Holy %&@#! Who is this guy?!

[Guiness]

Bretsky, I don't know what you enjoy more: ranting about the Fergy/Chambers mistake, or reminding me of which side I took in that debate. Somehow, I think they are connected.

I enjoy ranting about it much more; I dedicated an entire thread once as to why this was the worst draft choice in Packer history and as a basis for my argument used a lot of scout views on how many teams would have taken Mandarich over Sanders, and many thought Reynolds over Morgan was very understandable given GB's needs. But the anti Badger Chambers neglect was unsupportable and inexcusable.

I argued about many with this and have a somewhat photographic memory about who they are. Have great respect for you in that you came out and admitted it.


Cheers,
B

Well put. There's a difference between a bust, and a bad pick.

Mandarich and Reynolds were busts. Many in that spot would've made the same decision. Anyone who says different is playing the 20-20 hindsight game.

Other picks, like Ferguson, Sanders, Lee are bad picks, the result of monkeys left in a room with typerwriters.