Vince Young Finished In TN

[Patler]

Its no where near Michael Vick. Vick was out of the game for 2 seasons, thats why he had to go to a team to backup. VY may not put up great stats or look like the typical QB but hes a winner. Hes also very immature and while I do think the Titans made the right decision to go with Fisher over VY I still believe Young is a starter in this league.

I think he can be a starter, he hasn't been acting like a starter for the last two seasons. Being a starting QB in the NFL requires a lot more than just playing in the games (which at times he seemed disinterested in anyway). I think for his long term career, it would be best to "start over" and go somewhere that he can sit, watch, learn and most importantly, mature for a year or two. Let the emotional baggage carried by fans and himself diminish (as it did for Vick), then look to be a starter somewhere.

My opinion, and an opinion only, is that if he goes somewhere to start immediately, it will play out again the same as it did in Tennessee.

[Cheesehead Craig]

I think he can be a starter, he hasn't been acting like a starter for the last two seasons. Being a starting QB in the NFL requires a lot more than just playing in the games (which at times he seemed disinterested in anyway). I think for his long term career, it would be best to "start over" and go somewhere that he can sit, watch, learn and most importantly, mature for a year or two. Let the emotional baggage carried by fans and himself diminish (as it did for Vick), then look to be a starter somewhere.

My opinion, and an opinion only, is that if he goes somewhere to start immediately, it will play out again the same as it did in Tennessee.

I agree. I think he needs a break from the expectations and to get his head on straight(er). It doesn't sound like he wants to do that though so I highly doubt he'll take a backup role anywhere.