The Official Vikings@Packers Gameday Thread

[mmmdk]

well at least we can still fall back on chilly and is ineptitude in coaching

Although MM hasn't exactly been a genius.

Not even close

Good game so far

MM has been good but it ain't a common thing.

[mmmdk]

Where it Patler when we need him ? I'd like some formal clarification on the rule on the Shiancoe catch. I swore I've seen that exact play twice before and both times they ruled it a catch.

Lots of unbiased sports people on Twitter saying horrible overturn. I agree. Should of been a TD.

Aw. Poor football fans upset at bad refereeing. Join the club,

The ball moved and ground aided.

On the replay it was clear Vinsanthe readjusted the ball before hitting the ground. I am guessing it was because of that plus the point of the ball hitting the ground that caused the reversal!

I'm glad to got the call but it was not conistent with past rulings I've seen

Very true.

[Bretsky]

Where it Patler when we need him ? I'd like some formal clarification on the rule on the Shiancoe catch. I swore I've seen that exact play twice before and both times they ruled it a catch.

Lots of unbiased sports people on Twitter saying horrible overturn. I agree. Should of been a TD.

Aw. Poor football fans upset at bad refereeing. Join the club,

The ball moved and ground aided.

tivo'd this and watched it over and over; that's a load of bunk IMO

I am with you, but I am happy to have some go the Packer way.

Absolutely

I'll take the -4 pts on that call and the 7 they bothched on the Quarles Bobble

[pbmax]

Where it Patler when we need him ? I'd like some formal clarification on the rule on the Shiancoe catch. I swore I've seen that exact play twice before and both times they ruled it a catch.

Lots of unbiased sports people on Twitter saying horrible overturn. I agree. Should of been a TD.

Aw. Poor football fans upset at bad refereeing. Join the club,

The ball moved and ground aided.

On the replay it was clear Vinsanthe readjusted the ball before hitting the ground. I am guessing it was because of that plus the point of the ball hitting the ground that caused the reversal!

Are you sure? I could not see the ball move, as it was under him immediately after hitting the turf.

[pbmax]

Rodgers is playing like Cutler.

If he keeps it up, sit his ass down for a while. You can't have your QB flinging the ball all over the field and committing turnovers. They simply aren't good enough to overcome stupid mistake after stupid mistake. This team doesn't need a Favre II.

He is only on a pace for 4 INTs, not 6 and above.

[gbgary]

Rodgers is playing like Cutler.

not even close.

[Bretsky]

Where it Patler when we need him ? I'd like some formal clarification on the rule on the Shiancoe catch. I swore I've seen that exact play twice before and both times they ruled it a catch.

Lots of unbiased sports people on Twitter saying horrible overturn. I agree. Should of been a TD.

My understanding of the rule would mean it should have been a TD

I disagree. I don't think he had control of the ball when the ball touched the ground.

not sure how you can say that; he's by no means bobbling it on the replay. When I look at it I think he has complete control but the tip of the ball is going to the ground. In the past they have not called that an incompletion

[mmmdk]

Where it Patler when we need him ? I'd like some formal clarification on the rule on the Shiancoe catch. I swore I've seen that exact play twice before and both times they ruled it a catch.

Lots of unbiased sports people on Twitter saying horrible overturn. I agree. Should of been a TD.

Aw. Poor football fans upset at bad refereeing. Join the club,

The ball moved and ground aided.

tivo'd this and watched it over and over; that's a load of bunk IMO

I am with you, but I am happy to have some go the Packer way.

Absolutely

I'll take the -4 pts on that call and the 7 they bothched on the Quarles Bobble

So you tivo; that doesn't make you right. Schooled.

[sheepshead]

Where it Patler when we need him ? I'd like some formal clarification on the rule on the Shiancoe catch. I swore I've seen that exact play twice before and both times they ruled it a catch.

Lots of unbiased sports people on Twitter saying horrible overturn. I agree. Should of been a TD.

Aw. Poor football fans upset at bad refereeing. Join the club,

The ball moved and ground aided.

On the replay it was clear Vinsanthe readjusted the ball before hitting the ground. I am guessing it was because of that plus the point of the ball hitting the ground that caused the reversal!

That was a shit call. If that isnt a TD what is. This officiating is getting goofy. Plus Rodgers isnt playing very well at all.

[Bretsky]

Rodgers is playing like Cutler.

not even close.

Agree; Cutler, his OL, and his WR's seem lost at times. The Martz offense is complicated; maybe Cutler is just not a bright dude who can run through a few progressions quickly and make the right decision

[Rastak]

Look, hard to say. Quarless got the call on control, Vikes didn't get that same call.....that's football. Let's see the second half!

[mmmdk]

Rodgers is playing like Cutler.

not even close.

Agree; Cutler, his OL, and his WR's seem lost at times. The Martz offense is complicated; maybe Cutler is just not a bright dude who can run through a few progressions quickly and make the right decision

Cutler and Rodgers are friends

[ThunderDan]

Where it Patler when we need him ? I'd like some formal clarification on the rule on the Shiancoe catch. I swore I've seen that exact play twice before and both times they ruled it a catch.

Lots of unbiased sports people on Twitter saying horrible overturn. I agree. Should of been a TD.

Aw. Poor football fans upset at bad refereeing. Join the club,

The ball moved and ground aided.

On the replay it was clear Vinsanthe readjusted the ball before hitting the ground. I am guessing it was because of that plus the point of the ball hitting the ground that caused the reversal!

I'm glad to got the call but it was not conistent with past rulings I've seen

I'm not sure it shouldn't have been a TD also but I can see where the reversal came from with the readjust.

[pbmax]

Look, hard to say. Quarless got the call on control, Vikes didn't get that same call.....that's football. Let's see the second half!

I think he got the call on in bounds. The ref never saw the ball come loose.

[ThunderDan]

Where it Patler when we need him ? I'd like some formal clarification on the rule on the Shiancoe catch. I swore I've seen that exact play twice before and both times they ruled it a catch.

Lots of unbiased sports people on Twitter saying horrible overturn. I agree. Should of been a TD.

Aw. Poor football fans upset at bad refereeing. Join the club,

The ball moved and ground aided.

On the replay it was clear Vinsanthe readjusted the ball before hitting the ground. I am guessing it was because of that plus the point of the ball hitting the ground that caused the reversal!

Are you sure? I could not see the ball move, as it was under him immediately after hitting the turf.

No, while he was still in the air! Not when he hit the ground!