GOAT Packer QB

[Harlan Huckleby]

Choose wisely, this is part of your permanent record.

[mraynrand]

Patler will choose Bart

[mraynrand]

what is a 'QQ'?

[red]

whats choose widely mean?

[Harlan Huckleby]

whats choose widely mean?

Autocorrect bit me on that one.

[mraynrand]

Autocorrect bit me on that one.

Autocorrect is a harsh mistress.

[Fritz]

Choose wisely, this is part of your permanent record.

Cecil Isbell, baby!

[Zool]

Randy (if being this awesome is wrong, I don't want to be) Wright

[mraynrand]

We already did WOAT.


I can't decide here. Bart was the best leader, and the most successful in terms of championships, Favre was the greatest tough-guy, rocket-arm gamer, and Rodgers is the amazing, mistake-free, efficient, surgeon-of-a-QB. I refuse to pick.

[George Cumby]

What Rand said. Three different QQ’s from three different eras. Really hard to say which was best without clarifying the rating criteria.

[Harlan Huckleby]

You can clarify your own criteria. I voted for Starr because he won so much. Favre was too error prone, although he is in same league as other two. Rodgers may yet eclipse Starr.

Starr didn't have a great team around him every year he played. He was consistent.

I am surprised nobody voted for Favre yet.

[texaspackerbacker]

I grew up watching Starr, but I didn't vote for him because he was to a great extent a product of the team around him - and the coach, of course.

I had Favre pegged as the GOAT NFL-wide - until Rodgers came along and clearly is even greater.

[gbgary]

on all the measureables, stats, etc...Rodgers.

on history, class, being an icon...Starr.

[Harlan Huckleby]

I was not drunk when I made this poll, I was lying in bed with a tiny android tablet I could barely read, trying to punch tiny letters with my fat fingers. It took a couple tries, but I pressed on because of the urgency of settling the GOAT QQ question once and for all. Fuck you in advance, and your mothers for what you been saying.

[mraynrand]

I was not drunk when I made this poll, I was lying in bed with a tiny android tablet I could barely read, trying to punch tiny letters with my fat fingers. It took a couple tries, but I pressed on because of the urgency of settling the GOAT QQ question once and for all. Fuck you in advance, and your mothers for what you been saying.

^^^^ It's never the crime that gets ya, but the cover-up.