Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

SI : 2007 Draft all over again

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • SI : 2007 Draft all over again

    Draft redux

    Re-projecting the draft based on 2007 performances
    Posted: Friday December 7, 2007 12:12PM; Updated: Friday December 7, 2007 12:45PM

    With four weeks left in the regular season, it's time for a December do-over. In our third annual NFL re-draft, here's what we'd do with the first round, knowing what we know now:

    Don Banks' Revised Draft
    Position Team

    1 Oakland Raiders
    CALVIN JOHNSON, WR Georgia Tech


    Original pick: JaMarcus Russell, QB, LSU
    While Adrian Peterson has been the clear-cut rookie of the year, the Raiders have the fourth-ranked running game with emerging fifth-year vet Justin Fargas. An upgrade in the receiving ranks is still needed, and given JaMarcus Russell's lost year, taking the freakishly gifted Johnson would have been the wiser pick.

    2 Detroit Lions
    ADRIAN PETERSON, RB, Oklahoma


    Original pick: Calvin Johnson, WR, Lions
    The Lions rank dead last in the NFL in rushing (77.2 ypg), and the tandem of Kevin Jones and Tatum Bell pales in comparison to the talents of the most electrifying rookie rusher to hit the league since the Lions selected Barry Sanders third overall in 1989.

    3 Cleveland Browns
    JOE THOMAS, OT, Wisconsin


    Original pick: Joe Thomas, OT, Wisconsin
    Some second-guessed the Browns on draft day for bypassing Brady Quinn to take the Badgers tackle, but Cleveland hit a grand slam with the pick. Thomas has people talking Pro Bowl already, and his early dominance has as much to do with the Browns' playoff contention as anything.

    4 Tampa Bay Buccaneers
    AMOBI OKOYE, DT, Louisville


    Original pick: Gaines Adams, DE, Clemson
    Given the Bucs' need for another receiving threat, it was tempting to give them Dwayne Bowe in this slot. But Okoye has been described as a young Warren Sapp, and Tampa Bay could use a play-making presence at tackle. Four of Okoye's five sacks came in September, but he continues to play staunch run defense.

    5 Arizona Cardinals
    LEVI BROWN, OT, Penn State


    Original pick: Levi Brown, OT, Penn State
    The Cardinals' 25th ranked running game still leaves a lot to be desired, but Brown has been a defensible pick, starting at right tackle in seven of the nine games he's played. Arizona is well-stocked at a lot of the positions that make sense for the second half of our re-draft's top 10.

    6 Washington Redskins
    LARON LANDRY, S, LSU


    Original pick: LaRon Landry, S, LSU
    The Redskins found themselves facing injury issues on their offensive line from training camp on, so Thomas or Brown would have been natural fits had they lasted to No. 6. But Landry has been anything but a disappointment, and the Redskins need him all the more now in light of the Sean Taylor tragedy.

    7 Minnesota Vikings
    DWAYNE BOWE, WR, LSU


    Original pick: Adrian Peterson, RB, Vikings
    Without Peterson's impact to rely on, the Vikings would be in the market for another big-play option. Bowe has been this draft's second-best performer in that department, leading all rookie receivers in catches (54), yardage (786) and touchdowns (4, tied).

    8 Atlanta Falcons
    JAMARCUS RUSSELL, QB, LSU


    Original pick: Jamaal Anderson, DE, Arkansas
    We make it three ex-LSU Tigers in a row with Russell, whose rookie season in Oakland was effectively sacrificed to his contract stalemate. The Falcons' quarterback disaster makes this a no-brainer. Enough of Joey Harrington, Byron Leftwich and Chris Redman. Bobby Petrino would snap up Russell and have a QB to groom.

    9 Miami Dolphins
    PATRICK WILLIS, LB, Mississippi


    Original pick: Ted Ginn Jr., WR, Ohio State
    The Dolphins obviously have needs everywhere you look, but with veteran middle linebacker Zach Thomas playing in just five games this season, the polished Willis would have filled a very large gap in the middle of Miami's defense.

    10 Houston Texans
    MARSHAWN LYNCH, RB, California


    Original pick: Amobi Okoye, DT, Louisville
    The Ahman Green acquisition hasn't worked out, and Ron Dayne is just a stop-gap option. If the Texans had Lynch, the league's second-most impressive rookie runner, they'd have the makings of a very balanced offense.

