Will Spitz Lose His Job?

[Scott Campbell]

Costen's been playing well, and it might be hard for Spitz to get back into the lineup.

From McCarthy's press conference today:

(Did Coston play better than Spitz had?)
Well, Jason's calf started to tighten up there, probably two or three series before he went out. But I think we talked about Juice in here the other day. Just the fact that he's backing up all five positions on the offensive line tells you what we think of him and what he's done. He's definitely pushing those guys. He'll play the right guard position as we go into Wednesday, based on Spitz's status.

(How did he do when you watched the tape?)
I thought he did OK. He did a solid job, he did a good job. But as a group, that offensive line, the continuity and everything they do together, sometimes it's hard to sit there and say one guy played great and the other guy didn't. I know it happens. We have a lot of work to do, but I thought Juice did a nice job when he got in there.

(Is that a position where if Spitz is healthy, could it be 50-50 as far as deciding who to go with?)
Personally, I'm not a big fan of that, but it's something you could definitely justify. There's some sentiment in our room that feels Juice Coston is at that level, to push for a starting position. The flip side of that is the continuity you're trying to establish with five guys. So I'm not opposed to it, and that's something we have talked about.

[Sef0r]

I don't know about you but I think this could be bad news for Scott Wells.

Didn't someone post a rumor (READ: RUMOR) saying that the Packers sort of regret having given Scott Wells all that money? Jason Spitz suits the Center position better so in the future if guys keep progressing, the line could be:

LT, LG, C, RG, RT
Darren Colledge, Allen Babre, Jason Spitz, Junius Coston, Tony Moll

Am I drinking cool aid? For now....yes

[Bretsky]

If we had some veteran depth a few people would have been sat down at times yesterday. The interior OL of Well, Spitz, and Colledge were pushed around like blocking dummies

[VanPackFan]

I'm happy with this IF Spitz is losing his job because he's being pushed by Coston.
I'm unhappy with this IF Spitz is losing his job because he sucks and they want to see if Coston sucks less.
It's a fine line.

[HarveyWallbangers]

I don't know about you but I think this could be bad news for Scott Wells.

Didn't someone post a rumor (READ: RUMOR) saying that the Packers sort of regret having given Scott Wells all that money? Jason Spitz suits the Center position better so in the future if guys keep progressing, the line could be:

LT, LG, C, RG, RT
Darren Colledge, Allen Babre, Jason Spitz, Junius Coston, Tony Moll

Am I drinking cool aid? For now....yes

The rumor about Wells? Never heard of that one. Sorry, you'll have to post that one here if you find it. Maybe that was Joe Arrigo. The Packers coaches like Wells.

[CaliforniaCheez]

Spitz will not be cut. he will not lose his employment.

Taking some time off so the condition does not worsen might be a good thing. It is a long season.

[green_bowl_packer]

I don't know about you but I think this could be bad news for Scott Wells.

Didn't someone post a rumor (READ: RUMOR) saying that the Packers sort of regret having given Scott Wells all that money? Jason Spitz suits the Center position better so in the future if guys keep progressing, the line could be:

LT, LG, C, RG, RT
Darren Colledge, Allen Babre, Jason Spitz, Junius Coston, Tony Moll

Am I drinking cool aid? For now....yes

The rumor about Wells? Never heard of that one. Sorry, you'll have to post that one here if you find it. Maybe that was Joe Arrigo. The Packers coaches like Wells.

http://www.packerupdate.com/packer_update/2007/08/index.html

from the August 16th post What We're Hearing post . . .
Nobody will ever admit it, but we’ve been told that Thompson now regrets giving Scott Wells a $15 million extension last November. The former Tennessee star is an above-average center, but the coaches think that starting right guard Jason Spitz could play the position even better. Plus, young linemen Allen Barbre and Tony Palmer are having very solid camps....

That rumor was from the Packer Update site who seems to have a "connection/scout/Arrigo-esque source" who feeds them info. They've also stated that no one mentions that Clifton and Tauscher are still trying to figure out the zone blocking scheme (or aren't cut out for it) and consistently can't make the block on the back side.

