McGinn: Football Dept Agrees, Favre Can't Win Championship

[Tyrone Bigguns]

We always knew that the head office thought Rodgers had a greater potential to lead the team to a super bowl than did Favre, otherwise they would have kicked Rodgers back into the backup role once Brett wanted back in. The reasoning behind this decision is a little sketch, but for as many times as we have knocked on the door, our playoff record stunk over the last 10 years.

I don't think it has anything to do with Favre's talent. In terms of talent and ability, Favre is head and shoulders above Rodgers. In terms of the last 10 years, there were many reasons other than Favre that contributed to our playoff losses...lack of talent (STL), injuries (ATL), coaching blunders (PHI), etc. Yeah, Favre had his faults in some of those games as well...but it wasn't that he lacked the ability to win a title.

It has everything to do with his mental mindset NOW. The Packers think Favre is used up...he has nothing left to give in terms of being mentally prepared to make another run. Physically, he has the talent to do it...but mentally, he's done in the opinion of the Packers.

I'm not completely disagreeing with you, but as I continue to say. If I have an employee who constantly has similar problems and has a different excuse everytime.....I eventually point out the common denominator in the equation.

That being you?

[MJZiggy]

So you think Sherman actually called for a jump ball into double coverage while everyone was run blocking?

... coaching blunders (PHI)

4th and 1...punt.
4th and 26...ugh.

Was either Favre's fault max?

The Packers had that game won long before Favre's INT...but poor decision making by the coaches and poor execution elsewhere let it get away.

That doesn't excuse Favre's throw...but that does show that it wasn't just Favre that was responsible for those losses.

I think, from the comments that I've read that the Packers were more concerned with the more recent playoff performances as opposed to what happened in 2003...and they're concerned with Soldier Field and Dallas. Perhaps the whole team played like shit, but perhaps they also saw a poor quarterback performance in those games and became concerned by it. At least that's the impression I get from the stuff I've read and as much as I dis the media, this impression has come from more than one source which lends a minor bit of crediblity...

[mission]

The Law of Bob

When Bob has a problem with everybody/thing, the problem is usually Bob.

[Tyrone Bigguns]

The Law of Bob

When Bob has a problem with everybody/thing, the problem is usually Bob.

Hey, it's our friend Bob.

[mission]

The Law of Bob

When Bob has a problem with everybody/thing, the problem is usually Bob.

Hey, it's our friend Bob.

Exactly. He's obviously the problem. Makes me wanna beat the shit out of him just lookin at him.




But I only have a problem with Bob.


Not everyone.

Well, except all the idiots here.

[falco]

Exactly. He's obviously the problem. Makes me wanna beat the shit out of him just lookin at him.




But I only have a problem with Bob.


Not everyone.

Well, except all the idiots here.

why not just punch him in the shoulder

[mission]

Exactly. He's obviously the problem. Makes me wanna beat the shit out of him just lookin at him.




But I only have a problem with Bob.


Not everyone.

Well, except all the idiots here.

why not just punch him in the shoulder

cuz he's a guy in a john c. maxwell book ...

i mean, i can get away with beating the shit out of fake people.

[Fritz]

So you think Sherman actually called for a jump ball into double coverage while everyone was run blocking?

... coaching blunders (PHI)

I think he did, dude. I think he did.