Prisco's Top 50 NFL players

[Rastak]

This is the reason I stopped paying attention the media hype of the NFL. This asshole hasn't sat down and watched half of these players much less the other 1500 or so players that suit up in the NFL. I don't even know how a person could even formulate a list like this. What is it based on? stats, pro bowls, all-pro? I guess I don't understand how Larry FitzGerald makes the list. Compare him to Donald Driver, he hasn't shit in this league yet this dimprick has him rank based on what he could do with Matt Lienart at QB.

If I was drafting up a team right now I'd take Fitzgerald over Driver every time. Don't get me wrong, I think Driver is a pretty damn good reciever, but watch Fitzgerald play. He's pretty talented and needs a QB to step up.

[Bretsky]

This is the reason I stopped paying attention the media hype of the NFL. This asshole hasn't sat down and watched half of these players much less the other 1500 or so players that suit up in the NFL. I don't even know how a person could even formulate a list like this. What is it based on? stats, pro bowls, all-pro? I guess I don't understand how Larry FitzGerald makes the list. Compare him to Donald Driver, he hasn't shit in this league yet this dimprick has him rank based on what he could do with Matt Lienart at QB.

If I was drafting up a team right now I'd take Fitzgerald over Driver every time. Don't get me wrong, I think Driver is a pretty damn good reciever, but watch Fitzgerald play. He's pretty talented and needs a QB to step up.

I'd agree with this. Love Driver, but I'd take Fitzgerald every day

[Oscar]

My take on Driver....He has been kind of a one man show.. Who started opposite of him that other teams really had to respect?? I think Fitzgerald has a guy lining up across the line that is pretty good..I could be wrong...I'm posting this without any statistical support.. Maybe Fitzgerald has been a one man show as well.... Just thought I'd join in on the fun...

[HarveyWallbangers]

This is the reason I stopped paying attention the media hype of the NFL. This asshole hasn't sat down and watched half of these players much less the other 1500 or so players that suit up in the NFL. I don't even know how a person could even formulate a list like this. What is it based on? stats, pro bowls, all-pro? I guess I don't understand how Larry FitzGerald makes the list. Compare him to Donald Driver, he hasn't shit in this league yet this dimprick has him rank based on what he could do with Matt Lienart at QB.

If I was drafting up a team right now I'd take Fitzgerald over Driver every time. Don't get me wrong, I think Driver is a pretty damn good reciever, but watch Fitzgerald play. He's pretty talented and needs a QB to step up.

I'd agree with this. Love Driver, but I'd take Fitzgerald every day

I'd agree that I'd take him in your scenario. Driver is a lot older. However, what are these rankings based on? If it's based on production and who has been the better player or was the better player last year, then Driver gets the nod. Bottom line; Larry has one 1000+ yard season in his three seasons--while Driver has had three consecutive 1200+ yard seasons (which included one where Walker was the featured receiver). If it's based on potential, than Larry Fitz is the choice. I guess I don't have a quibble either way. I'd probably take Larry Fitz also, but Driver is still vastly underrated. He just does everything well, but doesn't wow anybody apparently. I think his athleticism is the most underrated aspect. People act like he's slow, but I don't remember him getting caught from behind, he has some crazy juke moves, and he's a world-class leaper.

[Rastak]

This is the reason I stopped paying attention the media hype of the NFL. This asshole hasn't sat down and watched half of these players much less the other 1500 or so players that suit up in the NFL. I don't even know how a person could even formulate a list like this. What is it based on? stats, pro bowls, all-pro? I guess I don't understand how Larry FitzGerald makes the list. Compare him to Donald Driver, he hasn't shit in this league yet this dimprick has him rank based on what he could do with Matt Lienart at QB.

If I was drafting up a team right now I'd take Fitzgerald over Driver every time. Don't get me wrong, I think Driver is a pretty damn good reciever, but watch Fitzgerald play. He's pretty talented and needs a QB to step up.

I'd agree with this. Love Driver, but I'd take Fitzgerald every day

I'd agree that I'd take him in your scenario. Driver is a lot older. However, what are these rankings based on? If it's based on production and who has been the better player or was the better player last year, then Driver gets the nod. Bottom line; Larry has one 1000+ yard season in his three seasons--while Driver has had three consecutive 1200+ yard seasons (which included one where Walker was the featured receiver). If it's based on potential, than Larry Fitz is the choice. I guess I don't have a quibble either way. I'd probably take Larry Fitz also, but Driver is still vastly underrated. He just does everything well, but doesn't wow anybody apparently. I think his athleticism is the most underrated aspect. People act like he's slow, but I don't remember him getting caught from behind, he has some crazy juke moves, and he's a world-class leaper.

I think they are based who is the better guy to have RIGHT NOW....my guess anyway. I certainly won't badmouth Driver.

[Patler]

My take on Driver....He has been kind of a one man show.. Who started opposite of him that other teams really had to respect?? I think Fitzgerald has a guy lining up across the line that is pretty good..I could be wrong...I'm posting this without any statistical support.. Maybe Fitzgerald has been a one man show as well.... Just thought I'd join in on the fun...

Ya, Fitzgerald has been pretty much a one-man show!

[mraynrand]

Quick glance shows just three QBs on the entire list, including 'just missed' players. Is that an indication of a QB poor league or downplaying a QBs importance. Just thinking about it briefly, I'd have to argue the former - there are a lot of sucky QBs playing in the NFL right now.