I know I'll catch grief for this one but I really believe there is some validity and fact behind it.
I've been going over all of TT's player moves and I've come to the conclusion that no one person can be this stupid or make this many mistakes in such a short time.
There has been speculation in the media from different sources that TT did not want Favre back. Think back to when Brett was pondering about retirement and made the statement that he'd like to see some effort by the Packers to sign some talent and when that got back to TT and he was asked about it, he stayed silent. Would'nt it have been natural for him to make some kind of positive statement to Brett? Hmmmmmm
Now let's look at the moves he made. First he brings Manuel in to start when he was'nt talented enough to start in Seattle until the injury gave him a shot. Do we need to see anymore of him to realize he's nothing more than a back-up? Then we get Woodson. Was he even required to work out and run with the stop-watch on him? Walker was to much an injury risk but Woodson was'nt? Pickett for Grady seem's like a draw but then he did'nt shine today either. Then we draft a LB with the 1st pick when history shows us that drafting a LB in the top 5 picks has'nt been done very often. In fact it's a rare occurence because the rest of the NFL believes that's to high to draft a LB.
OK, now what has he done to help Brett out? Well, he's accomplished putting out on the field an offensive line that was SMOKED today. Are we to believe that no one in the organization saw how badly Cliffy has deteriorated? He drafted a WR when we all know it takes WR's a yr or 2 to learn the WC offense. How about our RB's? No way Green stays healthy for a full 16 game schedule so does he bring in any RB to help? We've seen gado and herron and neither one would be on any other NFL roster.
Now I just don't believe anyone is stupid enough to defend these choices that TT has made. Sure, no one is perfect and it's only natural for a GM to make a mistake, but to make this many mistakes?
I'm not gonna even get into the Wahle thing because I understand that can be debated. But I will offer up that he had no back-up plan and let's not forget the 2 clowns he brought in last season.
Those mistakes are not enough for ya? How about our punter and kicker? That missed 53 yarder was the worst looking kick I've ever seen. How about our punter who loves to kick line drives? There were better alternatives out there. We all know it. Our special teams are a joke.
Now here's the kicker. Let's examine the coaching alternatives he had. The Saints HC had a proven track record of success on the offensive side. There were a few other coaches who had shown some glimmer of success that he could have hired. He had Bates who was a player favorite and who also had some proof of success in his past. However in the end he hired a coach who's biggest claim to fame was last season's last ranked offense. But it does'nt stop there. He brings in a coach with a new blocking scheme that will take a few yrs to learn, especially when you have rookies starting.
Now we all know it would be a PR nightmare if TT had told Brett he did'nt want him back. We also know with Brett's competitive nature that he could play another 2 yrs if there was any hope of winning. So if for the sake of arguement, he did'nt want Brett back, surrounding him with a terrible in-experienced team is the next best alternative. Favre is gonna take a beating this season and no way he comes back so TT wins and gets what he wanted. Not to mention the added bonus of those great Picks TT is gonna get next season and beyond. For a draft junkie like TT, it will be heaven.
Now a reasonable person would ask "does'nt TT risk getting fired for making so many bad moves"? Well, look how many fans on this forum that buy the it's ok to rebuild for 3yrs excuse. How many today have said this is to be expected and how exciting it will be to watch this team grow. He's gonna get at least 5 yrs to prove himself so he will have the option to fire MM after next season. We all know MM is in over his head and if you don't know it, watch film of a few other new HC's today like Detroit's and then you'll understand.
In closing, before you dismiss my ramblings as pure folly, realize this. TT did not make one move to help Favre out for this season. In fact he made several moves knowing how much harder they would make things for Brett. No one can make this many stupid moves can they? Think about it....
I've been going over all of TT's player moves and I've come to the conclusion that no one person can be this stupid or make this many mistakes in such a short time.
There has been speculation in the media from different sources that TT did not want Favre back. Think back to when Brett was pondering about retirement and made the statement that he'd like to see some effort by the Packers to sign some talent and when that got back to TT and he was asked about it, he stayed silent. Would'nt it have been natural for him to make some kind of positive statement to Brett? Hmmmmmm
Now let's look at the moves he made. First he brings Manuel in to start when he was'nt talented enough to start in Seattle until the injury gave him a shot. Do we need to see anymore of him to realize he's nothing more than a back-up? Then we get Woodson. Was he even required to work out and run with the stop-watch on him? Walker was to much an injury risk but Woodson was'nt? Pickett for Grady seem's like a draw but then he did'nt shine today either. Then we draft a LB with the 1st pick when history shows us that drafting a LB in the top 5 picks has'nt been done very often. In fact it's a rare occurence because the rest of the NFL believes that's to high to draft a LB.
OK, now what has he done to help Brett out? Well, he's accomplished putting out on the field an offensive line that was SMOKED today. Are we to believe that no one in the organization saw how badly Cliffy has deteriorated? He drafted a WR when we all know it takes WR's a yr or 2 to learn the WC offense. How about our RB's? No way Green stays healthy for a full 16 game schedule so does he bring in any RB to help? We've seen gado and herron and neither one would be on any other NFL roster.
Now I just don't believe anyone is stupid enough to defend these choices that TT has made. Sure, no one is perfect and it's only natural for a GM to make a mistake, but to make this many mistakes?
I'm not gonna even get into the Wahle thing because I understand that can be debated. But I will offer up that he had no back-up plan and let's not forget the 2 clowns he brought in last season.
Those mistakes are not enough for ya? How about our punter and kicker? That missed 53 yarder was the worst looking kick I've ever seen. How about our punter who loves to kick line drives? There were better alternatives out there. We all know it. Our special teams are a joke.
Now here's the kicker. Let's examine the coaching alternatives he had. The Saints HC had a proven track record of success on the offensive side. There were a few other coaches who had shown some glimmer of success that he could have hired. He had Bates who was a player favorite and who also had some proof of success in his past. However in the end he hired a coach who's biggest claim to fame was last season's last ranked offense. But it does'nt stop there. He brings in a coach with a new blocking scheme that will take a few yrs to learn, especially when you have rookies starting.
Now we all know it would be a PR nightmare if TT had told Brett he did'nt want him back. We also know with Brett's competitive nature that he could play another 2 yrs if there was any hope of winning. So if for the sake of arguement, he did'nt want Brett back, surrounding him with a terrible in-experienced team is the next best alternative. Favre is gonna take a beating this season and no way he comes back so TT wins and gets what he wanted. Not to mention the added bonus of those great Picks TT is gonna get next season and beyond. For a draft junkie like TT, it will be heaven.
Now a reasonable person would ask "does'nt TT risk getting fired for making so many bad moves"? Well, look how many fans on this forum that buy the it's ok to rebuild for 3yrs excuse. How many today have said this is to be expected and how exciting it will be to watch this team grow. He's gonna get at least 5 yrs to prove himself so he will have the option to fire MM after next season. We all know MM is in over his head and if you don't know it, watch film of a few other new HC's today like Detroit's and then you'll understand.
In closing, before you dismiss my ramblings as pure folly, realize this. TT did not make one move to help Favre out for this season. In fact he made several moves knowing how much harder they would make things for Brett. No one can make this many stupid moves can they? Think about it....



Comment