    11 San Francisco
    TONY UGOH, OT, Arkansas


    Original pick: Patrick Willis, LB, Mississippi
    Ugoh has excelled at guarding Peyton Manning's blindside in Indy, and with 49ers left tackle Jonas Jennings appearing in only five games before going on IR, the rookie would have filled a need. With Ugoh, the 49ers wouldn't have felt the need to trade their 2008 first-rounder to New England for the rights to select Joe Staley at No. 28.

    12 Buffalo Bills
    JON BEASON, LB, Miami


    Original pick: Marshawn Lynch, RB, Cal
    With Lynch gone to the No. 10 Texans, and second-rounder Paul Posluszny lost for the year early on with a broken forearm, Beason is a judicious use of the pick. If you're wondering why I don't give them quarterback Trent Edwards, who they wound up getting in the third round, it's a still a bit high for the ex-Stanford star.

    13 St. Louis Rams
    GAINES ADAMS , DE, Clemson


    Original pick: Adam Carriker, DE, Nebraska
    After a very slow start, Adams has started to come on in Tampa Bay, starting the past four games and logging three of his 4 1/2 sacks in that span. The Rams' season fell apart early due to offensive-line injuries, but they took Adam Carriker in this slot because they needed defensive-line help, and Adams has too much upside to overlook.

    14 New York Jets
    DARRELLE REVIS, CB, Pittsburgh


    Original pick: Darrelle Revis, CB, Pitt
    Let's not fix something that's not broken. Revis, the top-rated cornerback in the draft, has more than lived up to that label, starting all 12 of New York's games and notching 12 passes-defensed and two interceptions.

    15 Pittsburgh Steelers
    DAVID HARRIS, LB, Michigan


    Original pick: Lawrence Timmons, LB, Florida State
    Since taking over for the injured Jonathan Vilma inside, Harris has been a force with the Jets, totaling three sacks and a forced fumble in his five starts. Along with Willis and Beason, he continues the recent rookie trend of impact inside linebackers (Lofa Tatupu in 2005, DeMeco Ryans in 2006). Harris is a nice upgrade over LB Lawrence Timmons, who has had a very low-profile rookie season.

    16 Green Bay Packers
    TANARD JACKSON, FS, Syracuse


    Original pick: Justin Harrell, DT, Tennessee
    We're shaking things up a little here, pushing Jackson from the fourth round (where the Bucs took him) into the top half of the first. Jackson has a nose for the football and makes plays all over the field. He'd address one of Green Bay's few weak spots on defense, where free safety Nick Collins has missed time with a knee injury.

    17 Denver Broncos
    JAMAAL ANDERSON , DE Arkansas


    Original pick: Jarvis Moss, DE, Florida
    Anderson is still waiting to post his first NFL sack, but he has started all 12 games, with flashes of play-making ability. Defensive end Jarvis Moss, Denver's original pick, started just one of six games before going on IR. As much as the Broncos need help on run defense at tackle, Anderson's potential is too good to pass on.

    18 Cincinnati Bengals
    LEON HALL , CB, Michigan


    Original pick: Leon Hall, CB, Michigan
    Things are dismal once again on defense for the Bengals, but Hall didn't represent a miss in April's first round. He has four interceptions and 10 passes-defensed, and has started half of Cincinnati's 12 games. Injuries wiped out the Bengals at linebacker, but all the first-round prospects are off our board.

    19 Tennessee Titans
    REGGIE NELSON, S, Florida


    Original pick: Michael Griffin, S, Texas
    We know the Titans are happy with their first-round pick, safety Michael Griffin, who they've worked in at cornerback this season. But Nelson would upgrade the free safety spot, and as an added bonus, would weaken division rival Jacksonville. Nelson has four interceptions, one sack and nine passes-defensed in 11 starts.

    20 New York Giants
    TED GINN JR., WR, Ohio State


    Original pick: Aaron Ross, CB, Texas
    The Giants took Texas cornerback Aaron Ross in this slot, and he's shown up on numerous occasions as a rookie. But getting the speedster Ginn to help take some of the receiving burden off Plaxico Burress makes sense, too. Ginn would instantly upgrade New York's return units, too.

