To All Favre Doubters

[mraynrand]

The best way to assess a starting QB is to ONLY watch HIM during games. Magnify everything he does wrong and pay no attention to anything that goes right. Don't watch and/or remember mistakes made by defenders or other players on offense. After a loss, only focus on INTs and poorly thrown balls. Most important: never watch other QBs play an entire game - just watch their highlights on ESPN. Did you see Vince Young run it in against the Colts? Did you see McNabb throw that TD bomb on the run against the Cowboys? Why can't Favre do that? HE SUCKS!

[Rastak]

There wasn't a point, I was just posting NFC QB ratings and they are what they are. I don't write 'em, I just post 'em from NFL.com.

His point was Brad Johnson was a hair better than Brett Favre in QB ratings, and that's fair. Although I'll take a 7 TDs to 5 picks ratio and 56 completion % over a 3 TDs to 4 picks ratio and 60 completion %, but the QB ratings often favor a certain type of throw (high completion % is big). I'm not sure if the Vikings receivers have the drops that the Packers have had. I know Troy Williamson has at times, but Green Bay's drops are up this year. Favre doesn't seem quite as accurate in years past, but they did play a couple of games in windy conditions at Lambeau. I've been to windy games in Lambeau and that means swirling winds and a tough day to throw. Favre hasn't been great, but he hasn't been awful. It would help if they cut down on the drops and had a better running game, but he can't complain about protection--because that has been solid.

Marcus Robinson dropped a friggen sure 40-50 yard TD against Buffalo, right in his damn hands. Viking recievers have a had a BUNCH of drops, but Johnson has also beed inacurate at times.

[woodbuck27]

FLAT OUT !!!

I am certain that at this point and given the way OUR TEAM has looked in five games...

BRETT FAVRE IS OUR BEST PLAYER OVERALL and BEST and ONLY REAL CHANCE OF WINNING FOOTBALL GAMES.

END OF STORY.

[Fosco33]

The best way to assess a starting QB is to ONLY watch HIM during games. Magnify everything he does wrong and pay no attention to anything that goes right. Don't watch and/or remember mistakes made by defenders or other players on offense. After a loss, only focus on INTs and poorly thrown balls. Most important: never watch other QBs play an entire game - just watch their highlights on ESPN. Did you see Vince Young run it in against the Colts? Did you see McNabb throw that TD bomb on the run against the Cowboys? Why can't Favre do that? HE SUCKS!

Classic

I was at a national conference this week and made many coworkers feel retarded b/c they believed ESPN and the national media.

[woodbuck27]

The best way to assess a starting QB is to ONLY watch HIM during games. Magnify everything he does wrong and pay no attention to anything that goes right. Don't watch and/or remember mistakes made by defenders or other players on offense. After a loss, only focus on INTs and poorly thrown balls. Most important: never watch other QBs play an entire game - just watch their highlights on ESPN. Did you see Vince Young run it in against the Colts? Did you see McNabb throw that TD bomb on the run against the Cowboys? Why can't Favre do that? HE SUCKS!

Oooo Kaaa !