American Idol

[BallHawk]

Mediocrity.

Why nobody sang "Love on the Rocks" is beyond me.

Archuleta's voice is too juvenille for him to win the competition.

Syesha will go home even though Castro is by far the worst.

[GBRulz]

WHY is Castro still here? Lots of dreadheads out there voting for him or what?

I would like to see Syesha and David C in the finale, but I'm sure it will be a double David finale. Arch has an incredible voice, but he's so young. Has no stage presence at all.

[Partial]

WHY is Castro still here? Lots of dreadheads out there voting for him or what?

I would like to see Syesha and David C in the finale, but I'm sure it will be a double David finale. Arch has an incredible voice, but he's so young. Has no stage presence at all.

He picks awful songs as well in regards to Arch.

Dreadhead is still there because of his stupid smile and ugly teeth. For some reasons chicks think he's charming.

[LL2]

but I'm sure it will be a double David finale.

I bet your right. The bad boy rocker against the pretty boy teeny bopper.

[woodbuck27]

Cook will win the Idol now with the ypong fella as a close runner up. Why that blonde maried girl that plays piano has survived is beyond me.

Carly ( Irish gal) should still be there, as well as one of the fellas that went down early in April ( the fella from Australia or New Zealand, aa well as the Black American gal.

I's all anti-climatic now. Not up on Paula Abdul's Foo Fa as yet on Tuesday night past, but she''ll explain heself free of that.

[GBRulz]

Finally....Jason Castro is gone.

Next week is the finale and while I think David Cook should win, it's a closer race than I thought. Last night Ryan said there were 54 million votes and that less than a million votes separated the top 3 vote getters. That's insane.

[LL2]

I'm rooting for the kid. He may not be where David Cook is yet...but I think he's the most gifted. He was born with the talent. He just needs to be packaged better.

[Partial]

I liked Castro. He had a unique charm.

[GBRulz]

I'm rooting for the kid. He may not be where David Cook is yet...but I think he's the most gifted. He was born with the talent. He just needs to be packaged better.

Arch def has the best voice, but he's boring to watch. I think most 8 year olds are more socially tuned than this kid is.

[LL2]

I'm rooting for the kid. He may not be where David Cook is yet...but I think he's the most gifted. He was born with the talent. He just needs to be packaged better.

Arch def has the best voice, but he's boring to watch. I think most 8 year olds are more socially tuned than this kid is.

I agree. That's why I said someone needs to package him better. Make him more appealing to teen of today. Teach him how to dance...something...anything. I think he needs to take some risk in the next couple weeks to win it all.

[Partial]

Arch has the best voice to go on the show yet imo. Extremely talented but his song selection sucks and his stage presence sucks. Cook is a rock star. I still think the kid will win though.

[GBRulz]

The big question with Arch, does he go on with his career after H.S. or go on his two-year mission for the LDS church?

winner or not, David Cook will be going places.

[Partial]

Cook will sell more records, I definitely agree, but Archuleta will have many opportunities to sing in opera and broadway, etc.

[GBRulz]

Arch in Broadway? No, But I can see him singing some kind of Christian music or something.

I can def see Syesha on Broadway, though.

David A's Dad is now banned from backstage.

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20080510/ap_en_tv/american_idol_7

[red]

I liked Castro. He had a unique charm.

yeah, he had that special charm like he took it in the ass 3 times a day

the kid looks kind of...... gomery to me. he just doesn't look right to me

and i've never even see the other 2 sing, so i can't comment. haven't watched much of the show this year. none of them has really stood out to me as being any more talented then i can find at a local bar on the weekends