Rodgers >> Favre

[MadtownPacker]

Favre can still win games. He still can sling it. He damn sure wouldn't have held this year's team back.With that said I have to now agree Rodgers has reached the point where him and Favre's skills have met. Rodgers will go up to whatever his limit is. Favre will only fade more as time goes on. ARod will need to do what he is doing for a long time but he does have what it takes.

Welcome aboard, pendejo.

I have never doubted Rodgers skill set. Any opinion about the Favre mess had nothing to do with Rodgers and I even called him the only victim in all of it. My concern was his durability and he has shown it by playing through the injury.

[PlantPage55]

THREE MVP'S....

Ha ha, completely irrelevant to the argument. Astounding how some can not let go of things that happened 10+ years ago. But I'll play your game...so, Aaron will never be able to get himself a MVP or two? Not possible?

Because do you really want to pull 3 MVPs out on a guy who is in his FIRST YEAR as an NFL starter? What sense does that make?

That doesn't change the fact that Aaron Rodgers appears to be more than a game manager himself. Our defense and run game haven't been playing well enough for him to just "manage" games.

[Chevelle2]

Rodgers 08 > Favre 07.

I'd say Favre 07 > Rodgers 08

Rodgers' 08 numbers through 7 weeks

>

Favre's 07 numbers through 7 week

[MOBB DEEP]

[quote="Chevelle2"]

btw, it makes much sense that the BEST way to compare these two jokers is to compare how they play/win with the same teammates since we have the evidence. will pack be 13-3 and host nfccg...?????? game, set, match

Yeah. I already did that, dumbass.

Rodgers 08 > Favre 07.[/quote

ok, name calln on a forum

thats a moronic move if not face-to-face tuffy

[MOBB DEEP]

Rodgers 08 > Favre 07.

I'd say Favre 07 > Rodgers 08
I'd say Rodgers 08 > Favre 08

That second one is the only one that is pertinent.

shouldnt we wait til the end of the season to compare favre 07 to aaron 08 tho? what if #12 has bad 2nd half?

[HarveyWallbangers]

shouldnt we wait til the end of the season to compare favre 07 to aaron 08 tho? what if #12 has bad 2nd half?

Sure, but up to this point Rodgers has been better. Can we agree on that? And that's with Brett going up against Oakland, Cincinnati, Kansas City, and Miami. Brett's play has dropped off near the end of the year the last three seasons, so we'll see if he can turn that around.

[mraynrand]

shouldnt we wait til the end of the season to compare favre 07 to aaron 08 tho? what if #12 has bad 2nd half?

Sure, but up to this point Rodgers has been better. Can we agree on that? And that's with Brett going up against Oakland, Cincinnati, Kansas City, and Miami. Brett's play has dropped off near the end of the year the last three seasons, so we'll see if he can turn that around.

It should be noted that GB has defeated teams with 8 wins total.

[MOBB DEEP]

shouldnt we wait til the end of the season to compare favre 07 to aaron 08 tho? what if #12 has bad 2nd half?

Sure, but up to this point Rodgers has been better. Can we agree on that? And that's with Brett going up against Oakland, Cincinnati, Kansas City, and Miami. Brett's play has dropped off near the end of the year the last three seasons, so we'll see if he can turn that around.

heck yeah, aaron has been better thus far. i think lord had him beat the first 4 games but since then...

question: right now, in a do or die game who would u take?

tuff question right?

[Scott Campbell]

question: right now, in a do or die game who would u take?

tuff question

Hmmm - that's a toughie. What's the game temperature?

[Zool]

shouldnt we wait til the end of the season to compare favre 07 to aaron 08 tho? what if #12 has bad 2nd half?

Sure, but up to this point Rodgers has been better. Can we agree on that? And that's with Brett going up against Oakland, Cincinnati, Kansas City, and Miami. Brett's play has dropped off near the end of the year the last three seasons, so we'll see if he can turn that around.

It should be noted that GB has defeated teams with 8 wins total.

And the 3 teams they lost to are a combined 14-9.

[MOBB DEEP]

question: right now, in a do or die game who would u take?

tuff question

Hmmm - that's a toughie. What's the game temperature?

in tampa

[LEWCWA]

shouldnt we wait til the end of the season to compare favre 07 to aaron 08 tho? what if #12 has bad 2nd half?

Sure, but up to this point Rodgers has been better. Can we agree on that? And that's with Brett going up against Oakland, Cincinnati, Kansas City, and Miami. Brett's play has dropped off near the end of the year the last three seasons, so we'll see if he can turn that around.

You say this like it means anything! Lets reverse the roles. Brett QBing the Packers and Rodgers shipped to NY 3 weeks b4 the season. Who would have better numbers then.....Don't compare apples and oranges and pretend it means anything.

[Chevelle2]

shouldnt we wait til the end of the season to compare favre 07 to aaron 08 tho? what if #12 has bad 2nd half?

Good luck with that.

Everyone knows Favre's play dips in the 2nd half of the season.

[HarveyWallbangers]

You say this like it means anything! Lets reverse the roles. Brett QBing the Packers and Rodgers shipped to NY 3 weeks b4 the season. Who would have better numbers then.....Don't compare apples and oranges and pretend it means anything.

My guess is that the Jets would have 5 wins and the Packers would have 4.

[Scott Campbell]

question: right now, in a do or die game who would u take?

tuff question

Hmmm - that's a toughie. What's the game temperature?

in tampa

I'm guessing it wouldn't be 13 below there - right?