As a Packers fan, how much will you enjoy it if ........

[Patler]

Justin Fields goes on to a long, decent career, with frequent playoff appearances, a few pro-bowls, etc.; and

Caleb Williams takes the Bears nowhere?

I have to admit, I will chuckle a bit if (when) that happens!

[Joemailman]

I don't think what Fields does really matters. The best thing would be if Williams is mediocre and 1 of the QB's drafted after him turns out to be a HOF QB. Like when they passed on Mahomes to draft Trubisky.

[MadScientist]

As long as the second one happens, I'll be plenty amused.

[MadtownPacker]

You guys are playing checkers while Patler is playing chess. The bears have had so much shit at QB is it pathetic. That’s why Patler’s scenario is better in that it proves the organization is the bust not all these talented guys that have failed there. I’m surprised that none of them have pulled an Elway/Eli and said fuck no I won’t go. I wouldn’t if I was a top rated QB.

[Bretsky]

I think it'd be great is Justin Fields excels and make the HOF as a Steeler, and if Caleb Williams becomes the next Ryan Leaf

[Patler]

I don't think what Fields does really matters. The best thing would be if Williams is mediocre and 1 of the QB's drafted after him turns out to be a HOF QB. Like when they passed on Mahomes to draft Trubisky.

I don't know, passing on an unproven draft pick is one thing, but investing a draft pick, money and time in a quarterback, then basically giving him away in favor of the new draft pick heartthrob would be another whole level of incompetence, in my opinion, if Fields ends up a much better QB than Williams.

[Patler]

You guys are playing checkers while Patler is playing chess. The bears have had so much shit at QB is it pathetic. That’s why Patler’s scenario is better in that it proves the organization is the bust not all these talented guys that have failed there. I’m surprised that none of them have pulled an Elway/Eli and said fuck no I won’t go. I wouldn’t if I was a top rated QB.

I kind of thought Williams might. Wouldn't it be hilarious if he becomes successful, then forces his way out of Chicago?

[Joemailman]

I don't know, passing on an unproven draft pick is one thing, but investing a draft pick, money and time in a quarterback, then basically giving him away in favor of the new draft pick heartthrob would be another whole level of incompetence, in my opinion, if Fields ends up a much better QB than Williams.

Maybe we can have all three.

1. Williams sucks
2. Fields is great for Steelers
3. Jayden Daniels or Drake Maye becomes Mahomes II

[texaspackerbacker]

I don't knw about enjoying it, I guess I would. I've been predicting all along that the Bears will regret dumping Fields, and also that Williams is a fairly strong candidate to suck, making him a ....... Bear.

[MadtownPacker]

I kind of thought Williams might. Wouldn't it be hilarious if he becomes successful, then forces his way out of Chicago?

He has already shown his flare for dramatics so the potential is very much there. I just don’t think he is going to be good enough when he starts getting pounded. For the nailpainter to be considered successful would require beating the Packers and we can’t be having that.

[ThunderDan]

The 1 plus I will give the Bears is that they didn't trade up and give up a ton of picks to get Williams.

I still think he will probably be another USC QB bust.

[Fritz]

Maybe we can have all three.

1. Williams sucks
2. Fields is great for Steelers
3. Jayden Daniels or Drake Maye becomes Mahomes II

Why not think big? Go one step further - da Bears build their new fancy stadium, drum up publicity (and prices) and in their inaugural season . . . da Bears still suck!

[MadScientist]

If Fields is good elsewhere, it means that their scouting and drafting are not a problem, just the coaching. If he fails elsewhere, then the scouting and drafting are a problem, and the can't tell how bad the coaching is. So it's worse for the Bears if Feilds isn't good elsewhere as well. Even if it would be more humiliating if he did well elsewhere.

[sharpe1027]

Their talent evaluation is terrible if Fields turns out to be a good QB. It's one thing to miss on a draft pick. It's a another to miss on a player you have every day in practice and game days.

[Joemailman]

I don't think they're wrong about Fields. Don't think he can read defenses well enough to be consistent. He'll always have some good games because he's a great athlete.