Remember when..

[George Cumby]

More idiocy and Rodgers derangement syndrome in here from the usual suspects in here.

Always projection with you.

[MadScientist]

More idiocy and Rodgers derangement syndrome in here from the usual suspects in here.

More Rodgers' ball washing from the usual suspect here.

[MadScientist]

Remember when….

We wuz a playoff contender??

Seems like a long time ago.

[Fritz]

I think that unlike Favre, Rodgers does care what his legacy will be in Green Bay after he is done playing. So I wonder if Rodgers would retire or agree to a trade if he became convinced that the majority of fans, players and front office people would rather have Love at QB. Or would his ego prevent him from ever coming to that conclusion? Or would he come back just to prove everybody wrong?

I think you know the answer. He's not going to retire or agree to a trade because he wants to make fans or front office people feel more kindly about his legacy. He's going to come back to prove everybody wrong, as you suggest in that last line.

[Fosco33]

TeamArod here.

He’s never said he was retiring, held a presser while crying and came back 4mo later.
Never sent dick picks. Or cheated on his wife.
Never lied about his drug use.

Y’all are somehow butt hurt about his Covid stance? While almost none of you have gotten this latest booster. Or him wanting to win and being salty years ago?

I hate stupid people and hypocrites.

ARod is neither of those things.

I’ll take a healthy ARod, receivers w/ a year under their belts, etc.

I’d also be fine if he retired or asked for a trade.

It’s just a silly game.

[Joemailman]

TeamArod here.

He’s never said he was retiring, held a presser while crying and came back 4mo later.
Never sent dick picks. Or cheated on his wife.
Never lied about his drug use.

Y’all are somehow butt hurt about his Covid stance? While almost none of you have gotten this latest booster. Or him wanting to win and being salty years ago?

I hate stupid people and hypocrites.

ARod is neither of those things.

I’ll take a healthy ARod, receivers w/ a year under their belts, etc.

I’d also be fine if he retired or asked for a trade.

It’s just a silly game.

What? I don't know of anyone who cares about that. Except for you apparently. I think it's time to move on from Rodgers because the last couple of years in elimination games he hadn't been able to outplay Jimmy Garoppolo and Jared Goff. I see Daniel Jones and Brock Purdy doing things he can't do anymore.

[Fosco33]

Packers averaged 37 points allowed in our last 3 NFCC games.

I’m arguing the amount of vitriol spewed at 12 is ridiculous. The guy has played thru injuries, adapted to a run first mentality, watched the Def get most of the FA and Draft love (see above). He won back/back MVPs and y’all think he’s a diva and trash.

That asinine.

I would love to see him traded for value but don’t see that happening. We’ll know where we stand by early March. Til then it’s all speculation and bullshit.

[oldbutnotdeadyet]

Packers averaged 37 points allowed in our last 3 NFCC games.

I’m arguing the amount of vitriol spewed at 12 is ridiculous. The guy has played thru injuries, adapted to a run first mentality, watched the Def get most of the FA and Draft love (see above). He won back/back MVPs and y’all think he’s a diva and trash.

That asinine.

I would love to see him traded for value but don’t see that happening. We’ll know where we stand by early March. Til then it’s all speculation and bullshit.

Maybe, but it is clear he ain't what he used to be..

[RashanGary]

Maybe, but it is clear he ain't what he used to be..

He could be an MVP again with his new style of play if he had a supporting cast that was more serviceable.

[oldbutnotdeadyet]

He could be an MVP again with his new style of play if he had a supporting cast that was more serviceable.

Isn't that true of just about any QB in the league?

[call_me_ishmael]

It wouldn't shock me if he could put up big stats in the regular season. He has done that a lot. Lots of NBA players can put up big numbers in the regular season. But then the playoffs come along and defenses get tighter and better. Same for the NFL I imagine. When has he last had a great playoff performance? What about carrying a team in a playoff game? I am sorta over the great regular seasons with crappy playoff games thing.

[Joemailman]

It wouldn't shock me if he could put up big stats in the regular season. He has done that a lot. Lots of NBA players can put up big numbers in the regular season. But then the playoffs come along and defenses get tighter and better. Same for the NFL I imagine. When has he last had a great playoff performance? What about carrying a team in a playoff game? I am sorta over the great regular seasons with crappy playoff games thing.

I agree. There's also this to consider which has been the case for a while. Brady being the notable exception:

Andy Herman
@AndyHermanNFL

After Tom Brady is eliminated tonight, here will be the ages of the starting quarterbacks for the remaining 8 playoff teams:

23
23
24
25
26
26
27
29

Dak Prescott will be the oldest remaining quarterback at age 29.

[Fritz]

Packers averaged 37 points allowed in our last 3 NFCC games.

I’m arguing the amount of vitriol spewed at 12 is ridiculous. The guy has played thru injuries, adapted to a run first mentality, watched the Def get most of the FA and Draft love (see above). He won back/back MVPs and y’all think he’s a diva and trash.

That asinine.

I would love to see him traded for value but don’t see that happening. We’ll know where we stand by early March. Til then it’s all speculation and bullshit.

And the vaunted Packer offense, led by #12, averaged 22.3 points per game in those last three NFCC games.

Dude's been pooping the bed in the playoffs for a long time. And that's without counting last year, which was not a NFCC.

[Fosco33]

And the vaunted Packer offense, led by #12, averaged 22.3 points per game in those last three NFCC games.

Dude's been pooping the bed in the playoffs for a long time. And that's without counting last year, which was not a NFCC.

No argument there. Its why they loaded up on RBs and Defense - to win playoff games in Lambeau.

My argument is the amount of shade being directed at one of our best players doesn’t line up with reality.

[King Friday]

My argument is the amount of shade being directed at one of our best players doesn’t line up with reality.

I disagree. The value of the contract he now has comes with a certain level of expected performance. I think most Packers fans would be fine accepting Rodgers as he is if he didn’t hold the team hostage to get a ridiculous contract that precludes the team’s ability to actually surround Rodgers with the talent that he now needs.