Most Overrated NFL player

[packers11]

This question may have already been brought up, but id like to bring it up again ...



SI Players Poll
[Based on a survey of 361 NFL players]
Posted: Tuesday October 24, 2006 2:34PM; Updated: Monday October 30, 2006 4:30PM

Terrell Owens, Cowboys.....10%
Brian Urlacher, Bears.....8%
Ray Lewis, Ravens.....7%
Michael Vick, Falcons.....7%
Eli Manning, Giants.....4%
Keyshawn Johnson, Panthers.....4%
Peyton Manning, Colts.....4%
Ben Roethlisberger, Steelers.....3%
Charles Woodson, Packers.....3%
Warren Sapp, Raiders.....3%


PS : I had to take ELI,Big Ben, and Sapp out of the poll because it won't fit...

[packers11]

and to think they traded Matt Schaub... They must be hitting their heads against a wall...


I hope he turns out to be good so they can regret giving away two good quarterbacks in each decade... ironic huh?

THEY WILL NEVER TRADE AWAY another one if he turns out to be above average...

[Merlin]

How could it NOT be Vick? People are always whining about the media sniffing Favre's jock, that goes 100 times more for Vick. He gets a pass on EVERYTHING! Including his anemic passing skills.

[BF4MVP]

Michael Vick SHOULD win in a landslide...At least our posters know how to vote..

I can't believe Woodson got 3 percent on the SI poll...He picked off 8 passes and didn't make the pro bowl...How is that overrated?

[HarveyWallbangers]

How could you take Eli Manning out of the poll?

I would have taken Peyton (because he is good) or Keyshawn Johnson (because nobody thinks he's that good anymore) out of the poll.

[packers11]

How could you take Eli Manning out of the poll?

I would have taken Peyton (because he is good) or Keyshawn Johnson (because nobody thinks he's that good anymore) out of the poll.

I did take Keyshawn out, and I kept Peyton in because many people says he has the BEST o-line and WRS in the game... A lot of people are calling eli a bust/bad anyway...

[woodbuck27]

Easy.

Michael Vick. Outrageously overrated.

[Merlin]

Next o Vick should be Peyton IMO. Any team that gets pressure on him and he folds. He did in the Super Bowl. Sure, he completed a lot of passes, to the check downs. He ran away from his own fumble even though he was in the best position to recover it and later in the game when he tried to go down the field he got picked off. I wonder what would happen to him without the players he has around him? It was obvious in the Super Bowl he is no MVP. He can't scramble and if he has to make a pressure throw, it's usually fugly.

Favre does his best when he can improvise. It's when he sits back there all day and tries to force something that worries me.

[MTPackerfan]

michael vick without a doubt

[packinpatland]

Maybe Randy Moss? The Patriots seem to think he's the 'second coming'.

[BallHawk]

Michael Vick, without question. Can't pass, doesn't have a good understanding of NFL Defenses, is a complete jerk, etc. Oh, and he hasn't made a Super Bowl.

[Bretsky]

Eli Manning

[Joemailman]

Eli Manning

Chris Chambers.

[Bretsky]

Eli Manning

Chris Chambers.

[b bulldog]

Eli Manning would be up there along with Vick and Reggie Bush.