[HarveyWallbangers]

Even that rumor doesn't state that they think Wells isn't good--just that they think Spitz is a better player. Seems outlandish now--since Spitz basically got benched in the first game of the season. Apparently, the coaches aren't that enamored with him.

[Patler]

Even that rumor doesn't state that they think Wells isn't good--just that they think Spitz is a better player. Seems outlandish now--since Spitz basically got benched in the first game of the season. Apparently, the coaches aren't that enamored with him.

When Spitz was drafted many of the comments from scouts etc. were that he would eventually be a center, and might struggle as a guard. They seemed to think center fit his mauling style better, more natural for him. We might see it happen in a year or two.

[falco]

Even that rumor doesn't state that they think Wells isn't good--just that they think Spitz is a better player. Seems outlandish now--since Spitz basically got benched in the first game of the season. Apparently, the coaches aren't that enamored with him.

When Spitz was drafted many of the comments from scouts etc. were that he would eventually be a center, and might struggle as a guard. They seemed to think center fit his mauling style better, more natural for him. We might see it happen in a year or two.

but can he consistently get the snap count wrong? thats certainly wells expertise.

[wist43]

Wells is the weakest link on a weak line.

They may have given him a dump truck full of money, but he's barely able to hold his own against average DT's, and gets the living snot kicked out of him against the fat guys.

He's great in space and on the move... which you would expect from an OL that isn't much bigger than some teams FB's.

I haven't watched the whole game thru, but have watched some, and from what I've watched, Colledge was terrible.

Colledge and Wells were so bad, I haven't gotten around to looking at Spitz or Coston yet... Clifton also looked pretty bleak in the few snaps I watched him.

[Patler]

Wells is the weakest link on a weak line.

They may have given him a dump truck full of money, but he's barely able to hold his own against average DT's, and gets the living snot kicked out of him against the fat guys.

He's great in space and on the move... which you would expect from an OL that isn't much bigger than some teams FB's.

I haven't watched the whole game thru, but have watched some, and from what I've watched, Colledge was terrible.

Colledge and Wells were so bad, I haven't gotten around to looking at Spitz or Coston yet... Clifton also looked pretty bleak in the few snaps I watched him.

They all looked bad at times, Tauscher too. No running game, 4 sacks and 11 QB hits pretty much says it all because no one lineman was primarily at fault. It was a collective effort at sucking by all of them.

[Harlan Huckleby]

nobody said Spitz couldn;t play guard back in December when the line was playing well.

I'm confused about the O-line. We need another couple games to see where they are trending as individuals and as a group.

[Patler]

nobody said Spitz couldn;t play guard back in December when the line was playing well.

I'm confused about the O-line. We need another couple games to see where they are trending as individuals and as a group.

Actually, even the coaching staff said Spitz tailed off at the end of the year last year. Colledge was said to have "come on" as the season progressed. They have always talked about Spitz as an eventual option at center, and he practiced some there last season too. I think he even took a few plays at center when Wells was out with an equipment problem in one game. Its not that he can't play guard, but he might be a better center.

Don't forget, Frank Winters was a part time starter at guard for the Packers and was considered both a center and a guard until Campen was hurt and Winters moved to center full time. SPitz could be headed down the same path.

I agree more than one game is needed for any meaningful assessment of the line for 2007, but my patience will be much shorter this year than last.

[Carolina_Packer]

Yeah, there's really no surprise recipe for success on offense. It starts up front. Some backs are better than others, but all of these backs are in the pros and if they get a hole to run thorugh, they'll be able to use their abilities. If they don't, they'll struggle. Same with Favre. If he gets enough seconds of pass protection, he will usually find the right receiver, assuming that guy can get separation. But again, it all starts up front. This team may yet gel on the O-line, but it will take a few games. Perhaps having dodged a bullet against Philly will be the wake-up call and they will come together better.

If you're going to use so many young guys, call it what it is...rebuilding. When you rebuild with young guys, teams tend to struggle and grow-up. Being consistent in the NFL may be the hardest thing.