Originally posted by 3irty1
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Packers select USC DE/OLB Nick Perry At Pick #28 Round One 2012 Draft
Collapse
X
-
When I first read this post I but down my blackberry and thought about it for awhile. Your analysis of TT as the defensive version of Al Davis is quite accurate, lots of raw athleticism as displayed by his baseline for drafting lbs and the three cone drill for example. This was some of the best analysis of TT's style I have read, and really explains the Justin Harrell risk. Well done well done!All tyrannies rule through fraud and force, but once the fraud is exposed they must rely exclusively on force.
George Orwell
-
Ted is actually in the Al Davis GMing tree already. Ron Wolf learned the personnel game from Davis, and TT learned the personnel game from Ron Wolf.Originally posted by Upnorth View PostWhen I first read this post I but down my blackberry and thought about it for awhile. Your analysis of TT as the defensive version of Al Davis is quite accurate, lots of raw athleticism as displayed by his baseline for drafting lbs and the three cone drill for example. This was some of the best analysis of TT's style I have read, and really explains the Justin Harrell risk. Well done well done!
It's sort of a modified Davis approach, since TT's formula is basically "HWS+high character/leadership and throw out guys without actual football ability (for the most part, we all remember Mike Hawkins and Aaron Rouse.)"
It's not just on defense either. Ted drafts people who are unusually athletic at every position. He does not draft people who are short, slow, or small at any position.
Before anybody thinks this is a knock on or weakness of TT, you have to keep in mind that before he got old and crazy and stopped scouting well, Al Davis was quite probably the greatest GM going.</delurk>
Comment
-
Does this mean TT will still be the acting GM years after he has passed away?Originally posted by Lurker64 View PostTed is actually in the Al Davis GMing tree already. Ron Wolf learned the personnel game from Davis, and TT learned the personnel game from Ron Wolf.
It's sort of a modified Davis approach, since TT's formula is basically "HWS+high character/leadership and throw out guys without actual football ability (for the most part, we all remember Mike Hawkins and Aaron Rouse.)"
It's not just on defense either. Ted drafts people who are unusually athletic at every position. He does not draft people who are short, slow, or small at any position.
Before anybody thinks this is a knock on or weakness of TT, you have to keep in mind that before he got old and crazy and stopped scouting well, Al Davis was quite probably the greatest GM going.
Last edited by Bossman641; 04-27-2012, 04:19 PM.Go PACK
Comment
-
I think he wants to retire before he achieves lichdom.Originally posted by Bossman641 View PostDoes this mean TT will still be the acting GM years after he has passed away?
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_2i6rtCYMKQ...0/davis-zombie</delurk>
Comment
-
Kalil was on KFAN today and was raving about Nick Perry's skills and athletesism.Swede: My expertise in this area is extensive. The essential difference between a "battleship" and an "aircraft carrier" is that an aircraft carrier requires five direct hits to sink, but it takes only four direct hits to sink a battleship.
Comment
-
Ted definitely puts a premium on defensive athleticism which makes a lot of sense. By the nature of offense, being a great athlete isn't nearly as important. The defense doesn't know what's coming, offensive players that can execute can still be successful as all they have to do is impose their will on a defense. Finley isn't much of an athlete, but he runs good routes, explodes out of his cuts, knows how to set a cover-man up to create separation. That's all it takes to get open and gain yards. In general the defensive side of the ball is faster and stronger in the NFL, look at players that are similarly sized on the Packers.Originally posted by Lurker64 View PostTed is actually in the Al Davis GMing tree already. Ron Wolf learned the personnel game from Davis, and TT learned the personnel game from Ron Wolf.
It's sort of a modified Davis approach, since TT's formula is basically "HWS+high character/leadership and throw out guys without actual football ability (for the most part, we all remember Mike Hawkins and Aaron Rouse.)"
It's not just on defense either. Ted drafts people who are unusually athletic at every position. He does not draft people who are short, slow, or small at any position.
Before anybody thinks this is a knock on or weakness of TT, you have to keep in mind that before he got old and crazy and stopped scouting well, Al Davis was quite probably the greatest GM going.70% of the Earth is covered by water. The rest is covered by Al Harris.
Comment
-
I have to disagree with half of your point. I think it is important that offensive players are good athletes, very important in fact (Finley is a good athlete IMO). My theory is that offensive players generally require a much higher level of learned skills to be good. The type of thing you can't learn overnight.Originally posted by 3irty1 View PostTed definitely puts a premium on defensive athleticism which makes a lot of sense. By the nature of offense, being a great athlete isn't nearly as important. The defense doesn't know what's coming, offensive players that can execute can still be successful as all they have to do is impose their will on a defense. Finley isn't much of an athlete, but he runs good routes, explodes out of his cuts, knows how to set a cover-man up to create separation. That's all it takes to get open and gain yards. In general the defensive side of the ball is faster and stronger in the NFL, look at players that are similarly sized on the Packers.
For example, if a WR can't catch the ball nobody cares how fast they are and if they can't catch the ball by the time they are done with college, chances are slim they will ever by any good at it. On the other hand, defensive players need to have good fundamentals, but not necessarily the same level of fine/learned skills as an offensive player. That would make on-the-field production less important for defensive players.
I just made that up, but it sounded good to me.
Comment
-
What did everyone make of Perry's telephone interview at the press conference last night?
He mentioned a desire to play DE, I think he said he gained 10lbs to do so. Is there a transcript of that interview anywhere?--
Imagine for a moment a world without hypothetical situations...
Comment

Comment