How Will J-Love's Career Play Out?

[ThunderDan]

Fair point, they obviously were willing to give him another year unlike Hobbs.

Hobbs was a flaming disaster. Right from the get go when he laid someone out in training camp.

[Joemailman]

HLRNoIPbQAA-v0G?format=jpg&name=4096x4096.jpg

[Anti-Polar Bear]

As a great man once said, don't waste a bunch of money on yokozumas.

No great man would punt off $10K at 1-3 (and some 2-5 PLO) poker within the last 3 months.

Time for another poker break. #failure

[bobblehead]

Its not my job to do Bretsky's job for him. But seriously, he has the team he has and has gone 500. Love is a step above that with the team he has which also includes less than stellar pass pro.

Early I might have taken Burrow over Love; though currently he's banged up enough that I am not certain. I would have been after his Super Bowl appearance.

I like you Pb and I have utmost respect for your football acumen, but if you would take Love over Burrow, pass that shit my way cuz it must be good. Love is made to look better by an elite play caller who prioritizes running the ball to keep a D honest. Burrow managed to take a poor coach to the superbowl.

Burrow is 43-32 as a starter including playoffs. They are 7-16 without him and didn't play playoff games in that sample.

Love is 23-18 and the team is respectively 3-3 without him. and if I recall there was one game where they looked like they were losing until Willis played a quarter and rallied them.

This isn't a knock on Love post, I like him. Its just that if you watch Bengals games its obvious Burrow has better arm talent, better mobility and reads defenses better. I'm not sure Love does anything better than Burrow.

[pbmax]

I like you Pb and I have utmost respect for your football acumen, but if you would take Love over Burrow, pass that shit my way cuz it must be good. Love is made to look better by an elite play caller who prioritizes running the ball to keep a D honest. Burrow managed to take a poor coach to the superbowl.

Burrow is 43-32 as a starter including playoffs. They are 7-16 without him and didn't play playoff games in that sample.

Love is 23-18 and the team is respectively 3-3 without him. and if I recall there was one game where they looked like they were losing until Willis played a quarter and rallied them.

This isn't a knock on Love post, I like him. Its just that if you watch Bengals games its obvious Burrow has better arm talent, better mobility and reads defenses better. I'm not sure Love does anything better than Burrow.

Full health, sure. But he's played a full slate of games 3 times out of six seasons. Missed 6, 7 and 9 games in his career rookie year, fourth year and last year.

[Bretsky]

Fair point, they obviously were willing to give him another year unlike Hobbs.

Given what they did they are pretty much stuck with him for two years. Hopefully he's just an overpaid guard as opposed to a ridiculously overpaid guard

[Bretsky]

OK; when I answered who I'd take over Love I assumed even health.

Given Burrow's injuries an easy argument could be made for Love; but if they are both healthy for a season you undoubtedly take Joe.

And Herbert is going to be find PB Max

[bobblehead]

Full health, sure. But he's played a full slate of games 3 times out of six seasons. Missed 6, 7 and 9 games in his career rookie year, fourth year and last year.

Love has also missed a bevy of games. One of the reasons I said I'd dish him and roll with Willis. However, Burrow probably has PTSD from playing behind that bengals line with 9 run calls a game. Our O-Line is shit, but it ain't Cincinnati shit.