2005 First Round BUSTS

[Packman_26]

You can dissect any first round in history and get virtually the same result.

Get Out Now TT!

I guess I have to respectfully disagree... I thought I would test your theory and I chose the 2004 draft class and in my opinion, it is not really close.

http://bleacherreport.com/articles/138101-2004-nfl-draft-5-years-later

Please note that in this article the author makes a decision on whether the pick was a win or a loss for the team that drafted him. I would consider this slightly different from a player being a bust. For example, I would not consider Kellen Winslow a bust, it just didn't work out in Cleveland

[The Leaper]

Saying Rodgers could still be a bust completely devalues your list if that is your opinion.

The kid had his first season as a starter in the shadow of an iconic legend and a titanic PR mess...and was extremely successful by all accounts, on and off the field.

No chance is pick #24 a bust.

[Guiness]

That '04 draft looks pretty darn good now! Three franchise QB's - and, arguably, none of them were the best player in the draft. That would be Fitzgerald!

At least half the first round picks became solid contributors. So a big UGH to #25!!!