

Getting scared on last offensive play with all the marbles on the line?

Dud

[Maxie the Taxi]

It seems to me we're letting Stubby off the hook if he's not being mentioned as a DUD.

I didn't see his post-game presser, but last week he sort of blamed himself for the loss. This week I think he put it more on the players for not performing.

Made way too many mistakes & gave up too many big plays

The first half of that game yesterday to me was like a rerun of Denver. What did Stubby do this past week to fix either the offense or the defense?

They say insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results. Maybe Stubby has a screw loose?

[pbmax]

It seems to me we're letting Stubby off the hook if he's not being mentioned as a DUD.

I didn't see his post-game presser, but last week he sort of blamed himself for the loss. This week I think he put it more on the players for not performing.

The first half of that game yesterday to me was like a rerun of Denver. What did Stubby do this past week to fix either the offense or the defense?

They say insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results. Maybe Stubby has a screw loose?

They ran a run heavy package to get the run game untracked and sent out new personnel packages with Abby and Ripper (and supposedly Janis) to show something new.

Then they had to junk it for the normal stuff they pass with in the second half when they were down by 3 scores.

[mraynrand]

It seems to me we're letting Stubby off the hook if he's not being mentioned as a DUD.

I didn't see his post-game presser, but last week he sort of blamed himself for the loss. This week I think he put it more on the players for not performing.

The first half of that game yesterday to me was like a rerun of Denver. What did Stubby do this past week to fix either the offense or the defense?

They say insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results. Maybe Stubby has a screw loose?

No, he's just Stubby. And PBMax had predicted this scenario well before the fact. Stubby will not give up on his wonderfully and logically constructed plans after just one humiliating loss. It takes a few shocks to the system, and some lonely nights at the Golden Corral buffet before he comes around.

[Maxie the Taxi]

They ran a run heavy package to get the run game untracked and sent out new personnel packages with Abby and Ripper (and supposedly Janis) to show something new.

Then they had to junk it for the normal stuff they pass with in the second half when they were down by 3 scores.

Not with Abby. Abby didn't play.

New personnel packages? That's it. Gee, Stubby must have worked well into the night to think up that stuff.

[mraynrand]

They ran a run heavy package to get the run game untracked and sent out new personnel packages with Abby and Ripper (and supposedly Janis) to show something new.

Then they had to junk it for the normal stuff they pass with in the second half when they were down by 3 scores.

I did see some of this stuff, and was shocked when they 1) went to Ripper and 2) did not go back to Ripper after the play worked so well.

BTW, I wasn't following the game day thread, but did people notice the fans yelling Kuhn when Ripper was on his big run?

[mraynrand]

Not with Abby. Abby didn't play.

This is an evil rumor that someone started. 83 and 84 were seen on several offensive plays. I am 100% certain about 84 and about 90% certain about 83.

[Maxie the Taxi]

I did see some of this stuff, and was shocked when they 1) went to Ripper and 2) did not go back to Ripper after the play worked so well.

BTW, I wasn't following the game day thread, but did people notice the fans yelling Kuhn when Ripper was on his big run?

It wasn't "fans" yelling. It was Ted Thompson you heard.

[Maxie the Taxi]

This is an evil rumor that someone started. 83 and 84 were seen on several offensive plays. I am 100% certain about 84 and about 90% certain about 83.

Then the NFL Gamebook Pdf is wrong: http://prod.static.packers.clubs.nfl...k-panthers.pdf

Did Not Play
Did Not Play
QB 16 S.Tolzien, WR 84 J.Abbrederis