Did the best NFC kicker make the Pro Bowl? You judge.

[Patler]

Kickoffs

Kicker 1 - 63.0 avg, 4 TB, 23.1 Avg return
Kicker 2 - 63.7 avg, 7 TB, 22.3 Avg return


FGoals 1-19 yds 20-29 30-39 40-49 50+ Total
Kicker 1 - 0/0........ 9/10.....5/5......6/6....2/5......22/26...85%
Kicker 2 - 0/0........ 2/2......6/6.....10/11...1/3.....19/22...86%


Kicker 1 made the Pro Bowl. Should Kicker 2 have been selected instead?

[Rastak]

Re: Did the best NFC kicker make the Pro Bowl? You judge.

Kickoffs

Kicker 1 - 63.0 avg, 4 TB, 23.1 Avg return
Kicker 2 - 63.7 avg, 7 TB, 22.3 Avg return


FGoals 1-19 yds 20-29 30-39 40-49 50+ Total
Kicker 1 - 0/0 9/10 5/5 6/6 2/5 22/26 85%
Kicker 2 - 0/0 2/2 6/6 10/11 1/3 19/22 86%


Kicker 1 made the Pro Bowl. Should Kicker 2 have been selected instead?

How many clutch kicks in big games did each one make?

[HarveyWallbangers]

Close enough that neither would have a gripe. Actually, I'm surprised somebody else didn't have a better year than that. 19 FGs isn't many FGs. Does that kicker even have 100 points scored on the year? Not unless they are the New England kicker.

Another point: does one of the kickers kick indoors and the other outdoors? That makes a big difference.

[Patler]

Re: Did the best NFC kicker make the Pro Bowl? You judge.

How many clutch kicks in big games did each one make?

Don't know. I have not seen either one kick that much.

[Patler]

Close enough that neither would have a gripe. Actually, I'm surprised somebody else didn't have a better year than that. 19 FGs isn't many FGs. Does that kicker even have 100 points scored on the year? Not unless they are the New England kicker.

Kicker 1 is Folk, as I said he made the Pro Bowl, and has 100 points. Kicker 2 is very close to 100 points, probably will have it this week.

[HarveyWallbangers]

Not many kickers make it to the Pro Bowl with just 19 FGs. As far as Folk, there were a few kickers that should have made it over him. Dallas got a few undeserving Pro Bowl nods.

[BF4MVP]

Neither one should have been..Too many Cowboys AND too many Vikings already.

[Patler]

Not many kickers make it to the Pro Bowl with just 19 FGs. As far as Folk, there were a few kickers that should have made it over him. Dallas got a few undeserving Pro Bowl nods.

I think the selection of Folk is ridiculous. A rookie should have to have a clearly superior performance to be selected over similar players who have proven themselves over the years. Folk only has 22 fieldgoals, and 14 were less than 40 yards. "Kicker 2" only has 19, but his are more long range, and his kickoff performance is better.

[Patler]

No, kicker 2 should not have been selected instead...Too many Vikings made the pro bowl as it is :P

...and there clearly is a shortage of Cowboys!

[BF4MVP]

No, kicker 2 should not have been selected instead...Too many Vikings made the pro bowl as it is :P

...and there clearly is a shortage of Cowboys!

haha yeah edited that

[HarveyWallbangers]

Robbie Gould kicks in Soldier Field and he made 28 of 33 FGs, and around half his attempts were 40 yards or longer. That's way more impressive than Folk.

[Bretsky]

Robbie Gould kicks in Soldier Field and he made 28 of 33 FGs, and around half his attempts were 40 yards or longer. That's way more impressive than Folk.

Completely agree; Gould should have made the Pro Bowl

[Patler]

Robbie Gould kicks in Soldier Field and he made 28 of 33 FGs, and around half his attempts were 40 yards or longer. That's way more impressive than Folk.

Completely agree; Gould should have made the Pro Bowl

Yup, I agree on Gould, too. I started this thread just to see how people would compare Folk to Longwell. I can't say Folk was any better, at all.

All in all, Mason Crosby compares well, too. He has attempted more 40+ kicks than anyone in the NFC, and a lot more than most of them. He has 19 attempts at 40+ and most are actually 45+. The next closest to Crosby is 15 attempts at 40+. Folk has 11 attempts at 40+. Under 40 yards Crosby is 17/18, Folk is 14/15. Crosby's percentage suffers because he has attempted so many long kicks

[Bretsky]

Robbie Gould kicks in Soldier Field and he made 28 of 33 FGs, and around half his attempts were 40 yards or longer. That's way more impressive than Folk.

Completely agree; Gould should have made the Pro Bowl

Yup, I agree on Gould, too. I started this thread just to see how people would compare Folk to Longwell. I can't say Folk was any better, at all.

All in all, Mason Crosby compares well, too. He has attempted more 40+ kicks than anyone in the NFC, and a lot more than most of them. He has 19 attempts at 40+ and most are actually 45+. The next closest to Crosby is 15 attempts at 40+. Folk has 11 attempts at 40+. Under 40 yards Crosby is 17/18, Folk is 14/15. Crosby's percentage suffers because he has attempted so many long kicks

I do think Crosby is a better kicker than Folk; but neither should have made the Pro Bowl.

I think Longwell is more deserving than Folk as well

[Patler]

I do think Crosby is a better kicker than Folk; but neither should have made the Pro Bowl.

I think Longwell is more deserving than Folk as well

The selection of Folk is just plain baffling to me.

He is a middle of the pack kicker on kickoffs.
There are kickers with more fieldgoals, higher percentages and both combined. He hasn't put on a long range show, most of his kicks are very high percentage kicks. He hasn't decided a bunch of games. He really has done nothing impressive at all.