How long does Gutey get?

[red]

honest question

love is his pet project. if love looks great, then gutry will go down as a packer legend for drafting him and getting rid of rodgers

but what happens if love sucks this year?

is this a make or break year for gutebag, or does he get a couple years to see if love recovers?

or do we keep him for a few years after his mind and body breakdown and he hasn't been able to do his job for a few seasons?

[Joemailman]

Gute has hitched his wagon to the Love Train. But I think he gets a couple of years. But if 2 years from now Love isn't very good and the Packers are looking at 3 straight losing seasons, it could be over.

[MadtownPacker]

This year and next year maybe a third. That’s the new world.

[red]

i was thinking this year and next, unless love looks really really bad

then the pitchforks will be out midseason

[RashanGary]

I’d give him another shot at a QB

[RashanGary]

I don’t know, I don’t love Gute. I feel like his drafts are just so/so. I don’t mind if we go another direction.

[red]

I don’t know, I don’t love Gute. I feel like his drafts are just so/so. I don’t mind if we go another direction.

thats kind of what got me thinking about it

his drafting isn't all that special, so if his biggest gamble doesn't pay off, do we have any use for him?

i say no

[RashanGary]

thats kind of what got me thinking about it

his drafting isn't all that special, so if his biggest gamble doesn't pay off, do we have any use for him?

i say no

This is pretty much it. I guess there’s a case to be made if last years draft and this years drafts are big hits in the long run. You can make
The case that he’s settled in and got his staff pulling in the right direction.

If these last two drafts are home runs, I wouldn’t mind him staying. But if these guys start falling off like all his other drafts and Love stinks, it’s over. Csnt do much worse.

[Fritz]

This is Guter's sixth draft. He's had some hits - about two a year, maybe three - but last year's class could be good. I'm not sold on the guy. I think we'll get a real read on him now that he doesn't have Rodgers here.

I do think Love is going to be his legacy. If Love turns out to be really good, then Guter's going to be around for a while. If Love turns out to be mediocre, then that pick will define him and I don't think he'll get more than a couple more years after this one.

I also think the Darnell Savage pick was one of his worst. Gave up, what, two fourths to move up? And took a guy who had never developed into a consistent, high-level safety.

So I think his reputation and career are based on how Love turns out. That wouldn't be so if he'd killed his other drafts, but he hasn't. Maybe last year's but the jury is still out. The other drafts show him getting two starters, sometimes three, but outside of Alexander, Gary and maybe Jenkins he hasn't hit any big home runs, I don't think.

[Bretsky]

Look at ALL this round 2 and round 3 picks. Not too improssive IMO

[Fritz]

Outside of Deguara, who isn't exactly a world-beater, Guter has absolutely shit the bed with his third round picks:

2022 Sean Rhyan
2021 Amari Rodgers
2020 Josiah Deguara
2019 Jace Furburger
2018 Oral Burks

Hell, you couldn't man an XFL team with that crew.

[Bretsky]

Outside of Deguara, who isn't exactly a world-beater, Guter has absolutely shit the bed with his third round picks:

2022 Sean Rhyan
2021 Amari Rodgers
2020 Josiah Deguara
2019 Jace Furburger
2018 Oral Burks

Hell, you couldn't man an XFL team with that crew.

Josiah is a nice 6th round draft pick. in round 3 he's a mistake. But he's still our best.

[Freak Out]

If Love and Watson sync up Gute is safe.

[run pMc]

Look at some of the other NFCN GMs. They aren't doing so great either. MIN jettisoned several R2 and R3 picks last year with the new regime. Talk about wasted draft picks.

I think Gute gets this year and next, same as MLF. If Love stinks and they can't at least be competitive they are gone.
Not sure what their contracts are like, but I'd expect that plays into it as well.

[smuggler]

I would think if the team improves from last year, even if Love isn't particularly good, he's fine. If the rest of the team looks bad, he could be in deep doodoo even if Love is good.