It's a bit doom and gloom. We won't make a trade. Not for the cost. The FA RBs all have their warts. If we wait until the draft, then that's one less pick to use on other needs--which we still have (TE, S, CB, WR, possibly LB).
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Who Will Be Our #1 RB?
Collapse
X
-
What's this do for the Texans, Dominick Williams(Davis)? Are they going to keep him and green? Wasn't it last year or the year before they paid him some big money? I know he messed up his knee last year, but if he's going to be healthy he'd be a great back for Green Bay, with his running and receiving ability. Either way if the Texans release him he'd be worth a shot with an incentive laden deal.
Comment
-
Nobody has really mentioned D.Foster of Carolina yet. With the emergence of Williams as the main guy going into this year compiled with Foster's high salary and low durability....AND Carolina's depth at RB....Foster may be a guy who is cut after June 1. If that's the case, the Packers could do well to take a look at him. He's always been good. The guy just can't stay healthy.
The interesting thing is who will be the pounder next year? Morency isn't a pounder. Depending on who the Packers add to their RB stable, they may need a guy who can pound out the 1 yard runs.Life is a puzzle. Every day you get up and pick up the pieces from the day before.
and
You can't keep idiots from being idiots. You can only hope to contain them.
and
Idiots DO exist. I've seen them.
Comment
-
Agreed. I don't know that his 'happy feet' are that bad, but it seems his concentration watching the ball into his hands is not good. Signing him would be the end of that screen play we all love watching so much.Originally posted by HarveyWallbangersJamal Lewis would be horrible in a one cut system. He's like Jerome Bettis. A big back who likes to dance around (feet bouncing all around) before looking for somebody to hit. He's also a terrible receiver.--
Imagine for a moment a world without hypothetical situations...
Comment
-
Forgot about McGahee. Anyone hear why the Bills are shopping him? This confuses me - unless they want to make the ATrain a starter?
I think he would be a nice fit. Will certainly command a first day pick, however.--
Imagine for a moment a world without hypothetical situations...
Comment
-
It would be so dumb for packers to trade for McGahee when we could of just signed AG and keep all our draft picks. Trading for a RB would make no sense to me what so ever.Originally posted by GuinessForgot about McGahee. Anyone hear why the Bills are shopping him? This confuses me - unless they want to make the ATrain a starter?
I think he would be a nice fit. Will certainly command a first day pick, however.Draft Brandin Cooks WR OSU!
Comment
-
Yeah...trading for a guy 5 years younger than Green, and a better fit for the zone system would be a dumb idea....Originally posted by PaCkFan_n_MDIt would be so dumb for packers to trade for McGahee when we could of just signed AG and keep all our draft picks. Trading for a RB would make no sense to me what so ever.Originally posted by GuinessForgot about McGahee. Anyone hear why the Bills are shopping him? This confuses me - unless they want to make the ATrain a starter?
I think he would be a nice fit. Will certainly command a first day pick, however.
"I would love to have a guy that always gets the key hit, a pitcher that always makes his best pitch and a manager that can always make the right decision. The problem is getting him to put down his beer and come out of the stands and do those things." - Danny Murraugh
Comment
-
That is simply an assumption Cheesehead Craig.Originally posted by Cheesehead CraigI believe that Morency has the skills to get the job done. With a training camp under his belt, he'll have a fine season.
If YOU were the GM of the Packers, how would you logically back that up?** Since 2006 3 X Pro Pickem' Champion; 4 X Runner-Up and 3 X 3rd place.
** To download Jesus Loves Me ring tones, you'll need a cell phone mame
** If God doesn't fish, play poker or pull for " the Packers ", exactly what does HE do with his buds?
** Rather than love, money or fame - give me TRUTH: Henry D. Thoreau
Comment
-
Originally posted by woodbuck27That is simply an assumption Cheesehead Craig.Originally posted by Cheesehead CraigI believe that Morency has the skills to get the job done. With a training camp under his belt, he'll have a fine season.
If YOU were the GM of the Packers, how would you logically back that up?
