Best Packers by position : 1962-2005

[motife]

1962-2005 :

Top QB's :

1 Brett Favre
2 Bart Starr
3 Lynn Dickey
4 Zeke Bratkowski
5 Don Majkowski

[motife]

1962-2005 :

Top Wide Receivers :

1 James Lofton
2 Sterling Sharpe
3 Carroll Dale
4 Antonio Freeman
5 Boyd Dowler
6 Max McGee (based on Super Bowl Highlight plays)
7 Donald Driver
8 Robert Brooks
9 Javon Walker
10 John Jefferson
11 Andre Rison (based on Super Bowl Highlight plays)
12 Bill Schroeder Walter Stanley, Phil Epps, Steve Odom, Ken Payne, Corey Bradford, Bob Long, Don Beebe

[motife]

1962-2005 :

Top Tight Ends :

1 Keith Jackson
2 Jackie Harris
3 Paul Coffman
4 Marv Fleming
5 Mark Chmura
6 Bubba Franks
7 Ron Kramer
8 Rich McGeorge
9 Ed West

[motife]

1962-2005 :

Top RB's :

1 Jim Taylor
2 Ahman Green
3 Paul Hornung
4 John Brockington
5 Dorsey Levens
6 Donny Anderson
7 MacArthur Lane
8 Edgar Bennett
9 Eddie Lee Ivery
10 Gerry Ellis
11 Dave Hampton
12 Chuck Mercein

[motife]

1962-2005 :

Top Offensive Tackles :

1 Forrest Gregg
2 Ken Ruettgers
3 Chad Clifton
4 Mark Tauscher
5 Bob Skoronski
6 Earl Dotson
7 Ross Verba
8 Dick Himes
9 Bill Hayhoe
10 Mark Koncar
11 Greg Koch

[motife]

from 1962 - 2005 :

Top Guards :

1 Gale Gillingham
2 Mike Wahle
3 Jerry Kramer
4 Fuzzy Thurston
5 Ron Hallstrom
6 Bill Lueck
7 Marco Rivera
8 Aaron Taylor
9 Adam Timmerman
10 Rich Moran

[motife]

From 1962-2005 :

Best Centers :

1 Jim Ringo
2 Ken Bowman
3 Frank Winters
4 Bill Curry
5 Mike Flanagan
6 Larry McCarren
7 Mark Cannon
8 James Campen

[motife]

Top Defensive Ends :

1 Reggie White
2 Willie Davis
3 Tim Harris
4 Ezra Johnson
5 Mike Butler
6 Sean Jones
7 Vonnie Holliday
8 Kabeer Gbaja-Biamila
9 Alphonso Carreker
10 Lionel Aldridge
11 Aaron Kampman
12 Robert Brown
13 Alden Roche
14 Clarence Williams
15 Keith McKenzie

[motife]

1962-2005 :

Top LB's :

1 Ray Nitschke
2 Ted Hendricks
3 Dave Robinson
4 Fred Carr
5 John Anderson
6 Lee Roy Caffey
7 Wayne Simmons
8 Johnny Holland
9 Tony Bennett
10 Bryce Paup
11 Brian Williams
11 Nick Barnett
12 Jim Carter
13 George Cumby
14 George Koonce
15 Brian Noble
16 Mike Douglass
17 Dan Currie
18 Rich Wingo

[motife]

From 1962 - 2005 :

Top Defensive Tackles :

1 Bob Brown (his 72 season he was unstopable)
2 Grady Jackson (he made the GB defense respectable in 03, 04, 05)
3 Henry Jordan
4 Santana Dotson
5 Gilbert Brown
6 Dave Hanner
7 Mike McCoy (you might ask, why not Carl Barzilauskas?)
8 John Jurkovic
9 Dave Roller (along with Jurkovic, a fan favorite)

[motife]

From 1962-2005 :

Top Defensive Backs :

1 Herb Adderley
2 LeRoy Butler
3 Willie Wood
4 Willie Buchanan
5 Darren Sharper
6 Ken Ellis
7 Tim Lewis
8 Bob Jeter
9 Doug Evans
10 Mike McKenzie
11 Tyrone Williams
12 Mark Lee
13 Johnnie Gray
14 Craig Newsome
15 Al Harris
16 Al Matthews
17 Chuck Cecil
18 Jim Hill
19 Steve Luke
20 Eugene Robinson
21 Doug Hart
22 Dave Brown
Mark Murphy, Tom Flynn

[motife]

1962 - 2005 :

Top Kickers :

1 Ryan Longwell
2 Chris Jacke
3 Jan Stenerud
4 Paul Hornung
5 Chester Marcol
6 Don Chandler
7 Al Del Greco

[motife]

1962-2005 :

Top Kick Returners :

1 Travis Williams
2 Desmond Howard
3 Allan Rossum

[motife]

1962-2005 :

Top Punters :

1 Craig Hentrich
2 Ron Widby
3 David Beverly
4 Josh Bidwell
5 Sean Landeta
6 Ray Stachowicz
7 Bucky Scribner

[Bretsky]

1962-2005 :

Top Wide Receivers :

1 James Lofton
2 Sterling Sharpe
3 Carroll Dale
4 Antonio Freeman
5 Boyd Dowler
6 Max McGee (based on Super Bowl Highlight plays)
7 Donald Driver
8 Robert Brooks
9 Javon Walker
10 John Jefferson
11 Andre Rison (based on Super Bowl Highlight plays)
12 Bill Schroeder Walter Stanley, Phil Epps, Steve Odom, Ken Payne, Corey Bradford, Bob Long, Don Beebe

With good healthy I wonder if Sharpe was better than Lofton.

Also I'd rate a healthy Brooks better than Driver, although they are almost the same player.

Some of the players rated lower are a lot more talented than Antonio Freeman IMO. But Freeman did perform.