Latest Rumor PFT : Aaron Rodgers for Randy Moss?

[motife]

I'd have to say no. We'd go into camp with Driver, Moss, Jennings, Martin, and then K-Rob comes back October(ish)...Carlyle Holiday seemed to fit pretty well with Brett, keep him around until K-Rob comes back, or keep 6 on your roster.

I don't think they can even remotely count on Robinson.

when can we dump robinson??

Even if Koren Robinson did nothing but return kicks, he'd be a tremendous asset.

I'd bring him back even in mid-season just as a kick return guy. He's very good at it.

[Packnut]

Moss

Here is our best case scenario- trade Rodgers for Moss straight up (assuming Randy will re-work his deal), then sign Schaub after he becomes a FA a year from now.

[ND72]

Atlanta won't let Schuab go without compensation...and right now they're asking for 1st/2nd rounders for him...imagine next year after Vick fails again...

[Packnut]

Schaub

Atlanta won't let Schuab go without compensation...and right now they're asking for 1st/2nd rounders for him...imagine next year after Vick fails again...

Yep, no one is gonna give the Falcons what they want which is why he will be a FA after the 2007 season. I'm not sure anyone in that organization has the guts to bench Vick for Schaub.

[ND72]

he won't be a FA...they'll put a tag of some kind on him so they recieve something in return. I'd bank on that.

[falco]

he won't be a FA...they'll put a tag of some kind on him so they recieve something in return. I'd bank on that.

The tags are incredibly expensive for a QB. Unless they are planning on him starting, I can't see them putting a tag on him.

[ND72]

now see if you read my first post about it, I said when Vick fails again...if Vick fails again, he won't be back as a falcon.

[Rastak]

Hodge is shooting lots of holes in the idea..

hodge is a fucking idiot, he says moss never goes accross the middle, then they show 4 straight plays of moss going over the middle

clayton said two things are certain right now

Green bay is interested in moss

and moss has agreed to rework his contract

"idiot" or not, he makes valid points, and is this the type of character TT wants mixed in with all the "kids"

Agreeing to rework his contract is a good thing, can he rework his attitude to play EVERY play?

if he reworked his attitude back to the level it was at before he was traded against his will to the worst team in the nfl, then i wouldn't mind

people can become asshole when they are put in situations that they don't want to be in

moss wants to be in green bay

You gotta be shitting me, he walked off the field with the game on the line as almost his last official act with the Vikings. That was BEFORE he was traded. In fact, it most likely was the last straw.

[SD GB fan]

it wud be too bad that we wud nvr see how rodgers would do in place of favre, but id support this move. in the short term, moss would make a big impact whereas rodgers would be on the bench. in the long term, the only bad loss is if rodgers turns out to an all-pro. but with favre back this year and maybe even next year, there will be plenty of time to find a replacement for rodgers. hell, ingle martin may have already stepped up by then.

[red]

Hodge is shooting lots of holes in the idea..

hodge is a fucking idiot, he says moss never goes accross the middle, then they show 4 straight plays of moss going over the middle

clayton said two things are certain right now

Green bay is interested in moss

and moss has agreed to rework his contract

"idiot" or not, he makes valid points, and is this the type of character TT wants mixed in with all the "kids"

Agreeing to rework his contract is a good thing, can he rework his attitude to play EVERY play?

if he reworked his attitude back to the level it was at before he was traded against his will to the worst team in the nfl, then i wouldn't mind

people can become asshole when they are put in situations that they don't want to be in

moss wants to be in green bay

You gotta be shitting me, he walked off the field with the game on the line as almost his last official act with the Vikings. That was BEFORE he was traded. In fact, it most likely was the last straw.

his team played like shit against a horrible team in a must win game. there was 2 seconds left on the clock. even if they did recover the onside kick they would have run out of time and lost.

i can't sit here and rip on him for that, i despise losing too, and i've done worse a lot more times then he has. i'm not a good sport and hate losing. so i won't bash him for doing the same thing i could see myself doing in that situation

i can relate to him in that situation, sorry, but i can.. so i can see why he did that

[Rastak]

Hodge is shooting lots of holes in the idea..

hodge is a fucking idiot, he says moss never goes accross the middle, then they show 4 straight plays of moss going over the middle

clayton said two things are certain right now

Green bay is interested in moss

and moss has agreed to rework his contract

"idiot" or not, he makes valid points, and is this the type of character TT wants mixed in with all the "kids"

Agreeing to rework his contract is a good thing, can he rework his attitude to play EVERY play?

if he reworked his attitude back to the level it was at before he was traded against his will to the worst team in the nfl, then i wouldn't mind

people can become asshole when they are put in situations that they don't want to be in

moss wants to be in green bay

You gotta be shitting me, he walked off the field with the game on the line as almost his last official act with the Vikings. That was BEFORE he was traded. In fact, it most likely was the last straw.

his team played like shit against a horrible team in a must win game. there was 2 seconds left on the clock. even if they did recover the onside kick they would have run out of time and lost.

i can't sit here and rip on him for that, i despise losing too, and i've done worse a lot more times then he has. i'm not a good sport and hate losing. so i won't bash him for doing the same thing i could see myself doing in that situation

i can relate to him in that situation, sorry, but i can.. so i can see why he did that

So if Green Bay plays like shit in a must win game it's okay to just leave and say the hell with it?


Cmon Red, be real. Maybe things will be different in GB. Who knows.....but don't ever try and excuse at least that one incident. It can't be.

Most of his other stuff isn't that big a deal.

[RashanGary]

If Moss is a Packer, I'm 100% behind him.

[falco]

Cmon Red, be real. Maybe things will be different in GB. Who knows.....but don't ever try and excuse at least that one incident. It can't be.

Most of his other stuff isn't that big a deal.

I agree with you Rastak. I'm all for Moss coming to the packers; if anything it will make this an exciting season. But anyone trying to excuse him walking off the team isn't seeing clearly; if that had been a packer, the people on this board would be burning him in effigy.

EDIT: Especially if there is playoff implications.

[motife]

the greatest show on tundra.

[RashanGary]

Anythink he did in other citys will be forgotten by me. If he's not a Packer then he's a bad apple. If we get him then all is forgotten.

He'd immediately step in as our best player.