I actually said after the Philly game that Morency has all the tools to be our starting HB. I don't think he has the ability to be a 20 carries a game guy, but in a split back situation, I think he could get us 15 a game and be very good."I would love to have a guy that always gets the key hit, a pitcher that always makes his best pitch and a manager that can always make the right decision. The problem is getting him to put down his beer and come out of the stands and do those things." - Danny Murraugh
Comment
-
In the beginning of next season McGahee will be 27, so in about two years everyone is going to be talking about how we need to draft a younger back. If you keep AG, either this year or next you could draft a young back to play behind green for a year. That way you have Green and your future. If you trade for McGahee you have to give up a high pick for him and in about 2 years use another high pick on a RB. Like I said, it would be dumb.Originally posted by ND72Yeah...trading for a guy 5 years younger than Green, and a better fit for the zone system would be a dumb idea....Originally posted by PaCkFan_n_MDIt would be so dumb for packers to trade for McGahee when we could of just signed AG and keep all our draft picks. Trading for a RB would make no sense to me what so ever.Originally posted by GuinessForgot about McGahee. Anyone hear why the Bills are shopping him? This confuses me - unless they want to make the ATrain a starter?
I think he would be a nice fit. Will certainly command a first day pick, however.
Draft Brandin Cooks WR OSU!
Comment
-
McGahee is overrated, though. I question his toughness, big time.Originally posted by ND72Yeah...trading for a guy 5 years younger than Green, and a better fit for the zone system would be a dumb idea....Originally posted by PaCkFan_n_MDIt would be so dumb for packers to trade for McGahee when we could of just signed AG and keep all our draft picks. Trading for a RB would make no sense to me what so ever.Originally posted by GuinessForgot about McGahee. Anyone hear why the Bills are shopping him? This confuses me - unless they want to make the ATrain a starter?
I think he would be a nice fit. Will certainly command a first day pick, however.
Comment
-
Yep, he had far more big plays than Green last year.Originally posted by ND72Originally posted by woodbuck27That is simply an assumption Cheesehead Craig.Originally posted by Cheesehead CraigI believe that Morency has the skills to get the job done. With a training camp under his belt, he'll have a fine season.
If YOU were the GM of the Packers, how would you logically back that up?
I actually said after the Philly game that Morency has all the tools to be our starting HB. I don't think he has the ability to be a 20 carries a game guy, but in a split back situation, I think he could get us 15 a game and be very good.
Comment
-
These guys seem to have my back here. Morency showed great vision and good instincts when given the chance last year. You could see it in his play, that's logical enough. Just as it's logical that the OL will be better run blockers this year after having time to adjust to the new scheme, Morency will be better with having more time and reps.Originally posted by PartialYep, he had far more big plays than Green last year.Originally posted by ND72Originally posted by woodbuck27That is simply an assumption Cheesehead Craig.Originally posted by Cheesehead CraigI believe that Morency has the skills to get the job done. With a training camp under his belt, he'll have a fine season.
If YOU were the GM of the Packers, how would you logically back that up?
I actually said after the Philly game that Morency has all the tools to be our starting HB. I don't think he has the ability to be a 20 carries a game guy, but in a split back situation, I think he could get us 15 a game and be very good.
I just fail to see why we need to completely reinvent the wheel at RB when we already have a pretty good one for the system. I'm not advocating against drafting a RB or signing one in FA, but to completely discount him in the offensive gameplan as a legit option is foolish.All hail the Ruler of the Meadow!
Comment
-
They will need to bring someone in to split carries.Originally posted by Cheesehead CraigThese guys seem to have my back here. Morency showed great vision and good instincts when given the chance last year. You could see it in his play, that's logical enough. Just as it's logical that the OL will be better run blockers this year after having time to adjust to the new scheme, Morency will be better with having more time and reps.Originally posted by PartialYep, he had far more big plays than Green last year.Originally posted by ND72Originally posted by woodbuck27That is simply an assumption Cheesehead Craig.Originally posted by Cheesehead CraigI believe that Morency has the skills to get the job done. With a training camp under his belt, he'll have a fine season.
If YOU were the GM of the Packers, how would you logically back that up?
I actually said after the Philly game that Morency has all the tools to be our starting HB. I don't think he has the ability to be a 20 carries a game guy, but in a split back situation, I think he could get us 15 a game and be very good.
I just fail to see why we need to completely reinvent the wheel at RB when we already have a pretty good one for the system. I'm not advocating against drafting a RB or signing one in FA, but to completely discount him in the offensive gameplan as a legit option is foolish.
No sense in drafting an 8.0 prospect like Lynch at 20 when we can land a 9.5 prospect at 20 next year in the deepest running back draft ever.
Travis Henry would be a good, one year stopgap.
Comment


Comment