If Sharper is released...

[Kiwon]

If Shaper is released by the Vikings should the Pack consider signing him again? Your thoughts?

[packers11]

Re: If Sharper is released...

If Shaper is released by the Vikings should the Pack consider signing him again? Your thoughts?

he burned all bridges by talking bad about the organization... He used to be my favorite player but age definitely caught up with him... Also he tends to let up big plays... 4th and 25 (T.O)... 4th and 26 (Freddie Mitchell)...

So... my answer would be... NO

[red]

there were a lot of packer fans, including myself, that were glad hen we cut him

he just gave up way too many big plays

we wanted him cut, and we wanted something better

we still haven't found a decent nfl starter

but i wouldn't want him back

[BF4MVP]

I'm not a fan of Sharper's anymore..But if came down to choosing between Sharper and Manuel, I'd take Sharper any day of the week..

[retailguy]

Re: If Sharper is released...

If Shaper is released by the Vikings should the Pack consider signing him again? Your thoughts?

He should sign with Denver, or better Green Bay South (Houston)...

[hurleyfan]

Re: If Sharper is released...

If Shaper is released by the Vikings should the Pack consider signing him again? Your thoughts?

NO NO a THOUSAND TIMES NO!!

He really skewered the Packers when he left, whining about respect, team heading in the wrong direction, blah blah blah..

He forgot about all those big plays he gave up, and who can count the number of missed tackles?? And he had about 2 decent years?

What a sec, can he be any worse than Manual

[ahaha]

I would only like him on the Packers if he signed for the minimum and we just kept him on the bench. A humiliating end for a proud veteren. He deserved it. He whined and cried, and ripped the Packer organization because they cut him. Sharper wasn't living up to his big contract and the Pack was having salary cap problems. He burned his bridges with Green Bay because of that. What a baby! What a jack-ass! Sign him for the min, stuff him on the bench, and do an NFL films segment about him.

[BobDobbs]

You know I always liked him. I felt the good outweighed the bad. Even the year that he was cut he scored three touchdowns. I think he would beat out Manuel and probably Underwood for a starting spot.

But after everythng that has happened I don't see how you can bring him back. I haven't really watched him at Minnesota, but I have to assume he's feeling the effects of age. I think it is worth trying to find a long term partner for Collins.

I wish him luck though.

[GrnBay007]

hmm.....wasn't this once a huge argument between Harv and Mad?

ooops..... :P haha

[HarveyWallbangers]

Sharper was good in 2005. He didn't do as well in 2006, but he was still above average. Now, I'm hoping the Pack take a chance on Michael Lewis or pick up Ken Hamlin, but Sharper would still be a big upgrade over Manuel, Culver, and Underwood. Honestly, I doubt any of those guys will ever play as well as Sharper did even in 2006.

[Fritz]

Bringing Sharper back would be a very Shermanesque move.

[red]

lets not forget that the guy stuck his nose in every single little bit of news that came out of green bay

remember the javon situation, sharper felt he had to keep the world updated about what he thought about the situation

screw him, like others have said. he burned his bridges

just like javon and mike mckenzie did

[MadtownPacker]

Honestly, I doubt any of those guys will ever play as well as Sharper did even in 2006.

He is a damn choker and is directly responsible for the 2 of the Packers greatest playoff losses.

Anyone that backs sharper is full of crap and should wear purple!!!

[pacfan]

I'm not a fan of Sharper's anymore..But if came down to choosing between Sharper and Manuel, I'd take Sharper any day of the week..

...except on SUnday

[pbmax]

No, no, no, a million times no. The exact antithesis of the player this defense wants. Doesn't like the Cover 2 they are playing in Minny, we are playing a lot of 2 safeties back as well. Sharper as the last line of defense is like playing a Green Army Man as your goalie.