WHAT SHOULD WE DO WITH MIKE MCCARTHY ???

[Bretsky]

3 SIMPLE OPTIONS

Keep Him

Let him go

Let the new GM decide

[red]

Let the new gm bring in his own coach

But I think he’ll stay

[woodbuck27]

The Headline is right here:

MM has to have his tiring act FIRED in Green Bay.

[Bretsky]

I'm shocked I"m even creating this poll, but I keep reading some sentiment in here that MM needs to go.

I like to consider myself even keel...but at worst I can only think of 2-7 coaches I'd rather have.

I think MM is a good playcaller and does a good job.

But wondering if I"m in the minority.

IF you do vote for option 3 please give your bias in here on how you feel about MM being a top 10 coach or not

[Bretsky]

AND if a new GM is hired, should he move fast or take a while ?

[red]

I would think it was fat mike that fired capers. If they were gonna completely clean hous they would have just fired mike and his whole staff

It would be kind of a dick move to make a guy you are about to fire, fire his hero and good buddy

That is unless all these changes are coming from murphy

[pbmax]

The structure is important. Even if you construct a Frankenstein front office to get a short term payoff, it will eventually come back to destroy its creators.

Or maybe that was Asimov, but you get my point.

Let the GM be in charge of all football, no fooling around.

[red]

I think fat mike sucks as a coach

His teams are very often unmotivated and unprepared for big games

He way too often goes conservative and takes his foot off the gas and ends up costing us

He doesn’t use the running game enough, he doesn’t make coaching changes fast enough. He doesn’t know how to use a TE to save his life

He’s horrible at time management

He had a chance earlier this year to make a move for a QB to keep us in playoff contention, but he wanted his own guy that he groomed. That guy didn’t work out to well. And the real McCarthy offense we saw was pathetic

IMO, we win in spite of him, not because of him. We win because a rod is mostly changing up the plays at the LOS and playing backyard ball

That is why we win. Would a new coach come in and let a-rod do his own thing while fixing all the other issues, or would he tighten the reins and neuter Rodgers making us less effective

[Joemailman]

The new GM will have enough to do without going through a head coach search and hire. Keep MM. If after a year, the GM and coach are a bad fit, then make a change. Seems that happened once before here and it worked fairly well.

[call_me_ishmael]

He probably already agreed to or possibly even signed an extension ala Sherman, or he isn't coaching the Packers in 2018.

[Fosco33]

I think it'll be Wolf and McCarthy stays.

[Zool]

I voted option 3 because I have no say in the matter

[wist43]

Stubby stays - cuz I said so

[woodbuck27]

AND if a new GM is hired, should he move fast or take a while ?

This might be your answer:

[woodbuck27]

The new GM will have enough to do without going through a head coach search and hire. Keep MM. If after a year, the GM and coach are a bad fit, then make a change. Seems that happened once before here and it worked fairly well.

Baloney has Oakland hired this Guy yet?



Jon Gruden expected to become Raiders' head coach

http://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/21928301/jon-gruden-expected-become-next-coach-oakland-raiders