McNabb To Lions?!

[Partial]

I 100% agree. We've got to give the defense props though because they did win quite a few games with Koy Detmer and AJ Feeley at QB when McNabb was out.

[MadtownPacker]

Their defense wasn't THAT good. Again, four straight NFC title games. Can't take that away from him. He's had the stats--despite not being surrounded by great talent. One great receiver for one year. Bottom line is that his team's win.

If it wasnt that good they wouldnt have got to those NFC title games. I recall they had a lot of turnovers and where hard to score TDs on. Im not saying mcnabb is not good just that he is on the downslop instead of up. The lions need someone that is on the come up. Like Schaub.

Mcnabb had his chances to win the big one. Especially at the end of the SB where he got the ball with like 3 minutes to go and a long TD drive that would have likely won the game 28-24. Instead he completely collapsed during his moment of truth and history was written. Now I just dont see him getting back there again. He has broke down the last couple of seasons. No matter how good he is he is useless if he is on IR.

[SD GB fan]

on the downslope? you can say he doesnt move as well or is getting older but im not sure about being on the downslope. mcnabb was the hottest QB in the NFL before he got injured i believe.

[Fritz]

If you're Philly you ask for a #3 as well as Detroit's first rounder. You trade McNabb you better not bank on a home run with one pick. But if you can get that pick plus a third, then trade down and pick up another second, you'd have three firsts, and maybe a couple of thirds. That's the kind of draft that can inject your team with life.

[Partial]

If you're Philly you ask for a #3 as well as Detroit's first rounder. You trade McNabb you better not bank on a home run with one pick. But if you can get that pick plus a third, then trade down and pick up another second, you'd have three firsts, and maybe a couple of thirds. That's the kind of draft that can inject your team with life.

If you're Philly you're out of your damn mind. You trade McNabb to the Raiders for their entire draft this year, their entire draft next year, and their first and second rounders for the following five years. If I was a GM, you could not offer me enough to give up my superstar, especially when he is MVP caliber player at the most important position. With Donovan McNabb at the helm, that franchise will always make oodles of money, get on TV plenty, and always be in contention.

[Partial]

If you're Philly you ask for a #3 as well as Detroit's first rounder. You trade McNabb you better not bank on a home run with one pick. But if you can get that pick plus a third, then trade down and pick up another second, you'd have three firsts, and maybe a couple of thirds. That's the kind of draft that can inject your team with life.

Inject it with life while losing its heart and soul. If that team plays that good with Garcia, with McNabb they will be a superbowl contender.