    21 Jacksonville Jaguars
    JAMES JONES, WR, San Jose State


    Original pick: Reggie Nelson, S, Florida
    Sorry, but if Dennis Northcutt is your leading receiver, that means you need help at the position. Jones, a third-round pick by Green Bay, has 43 catches for 633 yards. Both totals would lead the Jaguars.

    22 Cleveland Browns
    ARRON SEARS, G, Tennessee


    Original pick: Brady Quinn, QB, Notre Dame
    No Brady Quinn deal this time around. Not with Derek Anderson rendering Quinn an after-thought this season. The Browns' offensive line has been great, but Cleveland lost Seth McKinney at right guard, and has plugged in former tackle Ryan Tucker. Sears, a second-round pick, has started since opening day in Tampa Bay, with solid results.

    23 Kansas City Chiefs
    BRADY QUINN, QB, Notre Dame


    Original pick: Dwayne Bowe, WR, LSU
    Had Quinn made it past No. 22 in April, the Chiefs would have pounced. And after watching both Damon Huard and Brodie Croyle struggle for the most part this season, you can understand why.

    24 New England Patriots
    AARON ROSS, CB, Texas


    Original pick: Brandon Meriweather, S, Miami
    Now that New England has won its 12th game of the season, the clause in Asante Samuel's contract that forbids the Patriots from using the franchise tag on him again has been activated. Thus, he's likely headed for free agency. Knowing that, Ross would be a sensible replacement to groom for the vacant starting job.

    25 Carolina Panthers
    SIDNEY RICE, WR, South Carolina


    Original pick: Jon Beason, LB, Miami
    The Panthers would have coveted a crack at Quinn, but he's gone to K.C. Although defensive lineman Adam Carriker would be tempting, Carolina is still searching for someone to draw some coverage away from go-to receiver Steve Smith. Rice has really come on of late for the Vikings. The second-rounder has caught touchdown passes in three of his past four games.

    26 Dallas Cowboys
    MICHAEL GRIFFIN, S, Texas


    Original pick: Anthony Spencer, DE, Purdue
    The Cowboys' secondary remains their glaring weakness, and the pass coverage of safeties Roy Williams and Ken Hamlin is the weakest of the weak. Griffin, who played for the home-state Longhorns, has good range and speed, and can also help you with his ability to return kickoffs.

    27 New Orleans Saints
    NICK FOLK, K, Arizona


    Original pick: Robert Meachem, WR, Tennessee
    I know, I know, you can't possibly take a kicker in the first round. But have you seen Olindo Mare's work this season? He's made 8 of 15 field goals in his first year in New Orleans. That's a recipe for making it his last year in New Orleans. The strong-legged Folk, who went in the sixth round to Dallas, is 20 of 23, and 18 of 19 from 49 yards or closer.

    28 San Francisco 49ers
    TRENT EDWARDS, QB, Stanford


    Original pick: Joe Staley, OT, Central Michigan
    With the 49ers having already landed offensive tackle Tony Ugoh earlier in my re-draft, they don't need to go after OT Joe Staley with this pick. But given their quarterback miseries, how about taking a chance on Edwards, the local kid from Stanford? True, taking another first-round quarterback would would signal the end of the Alex Smith era, but Smith is starting to run low on time anyway.

    29 Baltimore Ravens
    ADAM CARRIKER, DL, Nebraska


    Original pick: Ben Grubbs, OG, Auburn
    The Ravens have been very happy with Auburn guard Ben Grubbs, who they took at No. 29, and there would be no shame in standing pat. But Carriker is a top 20 talent who has fallen down our board, and he gives the Ravens a replacement for Trevor Pryce, who's out for the season due to injury and might be nearing the point where his spirit is willing but his body is beginning to falter.

    30 San Diego Chargers
    ANTHONY GONZALEZ, WR, Ohio State


    Original pick: Craig Davis, WR, LSU
    The Chargers taking LSU receiver Craig Davis hasn't worked out so far. He has just 13 catches for 127 yards, and San Diego is again being led in receptions by a tight end and a running back. Gonzalez isn't setting the world on fire with the Colts, but his receiving stats are almost twice what Davis has produced.

    31 Chicago Bears
    Greg Olsen, TE, Miami


    Original pick: Greg Olsen, TE, Miami
    The defending NFC champions have a slew of concerns, but the future of their tight end position is not one of them. Olsen has enjoyed a solid debut, leading all rookie tight ends in production with 31 catches for 315 yards and a pair of scoring grabs. He and Oakland tight end Zach Miller have been as good as advertised.

