Top QBs of All-Time

[HarveyWallbangers]

Vote! Unless your name is Rastak or Bulldog.

http://sports.espn.go.com/chat/sportsnation/listranker?id=479

Right now, it stands:
1 Montana
2 Marino
3 Elway
4 Unitas
5 Favre
6 Bradshaw
7 Young (Steve Friggin' Young?)
8 Starr
9 Aikman
10 Staubach
11 Brady
12 Namath (overrated, had more interceptions than TDs in his career)
13 Manning
14 Tarkenton
15 Kelly
16 Fouts
17 Graham
18 Moon
19 Baugh
20 Griese

The old guys get no love. Graham should be much higher. Baugh should be a higher also.

[Rastak]

Re: Top QBs of All-Time

Too late .....

Johnny U is my choice.....

[Anti-Polar Bear]

Brett Favre would be the greatest of all time if he has another ring.

It is a tragedy, at least in the football lore, to have to watch Favre go through a 4-12 campaign. You can send your thanks to one Mr. Polar Bear.

[Charles Woodson]

Favre is now 4!

[Harlan Huckleby]

i'm no historian, but I think Otto Graham has to be in top 5.

[Guiness]

These type of polls are worth the paper they're written on. As mentioned, the old guys get no love - they played a different game, w/o the benefit of pass interference calls.

One guy who should be higher though: Moon. He got shafted at the begining of his career, and dominated in the CFL back when it was a comparable league.

[RashanGary]

Favre will be a undisputed top 5 guy if he can break at least half of Marino's records.

Right now it's tough. There are a couple guys you know are in the conversation.

Montanta
Unitas
Elway

Marino Favre and a whole slew of others are just behind. I think Favre can cement his name as one of the undisputed top 4 by breaking a few more records. If he won another ring it could be argued he's the best of all time.

[HarveyWallbangers]

I'd agree with your breakdown on the QBs, NC.

[oregonpackfan]

I am old enought to have seen Johnny Unitas when I was a kid.

I am not old enough to have seen Otto Graham.

He was the greatest QB I have ever seen play.

Oregonpackfan

[b bulldog]

Graham,Montana,Unitas,Elway,bradshaw,Favre,Marino, Brady,Moon

[GBRulz]

favre passed Unitas for the #4 spot.

I'm sorry but I don't agree with Dan Marino being at #2 right now. Just wait until his records are shattered this year!!!

[Charles Woodson]

Favre is now 4!

Damn michele thats old news

[b bulldog]

Montana's numbers are sick!

[HarveyWallbangers]

My Rank:
1 Otto Graham
2 Joe Montana
3 Johnny Unitas
4 John Elway
5 Brett Favre
6 Dan Marino
7 Peyton Manning
8 Bart Starr
9 Tom Brady
10 Terry Bradshaw
11 Fran Tarkenton
12 Steve Young
13 Dan Fouts
14 Troy Aikman
15 Roger Staubach

Unless he wins another Super Bowl title, I can't see Favre moving into the top 3. If he finishes his career with a couple of solid seasons and leads the Packers into the playoffs, I'll probably move him ahead of Elway.

[mraynrand]

Why is Unitas dividing us?