OFFICIAL Favre/Rodgers Comparison Thread

[retailguy]

Nobody is going to fire TT, unless he gets caught in bed with a dead woman or live boy.

I have visions of "Ted trapped in the closet with a camera, Chapter 16"...

[swede]

Yeah. It's a what if thing.

I think the team will be fine and Favre can do as well as he wants as long as we make the playoffs.

But this summer will never go away and always be the exclamation point should the unthinkable happen and we go sub .500 for two years running.

[cheesner]

TT won Executive of Year award last season, right? His track record is stellar, he is not going to flounder badly. FAvre is a 39 year-old QB, he is not going to be a thorn in side for long.

Nobody is going to fire TT, unless he gets caught in bed with a dead woman or live boy.

But a dead boy is okay?

All I want is success for the Packers. TT has not done it 'my way' but he is certainly doing it. The future looks so bright for the Packers next couple years, I have to wear shades.

[Tyrone Bigguns]

These past 16 years have been the most consistent of any time in Green Bay. Sure the 60s had a hell of a lot more championships but they couldn't maintain. The Packers have had one losing season in 16 years, and all but one of those seasons was salary cap free. It has been an amazing run, but now the last piece of the beginning of the dynasty is gone. For some I don't think they realize this.

Could this be the continuation of the same dynasty, or a brand new one? Well for some their is a lot of fear that the glory of the Packers under Brett Favre, Reggie White, Mike Holmgren, Ron Wolf, Ahman Green, and many more is more over than continuing. One last nail in the coffin.

a sequence of rulers from the same family, stock, or group: the Ming dynasty

.

If anything the dynasty endd when wolf left.

But, in order to have a dynasty..you need to pass the torch. You can't have one with only one qb. That is why the pack never were a dynasty like the Niners.

But, if you consider being pretty average for a number of years a dynasty..good for you.

[mraynrand]

But, in order to have a dynasty..you need to pass the torch. You can't have one with only one qb. That is why the pack never were a dynasty like the Niners.

\

That's totally arbitrary. Favre alone spanned almost exactly the same time frame as Montana and Young. But so what? Were the Packers of the 60s not a dynasty (Starr), were the Steelers of the 70s not a dynasty (Bradshaw), were the Cowboys of the 90s not a dynasty (Aikman), and were the Patriots of the 00s not a dynasty (Brady) because they had but one QB through their championship runs?

[RashanGary]

The Favre lovers have said Murphy would step in if TT thought about getting rid of Favre as it would be financial suicide. They said there would be a lynch mob if it ever looked like TT was running Favre out of town. They said if he ever acctually did run Favre out of town he would be hung in the streets of Greenbay.


Well, Murphy never stepped in. Favre did make it obvious that TT was trying to get rid of him and then TT did get rid of him. Through all of it nothing happened except a couple hundred people widely considered idiots made a couple signs. . . Oooohh scary. Now we're supposed to believe this great mob is going to step up if the Packers don't dominate over the next few years. Haha. . .


Favre crank tuggers are so dillusional. They believe the shit that comes out of their mouth and then when it's proven wrong they say the same thing again believing it will be true this time. Idiots. Sad, pathetic idiots.

[Tyrone Bigguns]

But, in order to have a dynasty..you need to pass the torch. You can't have one with only one qb. That is why the pack never were a dynasty like the Niners.

\

That's totally arbitrary. Favre alone spanned almost exactly the same time frame as Montana and Young. But so what? Were the Packers of the 60s not a dynasty (Starr), were the Steelers of the 70s not a dynasty (Bradshaw), were the Cowboys of the 90s not a dynasty (Aikman), and were the Patriots of the 00s not a dynasty (Brady) because they had but one QB through their championship runs?

As per the defintion. Are you having reading comprehension issues? Right above is the def of a dynasty..from the dictionary.

But, if we want to compare to your examples...i stated if being average is a a dynasty..good for you.

Multiple championships is a necessary component of a dynasty.

Calling the packers a dynasty is laughable.

[mraynrand]

, in order to have a dynasty..you need to pass the torch. You can't have one with only one qb.

I think I understood this perfectly well. I just demonstrated that it is about as wrong as can be in the history of the NFL.

You can't have one with only one qb.

You can't have one with only one qb.

You can't have one with only one qb.

You can't have one with only one qb.

You can't have one with only one qb.

Did I miss something?

[gex]

The Favre lovers have said Murphy would step in if TT thought about getting rid of Favre as it would be financial suicide. They said there would be a lynch mob if it ever looked like TT was running Favre out of town. They said if he ever acctually did run Favre out of town he would be hung in the streets of Greenbay.


Well, Murphy never stepped in. Favre did make it obvious that TT was trying to get rid of him and then TT did get rid of him. Through all of it nothing happened except a couple hundred people widely considered idiots made a couple signs. . . Oooohh scary. Now we're supposed to believe this great mob is going to step up if the Packers don't dominate over the next few years. Haha. . .


Favre crank tuggers are so dillusional. They believe the shit that comes out of their mouth and then when it's proven wrong they say the same thing again believing it will be true this time. Idiots. Sad, pathetic idiots.

Sigh,

Things were going so well.

[Tyrone Bigguns]

, in order to have a dynasty..you need to pass the torch. You can't have one with only one qb.

I think I understood this perfectly well. I just demonstrated that it is about as wrong as can be in the history of the NFL.

You can't have one with only one qb.

You can't have one with only one qb.

You can't have one with only one qb.

You can't have one with only one qb.

You can't have one with only one qb.

Did I miss something?

Yes.

Wolf and being average.

[Lurker64]

However, a huge pressure wave of converted agnostics will grab pitchforks and shake foam hats at TT and Murphy should Favre do great in NY while we struggle to a .500 record and miss the playoffs..

[The Gunshooter]

Favre $hits bed. Rodgers pisses it.

[Zool]

Favre $hits bed. Rodgers pisses it.

Yeah but Coach Mac said "we'll get that stuff cleaned up."
I havent heard one word from Mangina about them getting their stuff cleaned up.

[Partial]

The Favre lovers have said Murphy would step in if TT thought about getting rid of Favre as it would be financial suicide. They said there would be a lynch mob if it ever looked like TT was running Favre out of town. They said if he ever acctually did run Favre out of town he would be hung in the streets of Greenbay.


Well, Murphy never stepped in. Favre did make it obvious that TT was trying to get rid of him and then TT did get rid of him. Through all of it nothing happened except a couple hundred people widely considered idiots made a couple signs. . . Oooohh scary. Now we're supposed to believe this great mob is going to step up if the Packers don't dominate over the next few years. Haha. . .


Favre crank tuggers are so dillusional. They believe the shit that comes out of their mouth and then when it's proven wrong they say the same thing again believing it will be true this time. Idiots. Sad, pathetic idiots.

You're off you're rocker. See training camp attendance this year. The lowest, according to Rob Demosky, by a HUGE amount, in 20 years. Just because not everyone is an extremist and going to go to a feeble protest doesn't mean much at all.

Listen to local sports radio. The sides are pretty evenly divided, leaning towards the "oh shit" side after the previous performances by A-Rod. Tonight his stat line is solid though.

[th87]

Who cares what the fans think? Many are emotional and blinded.

If the board thinks TT is the right man for the job, they should stick by him regardless. People won't stop going to games. And if they do, my whole family would love to give those people's tickets a new home.