Is AR like a hot chic that

[cpk1994]

Did you just call palmer the 8th best qb in the league? You just lost all credibility.

He never had much to begin with. Ill also point out that he has Hasselback on that list as well. Hasselbeck has been barely healthy at all this year. Rodgers has been way better than him.

[Partial]

Did you just call palmer the 8th best qb in the league? You just lost all credibility.

I said in no particular order.. but Carson Palmer has got to be up there. He's put up MVP numbers when healthy. His team around him always sucks.

This was his 6th season. He was hurt all this year. Last year he was coming back from that nasty hit in the playoffs that tore up his knee.

His 3rd and 4th years in the league he was an all-pro. Just a straight up dynamo.

His rookie year he didn't take a snap, and he was pretty solid his second season.

I'm not sure where you'd rate him, but he's clearly top 10 imo.

[Partial]

Did you just call palmer the 8th best qb in the league? You just lost all credibility.

He never had much to begin with. Ill also point out that he has Hasselback on that list as well. Hasselbeck has been barely healthy at all this year. Rodgers has been way better than him.

I stated that Hass wasn't healthy, dumbass. Hass has taken a team to the superbowl, has been to 3 pro-bowls, looked FAR better behind BF than Rodgers did, etc.

Hass has had a rough year. Seattle in general has. When all is said and done, if Rodgers ends up with a similiar career to Hass' we will all be overjoyed, as Hass is one of the best players in the league.

Wow, I cannot believe the shit that I am seeing.

[Zool]

I said in no particular order.. but Carson Palmer has got to be up there. He's put up MVP numbers when healthy. His team around him always sucks.

Well too fucking bad. Stats dont tell the story remember?

[Partial]

I said in no particular order.. but Carson Palmer has got to be up there. He's put up MVP numbers when healthy. His team around him always sucks.

Well too fucking bad. Stats dont tell the story remember?

Well, he took 2nd in MVP voting behind Peyton Manning. So, yeah, Wiseguy, where would you rank him with his picture perfect deep ball?

[Zool]

I said in no particular order.. but Carson Palmer has got to be up there. He's put up MVP numbers when healthy. His team around him always sucks.

Well too fucking bad. Stats dont tell the story remember?

Well, he took 2nd in MVP voting behind Peyton Manning. So, yeah, Wiseguy, where would you rank him with his picture perfect deep ball?

I rank him as having 1 winning season as a starter wiseguy. Its all about winning right? Or is it about stats? Or is it MVP votes?

[sharpe1027]

The football fans I talk to that really watch the games outside of Green Bay do not have the same love for A-Rod as a see on this board.

What I see is people who maybe said Rodgers will be great, or whatever and now will not admit certain flaws in his game.

If you want to talk about his flaws, I'm sure 99% of the posters will be willing to discuss them. However, blanket statements that "AR always have great stats but unable to lead the Packers to big wins," aren't very useful in assessing his flaws.

[Partial]

I said in no particular order.. but Carson Palmer has got to be up there. He's put up MVP numbers when healthy. His team around him always sucks.

Well too fucking bad. Stats dont tell the story remember?

Well, he took 2nd in MVP voting behind Peyton Manning. So, yeah, Wiseguy, where would you rank him with his picture perfect deep ball?

I rank him as having 1 winning season as a starter wiseguy. Its all about winning right? Or is it about stats? Or is it MVP votes?

Look at the three ring circus he has around him..

Aaron hasn't had a winning season, so until he does that Palmer has a step up on him. Hasn't Eli only had one winning season?

[sharpe1027]

Look at the three ring circus he has around him..

Aaron hasn't had a winning season, so until he does that Palmer has a step up on him. Hasn't Eli only had one winning season?

I remember a three-ring circus surrounding the Packers and their starting QB this year. Of course I'm sure that's different.

[Zool]

I said in no particular order.. but Carson Palmer has got to be up there. He's put up MVP numbers when healthy. His team around him always sucks.

Well too fucking bad. Stats dont tell the story remember?

Well, he took 2nd in MVP voting behind Peyton Manning. So, yeah, Wiseguy, where would you rank him with his picture perfect deep ball?

I rank him as having 1 winning season as a starter wiseguy. Its all about winning right? Or is it about stats? Or is it MVP votes?

Look at the three ring circus he has around him..

Aaron hasn't had a winning season, so until he does that Palmer has a step up on him. Hasn't Eli only had one winning season?

2 for Manning. 1 more at .500 and a SB win.

You dont call the Favre fiasco a circus? Why not just give Rodgers a break. Of course he could have played better this year, but he could have played a lot fucking worse too.

You always give other teams the benefit of the doubt, but are unrealistically hard on the Packers.

[Partial]

Yes.. The Packers have lost so many of their skill players because of in-team suspensions, nfl sanctioned suspensions, etc.

STFU. Seriously.

Look at the list. Who is A-Rod better than? Like I said, a few guys are banged up on their but still very good players.

I'm asking WHO?

[Zool]

Yes.. The Packers have lost so many of their skill players because of in-team suspensions, nfl sanctioned suspensions, etc.

STFU. Seriously.

Look at the list. Who is A-Rod better than? Like I said, a few guys are banged up on their but still very good players.

I'm asking WHO?

How about comparing the first year starting for each of them? No one is saying he's the next HOF QB, but you seem to think he's TJ Rubley part 2.

[DonHutson]

Keep comparing him to a chick and he's going to get all self-conscious and grow the 'stache back to look more badass.

[Partial]

Yes.. The Packers have lost so many of their skill players because of in-team suspensions, nfl sanctioned suspensions, etc.

STFU. Seriously.

Look at the list. Who is A-Rod better than? Like I said, a few guys are banged up on their but still very good players.

I'm asking WHO?

How about comparing the first year starting for each of them? No one is saying he's the next HOF QB, but you seem to think he's TJ Rubley part 2.

Gah! Where have I said htat? I said he's an average NFL starter!!!!!! I have said he has the physical skills to be special. How does that == TJ Rubley?

[Tyrone Bigguns]

Partial, regardless of Palmer, to even suggest that Jay Cutler is a top QB is laughable and better than Rodgers is

Cutler was 2-3 in his rookie year, 9 tds and 5 ints.

Denver was 7-9 last year. Cutler had 20 tds and 14 ints.

Denver is currently 8-6. Cutler has been the textbook definition of Jekyll and Hyde. 24 tds and 15 picks.

Not one season in the 90s for QB rating.