NFC North QB Race

[Badgerinmaine]

After week 10

1. Rodgers 93.3 (slight decline again)
2. Frerotte 74.0 (3 picks...very poor)
3. Grossman 59.0 (awful)
4. Culpepper 47.5 (very awful)

Honorary NFC North QB
Favre 89.8 (slight increase)

I have to think Culpepper will do better once he gets to know his teammates better...it was amazing how quickly they put him in to play after signing him. That's hard to do at QB.

[superfan]

Posting to keep this thread alive, I like it!

Anybody want to put any effort into figuring out the average QB rating for the NFC North compared to other divisions? Would be interesting to see. How do our QBs stack up against the rest of the league?

[Partial]

I don't put a lot of stock into quarterback rating. Rodgers is staying reasonably high because he doesn't cause turnovers.

But, he isn't putting up points. I maintain that 4 of his 7 games have been pretty poor.

[Rastak]

Posting to keep this thread alive, I like it!

Anybody want to put any effort into figuring out the average QB rating for the NFC North compared to other divisions? Would be interesting to see. How do our QBs stack up against the rest of the league?

What up Superfan? I post the results every week actually.

I am guessing the North is pretty much putrid compared but it would be an interesting analysis.

[MOBB DEEP]

After week 10

1. Rodgers 93.3 (slight decline again)
2. Frerotte 74.0 (3 picks...very poor)
3. Grossman 59.0 (awful)
4. Culpepper 47.5 (very awful)

Honorary NFC North QB
Favre 89.8 (slight increase)

lol honorary nfc north qb...

[Gunakor]

Posting to keep this thread alive, I like it!

Anybody want to put any effort into figuring out the average QB rating for the NFC North compared to other divisions? Would be interesting to see. How do our QBs stack up against the rest of the league?

What up Superfan? I post the results every week actually.

I am guessing the North is pretty much putrid compared but it would be an interesting analysis.

Well, 2 of the 4 regular starters at QB for NFC North teams have a rating at or near 90 (Rodgers and Orton). If you are comparing QB's by division, I'd say that's pretty good.

[Rastak]

After week 11




1. Rodgers 94.5 (slight increase still top dog)
2. Orton 88.5 (not bad!)
2. Frerotte 76.6 (increased a bit)
4. Culpepper 56.8 (putrid)

Honorary NFC North QB
Favre 93.0 (slight increase, pretty damn solid)

[sheepshead]

I never have put too much stock in the QB rating unless its very low.

[Rastak]

After week 12




1. Rodgers 90.5 (small decline, behind Favre now)
2. Orton 88.0 (not bad!)
2. Frerotte 75 (2 game slump)
4. Culpepper 50.3 (can't anyone block for this guy?)

Honorary NFC North QB
Favre 94.1 (MVP rumblings start)

[TennesseePackerBacker]

After week 12




1. Rodgers 90.5 (small decline, behind Favre now)
2. Orton 88.0 (not bad!)
2. Frerotte 75 (2 game slump)
4. Culpepper 50.3 (can't anyone block for this guy?)

Honorary NFC North QB
Favre 94.1 (MVP rumblings start)

hah, thanks Rastak. Favre hasnt had a bad game in a couple so we could see him have one against Denver. Other than that, it probably looks like the Jets, at worst, could go 10-6 but will probably be 11-5/12-4. The Packers miss the veteran leadership, not finishing has really killed this team.

[Rastak]

After week 13



1. Rodgers 91.2 (small increase but very nice game)
2. Orton 83.3 (declining, did not play well at all)
2. Frerotte 76.1 (slight increase, looked better than last week))
4. Culpepper 53.6 (man the Lions are bad)

Honorary NFC North QB
Favre 90.4 (Not a great game)[/quote]

[Rastak]

After week 14



1. Rodgers 92.1 (small increase but up and down game, not bad)
2. Orton 83.5 (Nice game vs Jax)
2. Frerotte 73.7 (He's a statue and he's getting killed)
4. Culpepper 63.9 (better but below the Kordoza line)

Honorary NFC North QB
Favre 88.2 (Not a great game again)

[cpk1994]

After week 14



1. Rodgers 92.1 (small increase but up and down game, not bad)
2. Orton 83.5 (Nice game vs Jax)
2. Frerotte 73.7 (He's a statue and he's getting killed)
4. Culpepper 63.9 (better but below the Kordoza line)

Honorary NFC North QB
Favre 88.2 (Not a great game again)

You should add next to FavreMVP rumblings end)

[Rastak]

After week 14



1. Rodgers 92.1 (small increase but up and down game, not bad)
2. Orton 83.5 (Nice game vs Jax)
2. Frerotte 73.7 (He's a statue and he's getting killed)
4. Culpepper 63.9 (better but below the Kordoza line)

Honorary NFC North QB
Favre 88.2 (Not a great game again)

You should add next to FavreMVP rumblings end)

No kidding. I should have.

[mngolf19]

After week 14



1. Rodgers 92.1 (small increase but up and down game, not bad)
2. Orton 83.5 (Nice game vs Jax)
2. Frerotte 73.7 (He's a statue and he's getting killed)
4. Culpepper 63.9 (better but below the Kordoza line)

Honorary NFC North QB
Favre 88.2 (Not a great game again)

You should add next to FavreMVP rumblings end)

No kidding. I should have.

Might have to add Jackson now since he will likely start the rest of the year.