81% want Brett traded

[b bulldog]

Green was nicked up and father time caught him.

[b bulldog]

Actually your more like a lefty in that you are presented all the facts that debunk your foolish opinion and you ignore as you try to convince that an apple is truely an orange.

[b bulldog]

oR MAYBE A INTERCEPTION IS A "GOOD PLAY"

[Bretsky]

oR MAYBE A INTERCEPTION IS A "GOOD PLAY"

Now there's a John Kerry like assertion seeing I never implied or stated that.

Of course later you will just circlespin the details again in hopes that your unfounded generalizations are heard but also forgotten about.

Good night all,

Bretsky

[esoxx]

Green was nicked up and father time caught him.

So then the Packers signing him for this season was foolish right?

[Bretsky]

Green was nicked up and father time caught him.

So then the Packers signing him for this season was foolish right?

If fathertime has caught him then I'd assume so since he started the year healthy, but ineffective.

[b bulldog]

sORRY BUT I hope all that I have posted is remembered but than again if he plays next season, he will be throwing more moonballs and you will have your head in the sand and will keep excusing him. Love the constant excuse making for him and how quick you are to throw everyone else under the bus. Brett is the organization in may peoples eyes, just not MINE!

[esoxx]

Green will definitely have his challenges given his age, wear and torn quad to deal with.

[Harlan Huckleby]

Yes, but let's pay attention to what's going on on JSO lately. They're not exactly Favre loyalists there.

I think it is a fair sample of packer fans.

There are many reasons to want to trade Favre, not just Favre-bashing. I think it makes perfect sense. I doubt it will happen, though.

[Chubbyhubby]

The reasoning I believe that Favre would be traded is because this team is in the rebuilding phase, we are need in so many improvements that we could get a stock pile of picks and use them to improve this team. TRADE FAVRE to a team that needs a QB. In return get a #1 #2 and #3 for him.

What do you think about it?

Comments/Suggestions?

[Harlan Huckleby]

In return get a #1 #2 and #3 for him.

It will be a #3, maybe #2. Favre is on the edge of retirement, and based on last season, is no sure thing.

But it is still a good deal for the Packers, even a #3 is better than the althernative - nothing.

[MJZiggy]

Unless he decides to play--then the alternative is having BF at QB.

[Chubbyhubby]

What is wrong with this picture? I feel with the holdup of Favre's decison from returning or retiring is severly hurting the team. The Packer organization has its hands tied. He needs to make his decsion BEFORE the draft. It has been reported that Aarron Rodgers is not ready and appear lost favor within the high ranks of Packer Brass. Rodgers had a miserable preseason, People assumed last year (media) that Favre would take the young QB under his wing. But Favre has said numerous times that he is not a coach and would not help Rodgers in ANY WAY.

Favre is giving the team a disservice by not committing either way. Favre is comming off a horrible season throwing 29 picks. I think he wants to go down like what Elway did and most recently that Steeler Running Back this past year. That would be a story book ending to a brilliant career.

However that is not going to happen..... Make up your mind ALREADY!!!

[GBRulz]

What is wrong with this picture? I feel with the holdup of Favre's decison from returning or retiring is severly hurting the team. The Packer organization has its hands tied. He needs to make his decsion BEFORE the draft. It has been reported that Aarron Rodgers is not ready and appear lost favor within the high ranks of Packer Brass. Rodgers had a miserable preseason, People assumed last year (media) that Favre would take the young QB under his wing. But Favre has said numerous times that he is not a coach and would not help Rodgers in ANY WAY.

Favre is giving the team a disservice by not committing either way. Favre is comming off a horrible season throwing 29 picks. I think he wants to go down like what Elway did and most recently that Steeler Running Back this past year. That would be a story book ending to a brilliant career.

However that is not going to happen..... Make up your mind ALREADY!!!

I do agree that TT should insist on knowing his decision before the draft. I also think that would justify TT's decision in picking a QB in the first round, which I honestly think he really wants to do. However, if he picked a Qb first, knowing Favre was coming back - it would be a slap in the face that TT basically messed up by picking Rodgers last year and I think he's too proud to admit it.

I guess I never saw the same articles you did about Favre saying he is not a coach and would never help Aaron Rodgers in any way, as you said above. Can you show me this, please?

I remember Favre saying it is not his job to mentor Rodgers and would gladly answer any questions he has, but that's entirely different. Would love to see that article where Farve said that though. Thanks

[MJZiggy]

I'm still waiting for someone to tell me who this great QB is that will do a better job when you've traded away a Hall of Famer for a couple of draft picks. Aaron Rodgers is not fully cooked yet. The game has not slowed down for him. He is not making his reads quickly enough or getting the ball out fast enough which with the protection he has is sacks and fumbles waiting to happen. I watched him in Balto and don't care how Brett played in that game I'm talking about Rodgers here. He reminded me of David Carr. And lets see, where do the Texans draft this year? Oh yeah, that's right.

You do NOT want to throw him in before he's ready. That leaves you with either a hall-bound experienced career qb with fixable problems or Rodgers with whom you can choose between sacks, fumbles and 3-and-outs until he gets things figured out. I think I'd take the ints with a chance to win over that.