Taysom Hill: America's Most Overrated QB

[mraynrand]

Sigh...just when I thought you were catching on. Jimmy will NEVER block. He may try, but he won't do it with any effectiveness.

Someone needs to tell the coach.

[bobblehead]

Someone needs to tell the coach.

McCarthy called M4 at the half. "WTF you doing using a receiving TE to block for? Jimmy catches screens, Mercedes blocks....don't confuse the defense"

Typical fat Mike...ending the sentence with a preposition!

[yetisnowman]

Good ol "bottom of the roster"Taysom Hill with a punt block, 2 catches and a TD in the first 3 minutes of tonight's game.

[pbmax]

Good ol "bottom of the roster"Taysom Hill with a punt block, 2 catches and a TD in the first 3 minutes of tonight's game.

Every blind squirrel finds a nut on Thanksgiving every so often.

[yetisnowman]

Every blind squirrel finds a nut on Thanksgiving every so often.

Add a 30 yard rush TD to his totals. You guys are hilariously stubborn sometimes. It's ok to admit you were wrong.

[ZachMN]

Add a 30 yard rush TD to his totals. You guys are hilariously stubborn sometimes. It's ok to admit you were wrong.

You will never get them to admit that- instead you'll get mathematical analysis which cannot account for the dynamism of human emotion and passion which can take over in game situations- like the beat down we got in SF.....but no worries I'm sure we will get some sort of spread sheet demonstrating our error in thinking.

[Fritz]

I don't know. I'm reading people saying that yes, the guy is an athletic freak, that yes, he can make some great special teams plays and some interesting and effective trick plays - he's a handy guy to have around. But he's not a #1 quarterback. That's all people are saying.

Hell, he's a more athletic version of Jarod Bush or Jeff Janis - great guys to have, but odd fits for an offense or defense.

[George Cumby]

I don't know. I'm reading people saying that yes, the guy is an athletic freak, that yes, he can make some great special teams plays and some interesting and effective trick plays - he's a handy guy to have around. But he's not a #1 quarterback. That's all people are saying.

Hell, he's a more athletic version of Jarod Bush or Jeff Janis - great guys to have, but odd fits for an offense or defense.

And in the hands of a creative mind like Sean Payton, he's going to shine on a teaser basis.

[bobblehead]

I don't know. I'm reading people saying that yes, the guy is an athletic freak, that yes, he can make some great special teams plays and some interesting and effective trick plays - he's a handy guy to have around. But he's not a #1 quarterback. That's all people are saying.

Those same people also say Kapernick should get another chance as a starter for some of the same reasons.

[bobblehead]

Some sane people say Hill should be our backup and Kapernick is a backup talent (as is tebow). Not mentioning names, but someone is consistent.

[pbmax]

Kaepernick started the Super Bowl. Hill doesn’t start preseason games. Easy to get the two confused

Would like to have Hill on team but not as #2 QB.

Though as it turned out, he would probably be more effective than either Callahan, Hundley or Kizer.

Not against changing the offense for any quality backup QB. But I haven’t seen enough of him passing to hitch the wagon to him which is why I wouldn’t want to leave camp with him as #2.

[pbmax]

But as we established, Packers haven’t done enough at the backup QB position.

[texaspackerbacker]

You wouldn't take Boyle over any of the three you mentioned? Or over Hill either for that matter?

I was gonna say something about holding the clipboard, but I haven't seen a clipboard for a while. Anyway, for the use the Packers make of a back up, any of those guys would be good enough ...... and heaven forbid, if Rodgers did get hurt, we're screwed and the season is down the drain no matter who the back up is.

[pbmax]

You wouldn't take Boyle over any of the three you mentioned? Or over Hill either for that matter?

I was gonna say something about holding the clipboard, but I haven't seen a clipboard for a while. Anyway, for the use the Packers make of a back up, any of those guys would be good enough ...... and heaven forbid, if Rodgers did get hurt, we're screwed and the season is down the drain no matter who the back up is.

Very unsure about Boyle. Good arm, no idea how he fares against starters. Don’t want to know until next pre season.

By showcasing Kizer as #2 in the preseason, really hindered coming to a conclusion about Boyle.

[yetisnowman]

Hill with a 19 yard run and a 50 yd completion on the Saints only Td drive so far. Anyone of you stubborn goobers want to admit you were wrong about this guy?