    32 Indianapolis Colts
    JOE STALEY, OT, Central Michigan


    Original pick: Anthony Gonzalez, WR, Ohio State
    Tarik Glenn's surprise retirement just before training camp made it all the more important that the Colts selected Arkansas tackle Tony Ugoh in the second round. But with Ugoh off our board at No. 11 to San Francisco, we have Indy opting for Staley, who went No. 28 to the 49ers and has impressively started all 12 games at right tackle.

  • #2
    I would still rather have Reggie Nelson over either Harrell or Tanard Jackson.
    My signature has NUDITY in it...whatcha gonna do?

    Comment


    • #3
      Nice to see JJ is considered 1st round talent!

      I tend to disagree that we should have gone after a Safety with the reasoning given. Rouse will work out just fine....

      I like the work the writers did overall.

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: SI : 2007 Draft all over again

        Originally posted by packers11
        Draft redux


        21 Jacksonville Jaguars
        JAMES JONES, WR, San Jose State


        Original pick: Reggie Nelson, S, Florida
        Sorry, but if Dennis Northcutt is your leading receiver, that means you need help at the position. Jones, a third-round pick by Green Bay, has 43 catches for 633 yards. Both totals would lead the Jaguars.
        How fitting. I remember the media backlash when GB picked him. Myself, I remember saying, 'who the heck is this guy'?? I'm glad he has stepped up to the challenge.

        Comment


        • #5
          Originally posted by Tarlam!
          I tend to disagree that we should have gone after a Safety with the reasoning given. Rouse will work out just fine....
          Perhaps, but we can stand to upgrade BOTH safety spots IMO.
          My signature has NUDITY in it...whatcha gonna do?

          Comment


          • #6
            I think we should draft Ronnie Lott....errr wait...errr maybe he is a free agent...
            Swede: My expertise in this area is extensive. The essential difference between a "battleship" and an "aircraft carrier" is that an aircraft carrier requires five direct hits to sink, but it takes only four direct hits to sink a battleship.

            Comment


            • #7
              Once again it is nice to see how even the press will validate TT's strength of finding great talent in later rounds by having JJ as a 1st rounder. I wonder what they would say today of Greg Jennings in a retro 2006 draft?

              Comment


              • #8
                I'm sure Jennings would be the second receiver taken behind Santonio Holmes.

                Comment


                • #9
                  I don't see Justin Harrell on the list. Probably just an oversight.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    A safety would be nice, but I think the current crop will come around.

                    I'd have liked to see TE Greg Olson in GB to phase-out Bubba. Or, in hindsight, an offensive lineman.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Originally posted by Harlan Huckleby
                      I don't see Justin Harrell on the list. Probably just an oversight.

                      We nailed our first rounder in round three and our third rounder in round one
                      TERD Buckley over Troy Vincent, Robert Ferguson over Chris Chambers, Kevn King instead of TJ Watt, and now, RICH GANNON, over JIMMY JIMMY JIMMY LEONARD. Thank you FLOWER

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        I predict a wist like turnaround for the doubters of the first round pick. If wist can throw some mild faint praise towards Barnett, then we shall soon be saying of Harrell, well, he doesn't fall down alot.

                        I am more worried that Colledge show improvement in year three like Rivera, Wahle and Andruzzi. I also hope it doesn't take a move to left tackle to do it, athough having another one isn't the worst thing. Spitz eventually at center and Juice and his lovely bride at left guard.
                        Bud Adams told me the franchise he admired the most was the Kansas City Chiefs. Then he asked for more hookers and blow.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Originally posted by pbmax
                          I predict a wist like turnaround for the doubters of the first round pick. If wist can throw some mild faint praise towards Barnett, then we shall soon be saying of Harrell, well, he doesn't fall down alot.

                          I am more worried that Colledge show improvement in year three like Rivera, Wahle and Andruzzi. I also hope it doesn't take a move to left tackle to do it, athough having another one isn't the worst thing. Spitz eventually at center and Juice and his lovely bride at left guard.
                          Spitz played very well at C. Guess the boy just can't play the RG spot well.

                          I thought he might elevate Rouse to Rnd 1, also. Rouse has played well and inproved by a huge margin.

                          Comment

                          Working...
                          X