Originally posted by Dabaddestbear
Peyton Manning
Tom Brady
Drew Brees
Tony Romo
Carson Palmer
Ben R
And I'd likely put him behind these guys, although a few are arguable, mostly due to age:
Phillip Rivers
Donovan McNabb
Marc Bulger
Eli Manning
Kurt Warner
Matt Ryan
I might even add Schaub and Hasselbeck to the list.
So, I'd roughly rank him 12-14. Not a sniff of top 5 for him!
ps I'm staying away from the obvious homerism of adding Rodgers to the list, but honestly, right now, I'd rather have him than Cutler.

Comment