NFC North QB Race

[Rastak]

After week 16




1. Jackson 96.8 (Yikes, it went up)
2. Rodgers 91.4 (steady year for Rodgers)
3. Orton 78.1 (dropping)
4. Orlovsky 74.3 (back in last)


Honorary NFC North QB
Favre 84.0 (postseason? Nah.)

[Rastak]

Final Standings



1. Jackson 95.4 (Nice finish to the year)
2. Rodgers 93.8 (Meet the new boss, same as the old boss- Great year)
3. Orton 79.6 (Not great)
4. Orlovsky 72.6 (Not good)


Honorary NFC North QB
Favre 81.0 (Very average in the end)

[Zool]

T-Jax has improved his decision making. If he can improve his middle-deep accuracy he can be good.

[HarveyWallbangers]

I thought Jackson looked good in week 16. I didn't see him week 15. I thought he regressed badly in this last game. Looked like TJack of old. Only an easy drop on what would have been an easy pick six on one play and/or the falling down of the Giants backup corner against TJack's primary receiver, Berrian, on another play kept his stats mildly impressive. I thought he mostly looked bad.

[Rastak]

I thought Jackson looked good in week 16. I didn't see him week 15. I thought he regressed badly in this last game. Looked like TJack of old. Only an easy drop on what would have been an easy pick six on one play and/or the falling down of the Giants backup corner against TJack's primary receiver, Berrian, on another play kept his stats mildly impressive. I thought he mostly looked bad.

He had a really nice pass to Wade, throwing across his body while scrambling. He definately didn't have a great game but wasn't terrible. He started slow and mixed in a couple bad throws later in the game. The pick was pretty bad, the Wade catch I mentioned was pretty nice. I'd grade him a 5 on the 1-10 scale last game.


edit: Week 15 he played out of his head. I was certain it wasn't really him.

[HarveyWallbangers]

He had some deer in the headlights looks to him on some of those blitzes, and he also resorted to bad habits. Some side-arm throws. Some throws where he tried to guide the ball too much. Just not impressed. He looked better late, but by the end of the game he wasn't going up against the Giants best on defense.

[Rastak]

He had some deer in the headlights looks to him on some of those blitzes, and he also resorted to bad habits. Some side-arm throws. Some throws where he tried to guide the ball too much. Just not impressed. He looked better late, but by the end of the game he wasn't going up against the Giants best on defense.

I'm actually watching the game right now (hadn't seen the tv broadcast yet and have been watching for 2 hours). He had several nice throws to Wade actually. Nice throw to Berrian (outside of the long one).

In another thread I mentioned they have to find a better way to cope with these attacking blitzes to beat Philly.

After watching most of the game a second time, I stand by my 5 out of 10. Not a great game, two very bad throws, a couple more not good. A couple nice throws and lots of standard completions. Not great but it got the job done...