Would Sherman have drafted Hawk at #5?

[MadtownPacker]

I was thinking about this. Remember Sherman never had a higher picker then #20, walker I believe. Would he have picked Hawk this past weekend?
I have to say no, he would have went with someone else. Who though?

[MJZiggy]

Davis or a wideout. Maybe a guard. Hee Hee.

[Deputy Nutz]

He would have gone with Davis. Probably would have traded up to get him.

[Guiness]

Ok, it's fun to speculate...

Since NO was a willing dance partner, he would've sent them the #5, our second rounder, JW and next year's first round pick for the #2. Sound about right?

[Scott Campbell]

Re: Would Sherman have drafted Hawk at #5?

I was thinking about this. Remember Sherman never had a higher picker then #20, walker I believe. Would he have picked Hawk this past weekend?
I have to say no, he would have went with someone else. Who though?

Sherman would have traded Walker, the #5, and a 3rd rounder for the number 1 pick in the draft.

And yes, he then would have drafted Hawk.

[Pack0514]

He would have gone with Davis. Probably would have traded up to get him.

hilarious!

[ND72]

he would have drafted Hawk. Sherman, year in and year out, drafted based on need, and LB was our greatest need position.

[Anti-Polar Bear]

Sherman the great would trade the 5th overall pick, Walker (assuming that he remained disgruntled even under Sherman, which is unlikely because Sherman would've extended Walker's contract after he made the Pro Bowl) , a 4th rd pick and a 07 conditional pick to Oakland for Moss and the 7th overall pick.

Sherman would draft Michael Huff.

[ND72]

even sherman wasn't that retarded.

[Anti-Polar Bear]

even sherman wasn't that retarded.

The only one retarded is thompson, who had the opportunty to do what I just wrote and did not.

I mean, Moss would not only help Favre and the Packers win the SB this year, he'd make Rodgers look like Tom Brady for years to come. All Rodgers would have to do is toss the ball up and Moss would do the rest.

Huff would do more for the Pack than Hawk.

[MJZiggy]

Sherman the great would trade the 5th overall pick, Walker (assuming that he remained disgruntled even under Sherman, which is unlikely because Sherman would've extended Walker's contract after he made the Pro Bowl) , a 4th rd pick and a 07 conditional pick to Oakland for Moss and the 7th overall pick.

Sherman would draft Michael Huff.

Javon Walker made the pro bowl in 2004. Sherman the Great had plenty of time to extend his contract before Thompson took over a year later and he didn't do it. Find me the article or scrap of information that tells me the Oakland would have wanted to move up in the draft because all indications I've seen point to the fact that they had no reason to trade with us--Maybe with Tennessee, but not with us. Now Pay UP.

[Anti-Polar Bear]

Sherman the great would trade the 5th overall pick, Walker (assuming that he remained disgruntled even under Sherman, which is unlikely because Sherman would've extended Walker's contract after he made the Pro Bowl) , a 4th rd pick and a 07 conditional pick to Oakland for Moss and the 7th overall pick.

Sherman would draft Michael Huff.

Javon Walker made the pro bowl in 2004. Sherman the Great had plenty of time to extend his contract before Thompson took over a year later and he didn't do it. Find me the article or scrap of information that tells me the Oakland would have wanted to move up in the draft because all indications I've seen point to the fact that they had no reason to trade with us--Maybe with Tennessee, but not with us. Now Pay UP.

What are you taking about? Walker made the Pro Bowl the same year Bob Harlan lost his mind and demoted Sherman. Pack were $9-11 M over coming into the 05 season, which means Sherman would've to take care of Wahle and Sharper's contracts first (Cut Wahle, and then immediately sign him to a new contract; extend or restructure Sharper's contract). If Sherman can "overpaid" Diggs and KGB in the same off-season with around only $3M of cap space, no reason he couldnt do what i stated.

Acquiring the #5 from the Pack would give Oakland more power to move up to the 2nd spot to get Vince Young. I am sure Al Davis was praying Young fell to him at #7, as some draft expert predicted; but also knew that Tenn was high on Young.

[MJZiggy]

You're right about the year. Oops. How are you going to get Mike Wahle to sign the contract after you cut him?

[Anti-Polar Bear]

You're right about the year. Oops. How are you going to get Mike Wahle to sign the contract after you cut him?

Hand Wahle a $12 M SB. That or wait til Carolina come into the picture and then outbid them.

[Anti-Polar Bear]

Here's what the top 5 picks would look like had Pack traded for Moss and Oak in turn trade the pick they got from Pack to NO for the 2nd Pick:

1. Hou Williams
2. Oak Young
3. Tenn Lienart
4. NYJ Bush
5. NO Hawk