OFFICIAL Packers vs Cardinals PLAYOFFS Thread

[Rutnstrut]

Had they went for 2 and not got it, everyone would be bitching that they should have kicked it.

[mraynrand]

Maybe. But I think he has been battling that hamstring he showed this game for most of the second half of the year.

He's battling a worthless NFL body

[pbmax]

Vonnegut.

It does have a Slaughterhouse feel tonight.

[Guiness]

yes. And that is not just revisionist history.

[Harlan Huckleby]

I have a feeling I know what people would be saying if MM had gone for 2 and not made it.

they'd be saying "darn!"

Lots of people called it at the time

[Maxie the Taxi]

Had they went for 2 and not got it, everyone would be bitching that they should have kicked it.

Maybe everyone except me. Damn, I called for it in black and white a few pages earlier. Look it up.

[mraynrand]

I don't think they are. But I do agree with Rand that the offense was going nowhere in the 2nd half. Tough call.

Packers have been terrible in short yardage this year. I doubt their chance of success at a 2 pointer is anywhere near 50%

betterntheir chances in OT. fuck it

[mraynrand]

Maybe everyone except me. Damn, I called for it in black and white a few pages earlier. Look it up.

I called it before Rodgers had the ball down 7. Stubby you spineless fat fuck.

[pbmax]

I have a feeling I know what people would be saying if MM had gone for 2 and not made it.

Yeah.

[Freak Out]

People were going to scream no matter what happened.....but what would you have done as HC?

[beveaux1]

I'm not upset
Arizona is much better

Let me ask the mass this..........had we gone for 2 and not made it....would u be pissed at MM for that ?

It was a no win

Absolutely agree. If Palmer had been sacked on the first play in OT and fumbled, it would have been bedlam. He made an unbelievable play and Fitzgerald made another unbelievable play and they won the game. That's after Rodgers and Janis made an unbelievable play. I think Harlan said that if we won, we would be the worst team ever in a championship game. I don't believe that's true, but I do think it would be one of the worst offenses ever in a championship game. But we do have a great QB, and we do have one of the best coaches in the NFL today. We had to have that in order to even stay in this game.

[Maxie the Taxi]

Absolutely agree. If Palmer had been sacked on the first play in OT and fumbled, it would have been bedlam. He made an unbelievable play and Fitzgerald made another unbelievable play and they won the game. That's after Rodgers and Janis made an unbelievable play. I think Harlan said that if we won, we would be the worst team ever in a championship game. I don't believe that's true, but I do think it would be one of the worst offenses ever in a championship game. But we do have a great QB, and we do have one of the best coaches in the NFL today. We had to have that in order to even stay in this game.

Absolutely disagree. Two many "ifs" in your scenario. Stubby couldn't manage a play clock if he was the CEO of Mattel.

[Harlan Huckleby]

People were going to scream no matter what happened.

Yes, about half the people disagree with any close call.

Stubby's decision was OK, just not what I'd do.

[Joemailman]

People were going to scream no matter what happened.....but what would you have done as HC?

If you're asking me, the thought of going for 2 never occurred to me. I would have kicked it.

[beveaux1]

Absolutely disagree. Two many "ifs" in your scenario. Stubby couldn't manage a play clock if he was the CEO of Mattel.

Only one if.